Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Trump-Appointed Judge Rules That College Professor Has The Right To Insult Trans Students In Class

Trump-Appointed Judge Rules That College Professor Has The Right To Insult Trans Students In Class
Notre Dame Constitutional Studies Minor/YouTube
Make us preferred on Google

Amul Thapar, a Federal Appeals Court judge appointed by former President Donald Trump, was among a panel of judges who ruled a decision to allow a college professor to invoke their First Amendment right to intentionally insult trans students in the classroom through misgendering.

The panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in the Meriwether v. Hartop ruling included Thapar; Joan Larsen, another Trump appointee; and David McKeague, who was appointed by George W. Bush.


In 2016, Shawnee State University in Ohio implemented a policy requiring professors to address transgender students by their preferred pronouns.

Nicholas Meriwether, a philosophy professor at the university, rejected the policy and refused to "recognize transgenderism."

Two years later, Meriwether claimed he inadvertently misgendered a trans woman in class, citing that "no one would have assumed" she was "female."

According to Mark Joseph Stern's legal analysis for Slate, the misgendered student, Alena Bruening, later demanded for Meriwether to recognize her as a woman.

The professor refused and debated gender identity with her and remained obstinate about addressing her by her last name.

Bruening responded by saying:

"Then I guess this means I can call you a c*nt."

@toomanyskulls/Twitter

When Bruening reported the incident, the dean offered a compromise to eliminate all gendered language from the classroom. However, Meriwether strongly opposed and chose to address all students as "Mr." or "Ms." while referring to Bruening only by her surname.

This resulted in the university launching a Title IX investigation, in which Meriwther was given a written warning for violating the university's nondiscrimination policy.

Title IX is a federal civil rights law passed as part of the Education Amendments of 1972 that prohibits sex-based discrimination in schools.

Meriwether countered the disciplinary act with a lawsuit against the university, alleging a violation of rights to free speech and free exercise under the First Amendment, but a federal judge tossed his suit.

In a grievance process, Meriwether said:

"I am a Christian. As such, it is my sincerely held religious belief, based on the Bible's teachings, that God created human beings as either male or female, that this gender is fixed in each person from the moment of conception, and that it cannot be changed."

The school, however, is not religiously affiliated.

Meriwether was represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, a powerful anti-LGBTQ+ law firm known for attacking LGBTQ+ people in court.

Thapar revived Meriwether's previously tossed suit and argued the professor's refusal to comply with the use of preferred pronouns for transgender students qualified as a constitutional protection because it involves "a hotly contested matter of public concern."

Thapar wrote in the decision:

"If professors lacked free-speech protections when teaching, a university would wield alarming power to compel ideological conformity."


You can watch a video of Thapar in the "Notre Dame Constitutional Studies Conversations: Judges Amy Barrett and Amul Thapar" discussion that took place on March 28, 2019, at the University of Notre Dame.

youtu.be

In Stern's legal analysis for Slate, he wrote:

"It was inevitable that a Trump judge like Thapar would undercut transgender rights."
"But the logic of Meriwether v. Hartop does not stop with preferred pronouns. Under Thapar's reasoning, professors have a constitutional right to use racial epithets in class, to use misogynistic language in front of students, to express all manner of odious views in a maximally offensive manner."
"They would not have to worry about creating a hostile environment in violation of civil rights law."

Stern continued:

"If disciplined, they could simply assert their First Amendment rights to speak about a 'matter of public concern' however they please. (With one exception: Presumably, any speech critical of religion would remain off-limits, since such expression apparently violates others' religious liberty.)"

According to a report from LGBTQ+ civil rights group Lambda Legal, nearly 40% of former President Donald Trump's confirmed federal appellate judges have a demonstrated history of anti-LGBTQ+ bias—including opposing same-sex marriage and supporting the implementation of the transgender military ban.

Lambda Legal CEO Kevin Jennings said in a statement:

"While Donald Trump's presidency may be coming to end, his devastating impact on our federal courts will take decades to reverse."
"When the basic human rights of LGBTQ+ Americans are so often challenged in court, we cannot accept a judiciary stacked with judges who would disenfranchise these vulnerable groups."

More from News/lgbtq

Screenshot of Ron DeSantis
Straight Shooter with Stephen A. Podcast

Ron DeSantis Just Ripped Republicans Who Claim That High Gas Prices Are 'No Big Deal'

On the eve of the midterm elections, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis surprised observers by criticizing Republicans who've downplayed the impact high gas prices have had on the electorate.

Americans continue to struggle with a nationwide affordability crisis hurting their wallets as well as at the pump. Because of the war President Donald Trump began with Iran earlier this year—and the continued blockade in the Strait of Hormuz—the global oil supply has been limited, causing a surge in prices.

Keep ReadingShow less
Abdul El-Sayed; JD Vance
Salwan Georges/Getty Images; Saul Loeb-Pool/Getty Images)

Victorious Abdul El-Sayed Points Out The 'Delicious Irony' Of What JD Vance Will Have To Do—And It's Too Good

After his historic defeat of Michigan Republican Mike Rogers in the state's U.S. Senate race, Democrat Abdul El-Sayed had observers cackling after he reminded his crowd of supporters that Vice President JD Vance will now have to swear him in.

It was a triumphant moment for El-Sayed, particularly after Vance had mispronounced his name at a rally on Friday at an Ohio steel plant before accusing him of arguing that "criticisms of Sharia law were rooted in white supremacy."

Keep ReadingShow less
Amy Poehler
ANGELA WEISS/AFP/Getty Images

Amy Poehler Sparks Debate After Claiming She Was Forced To Leave 'SNL' After Giving Birth Despite Wanting To Return

It might be late 2026, but there are still plenty of women who find their work compromised, if not taken away entirely, when they decide to become moms.

With women facing unpaid maternity leave, their jobs being taken away while they're on leave, or their hours or pay being reduced after they give birth, new moms are losing work opportunities all the time.

Keep ReadingShow less

French Actor Léa Seydoux's Disgusted Reaction To Nearly Every Food Item In Tasting Interview Has The Internet Cackling

Remember being forced to try a food you already knew you weren't going to like? Maybe you took a tiny bite just to be polite, smiled through the disappointment, and quietly vowed never to eat it again.

Well, French actor Léa Seydoux wasn't about to pretend her taste buds approved during an Elle UK food-tasting interview, and the internet is having an absolute field day with her reactions.

Keep ReadingShow less
P!nk
Theo Wargo/Tony Awards Productions/Getty Images

P!nk Responds After Photo Of Her Without Makeup Sparks Cruel Looks-Shaming Comments

P!nk has come under fire lately for her controversial and divisive political views, prompting many people to respond cruelly to just about any post concerning her.

So when the 47-year-old Grammy winner was recently photographed in New York City without makeup on, the internet trolls were the loudest commenters to show up. Shared by Page Six, the candid photo showed the singer without makeup, wearing a purple sweatsuit and brown and white headwrap, and carrying her small dog in a cream crossbody bag.

Keep ReadingShow less