Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Sotomayor Shuts Down Lawyer Who Claims Overturning Abortion Rights Won't Put LGBTQ Rights In Danger

Sotomayor Shuts Down Lawyer Who Claims Overturning Abortion Rights Won't Put LGBTQ Rights In Danger
Paul Marotta/Getty Images

The United States Supreme Court (SCOTUS) heard arguments in the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which challenges Mississippi's recently passed ban on abortions after only 15 weeks of gestation. The law violates Roe v. Wade, a historic SCOTUS decision that protected the right to abort a fetus until it is viable outside the womb.

By bringing this case before the Supreme Court, Mississippi is essentially asking the Court to overturn its own decision on abortion rights.


During arguments, Justice Sotomayor cited both Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey—which reaffirmed Roe—noting overturning those decisions would impinge on Americans' right to privacy.

While the United States Constitution does not explicitly guarantee privacy, several Supreme Court decisions have interpreted it to do so implicitly. Several cases since Roe have also determined the government has to respect citizens' rights to make their own choices, especially when it involves personal, moral decisions that do not affect others—like abortion.

Justice Sotomayor noted overturning the Court's landmark decision in Roe v. Wade would open an opportunity to challenge other rights gained because of SCOTUS decisions, such as rights for LGBTQ+ individuals.

She noted the Court has:

"recognized them in terms of the religion parents will teach their children."
"We’ve recognized it in their ability to educate at home if they choose…."
"We have recognized that sense of privacy in people’s choices about whether to use contraception or not."
"We’ve recognized it in their right to choose who they’re going to marry."

After Sotomayor spoke, conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett asked Scott Stewart, Mississippi's Solicitor General who was defending his state's anti-abortion law, whether the court deciding in favor of the law would affect the cases noted by Justice Sotomayor.

Stewart claimed they would not, because those cases had:

"clear rules that have engendered strong reliance interests and that have not produced negative consequences or all the many other negative stare decisis considerations we pointed out."

Stewart essentially claimed decisions decriminalizing gay sex and guaranteeing access to contraceptives haven't had a negative impact like Roe's guaranteed access to abortion has.

This answer prompted Justice Sotomayor to tersely challenge Stewart's words, telling him:

"I just think you’re dissimulating when you say that any ruling here wouldn’t have an effect on those."


There are plenty of people who rely on access to abortion, and there are also plenty of people who would claim gay sex, contraceptives and abortion are all harmful in an attempt to overturn their legality.

Twitter users seemed to largely agree as well.













Lambda Legal's Sharon McGowen seems to agree with Justice Sotomayor as well, telling Bloomberg hard-won victories like Lawrence v. Texas—which legalized gay sex in all states—and Obergefell v. Hodges—which legalized marriage equality:

"were built on the foundation of Roe and Casey and the Court’s other reproductive rights cases."

More from Trending

Matt Rife
Taylor Hill/Getty Images

Makeup Brand Sparks Further Backlash With Statement About Using Comedian Matt Rife In Ad

Content warning: domestic violence, joking about domestic violence

E.l.f. Cosmetics faced serious backlash across all social media platforms just days ago when they decided to hire Matt Rife, who has a history of telling "dark humor" jokes that promote sexism and domestic violence.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tim Walz; Donald Trump
Tibrina Hobson/Getty Images; Contributor/Getty Images

Tim Walz's Viral Reaction To Trump's Planned Audit Of Smithsonian Museum Exhibitions Is Spot On

On August 12, the administration of MAGA Republican President Donald Trump sent a letter to the Honorable Lonnie G. Bunch III, Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution.

The letter said:

Keep ReadingShow less
Jennifer Lawrence handing Emma Stone her oscar with Michel
Kevin Winter / Staff/Getty Images

Jennifer Lawrence Reveals Emma Stone's Candid Bathroom Confession After Winning Her 2nd Oscar

In 2024, Emma Stone earned her second Academy Award for Best Actress for her memorable performance in Poor Things.

A considerable accomplishment, as she became one of only 15 actors to win in that category multiple times, joining such acting legends as Katherine Hepburn, Frances McDormand and Meryl Streep.

Keep ReadingShow less
Halle Berry Hilariously Trolls Ex-Husband After His Comments About Her Not Being 'Motherly'
Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for Joylux & Playground; Paul Archuleta/Getty Images

Halle Berry Hilariously Trolls Ex-Husband After His Comments About Her Not Being 'Motherly'

Halle Berry's ex-husband, former MLB star David Justice, recently had a lot to say about why he divorced her back in the '90s—and Berry is giving it right back.

Justice sparked quite a bit of controversy online last week when he told the host of podcast All the Smoke that he divorced Berry because she wasn't "motherly" enough and didn't cook or clean to his liking at the time.

Keep ReadingShow less
Jennifer Welch
@ivehaditpodcast/YouTube

Podcast Host Goes On NSFW Rant About 'Triple Trump' Voters—And It's Truly A Must-See

Oklahoma based interior designer, former Bravolebrity, and podcast host Jennifer Welch had some harsh words for White voters who supported Donald Trump in 2016, 2020, and 2024.

The designer gained national attention after being featured on the Bravo show Sweet Home Oklahoma—retitled just Sweet Home for season two—in 2017. Welch now hosts the I've Had It podcast alongside her Sweet Home costar Angie "Pumps" Sullivan.

Keep ReadingShow less