Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Brilliant Ideas That Were Poorly Executed

Pile of recycling
sprite plastic bottle on table
Photo by Nick Fewings on Unsplash

Reddit user thespacecowboyy asked: 'What was a brilliant idea but poorly executed?'

The key to being a successful entrepreneur is having one brilliant idea.

A catalyst to spark inspiration and creativity, something you know that everyone in the world will want, that corporations will try to buy, and competitors will try to mimic.

Of course, the other key to being a successful entrepreneur is having that idea successfully executed.

No matter how brilliant your idea was, if it falls short on execution even the tiniest bit, then its chances of success are all but doomed to failure.


Redditor thespacecowboyy was curious to hear all the inventions and concepts that might have been triumphant were it not for their poor execution, leading them to ask:
"What was a brilliant idea but poorly executed?"

$10 A Month For $4 Thousand Worth Of Movie Tickets... How Could It Go Wrong?

"Moviepass, i.e. a monthly subscription service to see as many movies as you want for a flat fee."

"The core concept is actually solid."

"The big risk with unlimited subscriptions is induced demand, where people consume more of your product because their unit price drops."

"Movie theaters are mostly fixed costs, however, they don't really care about induced demand outside of opening weekend for big blockbusters (which you can make special rules about)."

"As long as a movie isn't sold out, you'd basically take any amount of money for the empty seats."

"Even if someone sees ten movies in a month, you're still probably making money even if you only charged them two movie's worth, and that's before potential concession sales."

"That said, the theaters have to be on board, and Moviepass launched without first getting them to agree to such a system."

"Instead, Moviepass had to pay full price to the theaters for every single movie seen."

"Their prices were not fixed, and as a result the induced demand absolutely crushed them."- Notmiefault

Microsoft Clearly Didn't Read The Book Of Genesis...

"Microsoft Zune."- TheDadaMax

"Great product, poorly marketed."

"But it was (imo) vastly superior to the iPod."- EnigmaCA

technology rip GIF by gifnewsGiphy

So, So, Sad...

"Recycling."

"I wish it was great everywhere."- Glitchykins8

Biking Without The Peddling

"The Segway."

"It was hailed as what the car was to the horse and buggy."

"Built by a famous inventor it never took off."

"One of the most hyped inventions of all time."- Swimming_Stop5723

Way Too Soon... (On So Many Levels)

"Selling tickets to dive in a sub to see the Titanic."- nullrecord

Titan Submarine GIF by GIPHY NewsGiphy

Not The Right Prescription

"Google Glass."

"I remember when people were talking about how it was gonna be the next 'big thing' and it failed."- LouisTheFox

When You Can't Help But Miss Used Car Salesmen...

"Carvana."

"Loved the idea of putting more control of the car-buying experience back in the hands of the buyer but myself and my wife both had a harrowing experience buying through them and their 'hassle-free' return process was absolutely riddled with hassles."- Grand-wazoo

Yeah...

"Public transit in the United States."- takescoffeeblack

train help GIFGiphy

It Literally Had People Seeing Red...

"Nintendo's Virtual Boy."- TailsxCream4Eva

"Nintendo's Power Glove."- mezz7778

"RoB the Robot."- DiscussionLoose8390

One Of Many Failed Ideas In US Education

"I think No Child Left Behind was a good concept."

"But basing school funding on standardized tests just crushed anything good out of it— the rich schools with funding for equipment and higher-end teachers got more money, and the schools that needed financial help got probation and threats of funding withdrawal."

"As a former teacher, I loved the idea that a kid could move to another school mid-semester and be learning the same concept in each subject as the school they left, but instead any kid who wasn’t immediately grasping concepts was forced to fail upwards."

"Failing upwards hurts all of us."- bp_516

Ha!

"Fyre Festival."- Old_Army90

"I’ve always thought that it could have worked if it had been planned years in advance."

"I have to admit, the idea of a music festival on a Caribbean island still intrigues me."

"The problem is that the island location alone presents major logistical hurdles."

"By definition, everything on an island is harder to acquire, from food to land."

"Add to that the issues of promised catered meals and guaranteed luxury lodging and you have serious mountains to climb to pull off the festival."

"With enough lead time to construct the bungalows and hire enough food services to prepare the meals, it is feasible, but trying to pull it off in a few months time made it impossible."

"Sure, Woodstock ‘69 was planned in less than a year, but festival attendees weren’t promised lodging and food."

"They knew they’d be camping and would have to get their own provisions."

"Even then, there were logistical hurdles, such as the New York State Thruway succumbing to complete gridlock."

"Still, as far as festivals go, it was a relatively simple set-up."

"A better approach would have been for Fyre, the music booking app company behind the festival, to start small, such as on a beach somewhere with no inclusion of lodging or catering in the ticket packages."

"Concertgoers would know what to expect, and the festival would have been a lot more successful."

"If Fyre had done that for a few years, they would have built trust in their name brand, so when the time came for an actual festival on an island, Fyre Festival could have booked enough contractors to build lodging and hired enough vendors to make food for the whole weekend."

"Unfortunately, Billy McFarland’s hubris was enough that he wanted to skip ahead of the build up and go straight for the opulent."- Brunt-FCA-285

ja rule fyre festival GIFGiphy

More Like Great Leap Backwards...

"China's Great Leap Forward."

"The idea was to improve the country, but it ended with one of the worst man-made natural disasters in history."- Kartoffelkamm

While a good idea always requires imagination, we must also remember it's very easy for our imaginations to get the better of us.

Reality often has a way of bringing us back down to Earth and making us realize what looks good on paper doesn't always deliver.

(But seriously... who actually thought the Fyre Festival was going to work?)

More from Trending/best-of-reddit

Karoline Leavitt and Scott Bessent
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

Karoline Leavitt Dragged After Making Mind-Numbing Claim About Trump's Tariffs Reversal

White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt is getting called out after she attempted to justify President Donald Trump's sudden reversal on his proposed tariffs, telling reporters that his actions make sense because he has a master plan to make the world bend the knee.

Trump declared a full 90-day suspension of all the “reciprocal” tariffs that took effect at midnight April 10—except for those on China—in a dramatic about-face from a president who had long championed his historically high tariff rates as permanent.

Keep ReadingShow less
religion signs
Noah Holm on Unsplash

People Explain What Stopped Them From Going To Church Anymore

There's been a perception of a bit of an exodus from religion for the last several decades. But humanity has gone from no organized religions to oppressive religious regimes to rebellion and back again over the last several millennia.

But is the 21st century when religion finally fails to bounce back?

Keep ReadingShow less
Jojo Siwa; Mickey Rourke
ITV

Mickey Rourke Reprimanded After Indirectly Aiming Anti-Gay Slur At JoJo Siwa On 'Celebrity Big Brother'

Dance Moms dancer, Nickelodeon child star, singer, and reality TV staple Jojo Siwa had a rough few months in 2024 over some problematic comments and behavior.

But 2025 is looking brighter as the public rallies to her defense.

Keep ReadingShow less
Barack and Michelle Obama
Scott Olson/Getty Images

Michelle Obama Expertly Shuts Down Baseless Rumors That She And Barack Are Divorcing

Speaking on Sophia Bush's Work in Progress podcast, former First Lady Michelle Obama addressed rumors that she and her husband, former President Barack Obama, were getting a divorce.

Obama addressed the recent divorce rumors for the first time, while also reflecting on the personal choices she’s made since departing the White House in 2017.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kristi Noem
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

Kristi Noem Ripped Over Her Lack Of Gun-Handling Skills While Cosplaying As ICE Agent

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem was criticized after she had an ICE officer seemingly dodging her aim after she pointed a gun towards his head while filming a video.

In a 20-second video posted to X on Tuesday, Kristi Noem stands flanked by two Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers, brandishing a gun. Wearing a vest marked "ICE," along with dark cargo pants and a cap, Noem addresses the camera while the two agents remain silent beside her—though some X users expressed concern for the safety of one of them.

Keep ReadingShow less