Last week, in a joint press conference with President Joe Biden, Justice Stephen Breyer officially announced his intention to retire from the Supreme Court.
The announcement revived a moment from the 2020 campaign trail in which then-candidate Biden vowed to nominate the first Black woman ever to sit on the nation's highest Court.
At the joint presser, Biden announced that he intends to make good on that promise, saying:
“While I've been studying candidates' backgrounds and writings, I've made no decisions except one: The person I will nominate will be someone with extraordinary qualifications, character, experience, and integrity, and that person will be the first Black woman ever nominated to the United States Supreme Court.”
Though Biden hasn't yet named a nominee, conservatives have decried Biden's commitment to appoint a Black woman. Under the apparent assumption that a Black woman wouldn't be the most qualified for the job, they've claimed Biden is solely considering candidates' race and gender in making his decision, despite the many qualified Black women jurists suitable to serve on the Supreme Court.
Far-right Senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas, however, vowed that Republican Senators wouldn't launch a "smear campaign" against whomever the nominee ends up being.
January 30, 2022: Senator Cotton Joins Fox News Sunday with Dana Perinoyoutu.be
In a Fox News Sunday interview with Dana Perino, Cotton reminisced on Trump's contentious 2018 nomination of now-Justice Brett Kavanaugh to replace Justice Anthony Kennedy on the Court. Kavanaugh was credibly accused of sexual assault, which spurred additional Senate Judiciary Committee hearings of both Kavanaugh, and his accuser, Dr. Christine Blasey-Ford. Kavanaugh was eventually confirmed to the Court, after which it was discovered that the FBI's investigation of the claims was insufficient.
When asked how Republicans would approach Biden's eventual nominee, Cotton responded:
"I suspect we'll all keep an open mind, we will review the nominee on her merits. ... I can say one thing that I won't do, and I doubt any Republican will do, is engage in the kind of grotesque smear campaigns against the character of fine men like Clarence Thomas or as we saw what happened with Brett Kavanaugh two years ago. ... We're not gonna do what Democrats do, which is simply make up smears against a nominee."
People were highly skeptical of his comments.
When did vetting a lifetime appointment to SCOTUS become a “grotesque smear campaign”?
Sen. Cotton says Republicans won’t launch ‘grotesque smear campaigns’ against SCOTUS nominee like Dems did https://t.co/ZquOiHJwfo
— Greg Scott (@GregScott04) January 31, 2022
Lol. So they won’t do it this time…what changed
Sen. Cotton says Republicans won’t launch ‘grotesque smear campaigns’ against SCOTUS nominee like... https://t.co/JY6UPcdio9 via @Yahoo
— Tange (@Tange14764308) January 31, 2022
I too have a bridge to sell you
— America, you're in danger girl (@OverUnderClover) January 30, 2022
Too many mediocre men have too large of a microphone and Sen. Cotton is one of them.
— Kristi (@WhyKelly2) January 30, 2022
That's literally all Republicans do. https://t.co/xbal0d7r5L
— Matt Murphy (@MattMurph24) January 30, 2022
Rs also said they wouldn't start a riot if Trump lost 2020 either https://t.co/Z6ANSjRgsX
— ᕙ(⇀‸↼‶)ᕗ (@NtRdytoMkNice) January 31, 2022
Others claimed Republicans have already launched a smear campaign of sorts before even knowing who the nominee is.
Right. Because they're already disqualifying the candidate as an "affirmative action" hire who's being considered based on race rather than qualifications. Nice try @SenTomCotton
https://t.co/im23eIYILu
— SitBacknLaugh 🇺🇲 (@ItsAllLaughable) January 30, 2022
Too late. His Republican Senate colleague Roger Wicker has already smeared any nominee who is a Black woman -- before anyone has even been nominated.
Note too his comment about "fine men."
— David Lapan (@DaveLapanDC) January 30, 2022
They've already started.
— Rick the Resister 🌊 (@RickyResister11) January 30, 2022
We'll see how well his comments end up aging.