Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Sonia Sotomayor Has Dire Warning After Supreme Court's Latest Church State Separation Decision

Sonia Sotomayor Has Dire Warning After Supreme Court's Latest Church State Separation Decision
ERIN SCHAFF/POOL/AFP via Getty Images

Left-leaning Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor's opinion in a recent SCOTUS ruling pertaining to the separation of church and state has left many feeling nervous after it included a sobering warning about the increasingly far-right moves of the Court.

In her dissenting opinion on Carson v. Makin, which mandates government funding for religious schools, Sotomayor called the Court's decision a "perverse" and unconstitutional violation of church/state separation.


And she made clear she is deeply disturbed by the Court's rightward lurch in recent years, expressing her "growing concern about where this Court will lead us next."

The conservative-leaning court came to a 6-3 decision on Carson v. Makin in favor of parents who sued the state of Maine to compel it to provide public education funding for religious schools in certain instances.

The state of Maine had refused to provide the funding, citing First Amendment rights. But the Court's conservative Justices argued that Maine's refusal violated parents' rights to free exercise of religion.

Calling that take on things "especially perverse," Sotomayor pointedly countered in her dissenting opinion that the Constitution expressly forbids public education from being tied to religion. She wrote:

"As this Court has long recognized, the Establishment Clause requires that public education be secular and neutral as to religion..."
"...Nothing in the Constitution requires today’s result."

Adding to the controversy is that the two specific religious schools involved in the case, Bangor Christian and Temple Academy, have implemented policies that refuse admission to LGBTQ students. Sotomayor called out this hypocrisy in her opinion, too:

"...[W]hile purporting to protect against discrimination of one kind, the Court requires Maine to fund what many of its citizens believe to be discrimination of other kinds."

Sotomayor went on to detail the domino effect of the Court's unconstitutional decision:

"Today, the Court leads us to a place where separation of church and state becomes a constitutional violation.
"If a State cannot offer subsidies to its citizens without being required to fund religious exercise, any State that values its historic antiestablishment interests more than this Court does will have to curtail the support it offers to its citizens."

And referencing a similar 2017 decision, she sounded an alarm in no uncertain terms about the disturbing direction in which decisions like these steer the country.

"...In just a few years, the Court has upended constitutional doctrine, shifting from a rule that permits States to decline to fund religious organizations to one that requires States in many circumstances to subsidize religious indoctrination with taxpayer dollars."

On Twitter, many were deeply disturbed by the outcome of the case and by Sotomayor's warnings about it.










Far-right and religious conservatives have long sought to overturn previous Supreme Court decisions that made religious teaching, Bible study and prayer in public schools unconstitutional. Conservatives frequently blame such bans for all of society's ills.

After yesterday's decision and another forthcoming in a case pertaining to a former high school football coach who was fired for praying with student athletes before games, it seems the far-right is getting ever closer to the theocracy they've been fighting for.

More from News

Screenshots of Will Thilly breakdancing
New York Post/YouTube

Guy Breakdances His Way Into Town Hall Meeting To Ask Why Taxes Went Up—And Becomes An Instant Legend

Cranford, New Jersey town council candidate Will Thilly went viral after dancing his way up to the podium at a recent town hall meeting to ask why property taxes in Cranford have gone "up so much."

Thilly's unique tax protest began when he danced his way up to the podium and continued to dance even after a Cranford Township official said, "Mr. Thilly, I started your time." People laughed when Thilly held up a finger to stop the official and continued to dance anyway.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Brian Kilmeade
Fox News

Fox News Host Apologizes After His Suggestion That Homeless People Be Euthanized Sparks Outrage

Fox and Friends host Brian Kilmeade was criticized for suggesting that homeless people with mental health issues get "involuntary lethal injection" after the murder of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska on a train in North Carolina—and was swiftly condemned for an insincere apology several days after the fact as many are calling for Fox News to terminate his contract.

Zarutska was stabbed to death at the East/West Boulevard station on the Lynx Blue Line in Charlotte last month; her killer, a homeless man with a history of mental health issues, has since been charged with first-degree murder.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sofía Vergara
Bryan Steffy/Getty Images

Sofía Vergara Reveals She Missed Presenting At The Emmys Due To 'Craziest' Medical Emergency

Almost everyone has a favorite television show they like to turn on at the end of a rough day or binge-watch for a bit of nostalgia, and most of us pretty frequently check out new shows to see if we can spot a favorite.

Needless to say, the Emmys award show is a huge deal every year, honoring all of the people involved in the projects that are currently gracing the small screen, and basically anyone who's anyone will attend.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rep. Nancy Mace
CNN

Nancy Mace Just Tried To Claim She's Never 'Dehumanized' Her Colleagues—And The Internet Brought The Receipts

South Carolina Republican Representative Nancy Mace was called out for hypocrisy after she claimed on CNN that Democrats in Congress have been "dehumanizing" Republicans, a move she would "never" do—despite her record of doing just that.

Speaking to anchor Katie Bolduan while the search for the suspect who killed far-right activist Charlie Kirk was ongoing, Mace objected to Bolduan's observation that she was using "us v. them" language, only saying that things are "very one-sided right now." She also suggested that the situation is so bad for her that she's actually afraid of "just walking out in public."

Keep ReadingShow less
A younger man stand on top of a mountain with his arms outreached and his face looking to the sky. It's a beautiful day and lakes and mountains are the backdrop.
Photo by Kyle Loftus on Unsplash

People Who Quit Their High-Paying Jobs For Happiness Explain How It Turned Out

Sometimes money isn't the goal.

It is a BIG goal for many.

Keep ReadingShow less