A mathematics professor at Oakland, California's Laney College was placed on leave after a chain of email between him and an Asian American student went viral.
The emails—in which the professor pointedly and repeatedly insists the student "anglicize" her name—drew wide criticism and accusations of xenophobia and racism.
The student's sister shared screenshots of some of the professor's emails on Instagram.
The Laney College professor, Matthew Hubbard, insisted Vietnamese American student Phuc Bui Diem Nguyen change her name.
He claimed it "sounds" like a vulgar insult in "his language."
Laney College professor Matthew Hubbard is asking a Vietnamese student to “Anglicize" her name to accommodate him. pic.twitter.com/0CulBh49Jb
— karly (@aybarlyy) June 18, 2020
A second Instagram post was added with video captioned:
"Update: he now refers to her as P Nguyen. I wanna know why he can't just ask my sister how to pronounce her name"
Dion Lim of San Francisco ABC7 News shared coverage of the professor's actions on Twitter.
She included a screenshot of the email and a response from Laney College.
EXCLUSIVE: “I was shook."
Vietnamese American Laney College freshman Phuc Bui talks about what it was like when her teacher sent her an email asking her to “Anglicize" her name. pic.twitter.com/nUPiw19k3r
— Dion Lim (@DionLimTV) June 19, 2020
Hubbard never asked the student how to correctly pronounce her name in his emails. He only looked at the spelling and made assumptions about the way it would be pronounced.
According to the Sacramento Bee, Laney College's student population for the 2019 academic year was 27% Asian, 26% Latinx, 20% Black/African-American, 15% white, 6% multi-ethnicity, 2% Filipino, 0.6% Pacific Islander, and 0.2% Native American.
The student's sister pointed out:
"If you read the last page [of the Instagram post], he's calling my sister's name an embarrassment and that it's sounds like an insult."
"I love that my parents want to keep my culture alive by keeping our Vietnamese name. If you can't say it then ask."
"In addition, Hubbard said that English is his language. But also forgot that my sister also spoke English and that's not his language."
@DionLimTV/Twitter
It was then reported Hubbard posted an apology on Twitter after his emails went public.
The apology on Twitter has since been deleted or made private, but not before being screengrabbed.
UPDATE: the professor who asked a student to "Anglicize" her name emailed an apology to her.
His Twitter apology is now hidden.
PS: I offered him opportunity to speak on cam multiple times but he declined. 1 email to me: “If you want to learn more read the New York Times."😐 pic.twitter.com/4ZLyCds8N6
— Dion Lim (@DionLimTV) June 21, 2020
@DionLimTV/Twitter
Laney College President Dr. Tammeil Gilkerson issued a statement about the incident, which Nguyen said in an interview with San Francisco's ABC affiliate KGO left her "shook."
While Gilkerson's statement stopped short of naming Hubbard, it was unsparing in its summation of his emails with Nguyen.
"...this incident is obviously disturbing and comes after decades of discussing and working to combat structural racism, xenophobia, and violence in both the Black and Asian Pacific Islander community..."
"...we also recognize that our college and its community is a reflection of broader society and we must actively fight ignorance with education."
"We do not tolerate racism, discrimination or oppression of any kind."
Gilkerson also specified that Hubbard was placed on administrative leave while the college investigates the matter.
Speaking to KGO ABC7 News, Nguyen described how the exchange made her feel.
Laney College professor accused of telling Vietnamese American student to 'anglicize' her nameyoutu.be
As Nguyen put it:
"I was shook because growing up, there were problems with how to pronounce my name, but they would ask me how to pronounce my name... he's being an ignorant person and not trying to learn my name."
On Twitter, people were outraged by the racist and xenophobic overtones of Hubbard's emails.
He refuses to call her by her name, has yet to ask her how to pronounce it, and refers to her as “P." GET THIS MAN FIRED pic.twitter.com/8XDtJlzatg
— karly (@aybarlyy) June 18, 2020
i was wondering how it was “inappropriate" and . bui isn't pronounced as “boy" 😭😭 it's pronounced like boo eee
— kyanna day (sea appreciation) !!! (@frvitytannie) June 19, 2020
proud of these students for speaking up! My daughter had to report a professor who would not stop calling Coronavirus the "Wuhan Flu" She decided her nervousness reporting him wasn't more than the sick feeling she got listening to him speak racist terminology
— Tracey (@Tracey___G) June 19, 2020
Um, exsqueeze me?
Her name is an offensive sound in my language?
This letter is offensive in my language.
— Cheryl Mireles (@cherylita81) June 19, 2020
WTF!!!! this teacher needs to lose their job asap! no apologies no nothing just leave and go away!!! how horrible that this is happening in 2020 esp from a supposed educator.
— Mi Dan (@haelani) June 19, 2020
I bet the only reason he apologized was because of backlash he personally received. He'd do it again if he thought he could get away with it. I'm so sorry this happened to her. I hope there are consequences for him at the university - at the very least, cultural safety training
— PrincessRainbow Pant (@Princes56695607) June 21, 2020
Suspended! Not good enough @laneycollege. The language in the email he sent to Ms. Bui should be enough on its own to terminate him. The only ending to this story that makes any sense is Mr. Hubbard being terminated (with cause) immediately.
— Scott S (@scottsayswtf) June 21, 2020
This is so, so bad. https://t.co/Tu9G8MMu0Q
— Kaya Oakes (@kayaoakes) June 19, 2020
Phúc is also my grandmother's name. If they'd learn to pronounce it correctly, it wouldn't sound anything like an English pejorative, but no, we gotta adjust to suit lazy English speakers every time. https://t.co/SCXRPwzeOO
— Trung @ Powderhorn MPLS (@Trungles) June 19, 2020
In what alternate universe do you send this email without expecting to get fired oh right White Male Prime https://t.co/CIq6UY5aOz
— Mere Smith (@EvilGalProds) June 19, 2020
and you wonder why my mother named me JEFFREY and not some very traditional sounding Filipino name like her brothers https://t.co/iNcvafLjZy
— Jeff Ramos (@ohjefframos) June 19, 2020
he is definitely not sorry and if he doesn't face the appropriate consequences, he'll do it again https://t.co/GA8S26izWo
— P (@pxpanchal) June 21, 2020
As for other Asian Americans for whom an incident like hers might be embarrassing, Nguyen told KGO:
"People should not be embarrassed of their name and they should be proud of their name. I hope they'll feel more comfortable using their real name rather than using a whitewashed name."
Nguyen's sister confirmed to KGO that Professor Hubbard has since emailed her a personal apology.