Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

In Post-Fact America, Alternative Scientists Put Belief Ahead Of Fact

In Post-Fact America, Alternative Scientists Put Belief Ahead Of Fact

Alternative scientific theories are not supported by evidence, yet they are gaining traction among believers

[DIGEST: IFLS, Science, Atlantic (1, 2), Denver Post]

We live in an age in which “alternative facts” are given equal respect — and disproportionate influence. So it follows that “alternative science,” or pseudoscience, is fast becoming an accepted version of reality. Often peddled by celebrities, including Jenny McCarthy and Gwyneth Paltrow, this alternative science — that is, science based solely on opinion supported by no evidence or proof — is gaining influence and demanding equal access.


Pseudoscience isn’t limited to healthcare. When Andrew Snelling, a self-described creationist geologist, applied for a permit to collect rock specimens at four locations within the Grand Canyon to support his claims that the famous rock layers were created in Noah’s Biblical flood, his request was initially denied. The National Park Service consulted three professionals before deciding that the claim was not scientifically valid, and told Sullivan alternative locations outside of the park would provide him with a suitable alternative for gathering the samples.

"His description of how to distinguish soft sediment from hard rock structures is not well written, up-to-date, or well referenced," said Karl Karlstrom, a geologist at the University of New Mexico, who reviewed Sullivan’s proposal. "My overall conclusion is that Dr. Snelling has no scientific track record and no scientific affiliation since 1982."

Andrew Snelling. (Credit: Source.)

The scientific community generally believes that the Grand Canyon was carved by the Colorado River in a process beginning 5 million to 6 million years ago. The oldest rocks in the Grand Canyon are 1.8 billion years old, according to NPS.

The park has granted Snelling access in the past, and still permits him to run young Earth tours of the park. From 1998 to 2007, Snelling was a geology expert at the Creation Science Foundation and has since worked for Kentucky-based Answers in Genesis, an organization that investigates geology "from a Biblical perspective" and established the Creationist Museum and Ark Encounter theme park. A “young Earth” creationist, Snelling believes that the Earth was created in six literal (24-hour) days, which occurred 6,000–12,000 years ago and are described in the Book of Genesis, which he insists is “history, not poetry, parable, prophetic vision, or mythology.”

Snelling, along with the Christian legal help organization Alliance Defending Freedom, sued the National Park Service, claiming that it discriminated against his creationist beliefs when it prohibited him from taking samples and violated Snelling's constitutional rights and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, as well as Trump's May 4 religious freedom executive order. The park reversed its decision, and Snelling is now scheduled to visit the park in August to collect samples.

Not all Christians agree with the young Earth creationists, including those in the scientific community.

“In science we want to be the type of community where people can bring about ideas that are controversial,” says Stephen Moshier, a geologist at Wheaton, a Christian liberal arts college in Illinois, and a former president of the Affiliation of Christian Geologists. He says young-Earth creationists are too inflexible when faced with evidence contradicting their ideas. “Often I read things by young-Earth creationists where I think they really ought to know better. Many of them have excellent training in the geosciences.” Moshier is the author of The Grand Canyon, Monument to an Ancient Earth, which directly refutes young-Earth creationists who cite the canyon as evidence of Noah’s flood.

Another theory gaining traction in the alternative facts era is that the Earth, generally believed to be spherical, is instead a flat, rectangular planet resembling a table. The Flat Earth movement, according to Neil DeGrasse Tyson, is the result of the failure of the education system. But others are less dismissive.

“This is a new awakening,” says John Vnuk, founder of a Colorado Flat Earth group. “Some will accept it, some won’t. But love it or hate it, you can’t ignore Flat Earth.”

Flat Earthers gather across the globe — er, world — to discuss their theories, and answer questions such as, how does the Flat Earth theory work with the August 2017 solar eclipse? The answer? “We’ll have to do more research and get back to you on that.”

More from News

Screenshot of J.D. Vance
C-SPAN

JD Vance Got Laughs With A Cringey 'Political Violence' Joke During His RNC Speech

Former President Donald Trump's running mate J.D. Vance was criticized for appearing to make light of the recent assassination attempt on Trump's life during his speech accepting the vice presidential nomination at the Republican National Convention.

At one point, Vance joked about "political violence" between Ohio and Michigan supporters while discussing some of his life experiences before officially starting his political career with a successful 2022 Senate campaign.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshots of Kamala Harris and J.D. Vance
C-SPAN; NBC News

Kamala Harris Calls Out JD Vance For 'What He Didn't Say' During RNC Speech In Epic Takedown

In a fiery speech to supporters in North Carolina, Vice President Kamala Harris called out what J.D. Vance—former President Donald Trump's freshly selected running mate—"didn't say" in his speech accepting the VP nomination on Night 3 of the Republican National Convention.

Amid much talk about key conservative issues like immigration, the ongoing border crisis, and "law and order," he did not once mention what the GOP has explicitly laid out and is now attempting to distance itself from: Project 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Daniel Dale; Donald Trump
CNN; Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

CNN Fact-Checker Debunks Trump's RNC Speech Lies For 2 Minutes Straight—And Yeah, It's A Lot

CNN fact-checker Daniel Dale debunked lies former President Donald Trump told during his acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention, dedicating two minutes to picking apart Trump's many falsehoods.

Trump made numerous oddball remarks during his speech, particularly his reference that the world was "at peace" when he was in office until his political opponents "turned it into a planet of war," declaring that the planet is now "blowing up around us" due to Democratic policies.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshots of Donald Trump and Tiffany Trump
C-SPAN

Trump Snubbed Daughter Tiffany As She Went In For A Kiss At The RNC—And People Are Team Tiffany

Social media users were sympathetic to Tiffany Trump after her father, former President Donald Trump, appeared to snub her as she went in for a kiss before his climactic speech accepting the GOP's presidential nomination.

Footage from early in the evening shows a smiling Tiffany walking up the stairs toward Trump, who clearly saw her. She then attempted to greet him with a kiss only to be ignored, as he looked out at the crowd beyond her, as she walked away looking dejected.

Keep ReadingShow less
Picture of Marjorie Taylor Greene seen on "The Daily Show" with Jon Stewart
The Daily Show

Jon Stewart Just Pointed Out The Weird Noise MTG Made During Her RNC Speech—And Now We Can't Unhear It

Jon Stewart had a lot to unpack on Tuesday's airing of The Daily Show, given a wild week that included the shocking assassination attempt on former Republican President Donald Trump as well as the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee, which kicked off on Monday.

One specific highlight from the opening night of the RNC that Jon couldn't help but fixate on was far-right Georgia Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene making strange sounds while addressing delegates during her speech.

Keep ReadingShow less