Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Justice Sotomayor Calls Out Kavanaugh for Failing to Allow Death Row Inmate to Choose Less Painful Means of Death

Justice Sotomayor Calls Out Kavanaugh for Failing to Allow Death Row Inmate to Choose Less Painful Means of Death
Erin Schaff-Pool/Getty Images // Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Ernest Johnson was sentenced to death for murder in 1994. Fourteen years later, in 2008, Johnson was diagnosed with brain cancer that required an operation to remove a tumor, removing a significant portion of his brain in the process and resulting in epilepsy.

The state of Missouri will execute Johnson using pentobarbital, to which Johnson is particularly vulnerable due to the drug's triggering of seizures and exacerbation of pain sensations. The likely result for Johnson will be agonizing pain when the drug is administered, which his lawyers argued was a violation of the 8th Amendment banning "cruel and unusual" punishments for crime.


Johnson embarked on a legal battle imploring the state to execute him using nitrogen gas instead—which Missouri law allows as a method of execution. The case went all the way to the Supreme Court, where its conservative majority ruled in 2019's Bucklew v. Precythe that procuring nitrogen gas for execution would be an undue burden on the state of Missouri.

But Kavanaugh did say, in a concurring opinion supporting Bucklew, that Johnson could request a method of execution outside of the state's explicitly stated methods:

"I write to underscore the Court's additional holding that the alternative method of execution need not be authorized under current state law—a legal issue that had been uncertain before today's decision."

Kavanaugh even noted that the state conceded in court that firing squad would be a viable alternative method:

"At oral argument in this Court, the State suggested that the firing squad would be such an available alternative, if adequately pleaded.

As a result, Johnson requested to be executed by firing squad as a less agonizing alternative, but the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals denied this request, ruling that Johnson's request came too late and should've been made before the Supreme Court ruled on the viability of nitrogen gas.

This is despite, as Kavanaugh noted in his concurring opinion, that the legitimacy of the request was "uncertain" before the Court's 2019 decision.

Mark Joseph Stern of Slate noted this reversal—and its diversion from Kavanaugh's predecessor Justice Anthony Kennedy—in a lengthy assessment.

For a case to earn standing in the Supreme Court, four Justices need to agree to hear the arguments. All three of the Court's Liberal Justices agreed to hear Johnson's appeal of the 8th Circuit's decision, but Kavanaugh—who explicitly laid this path forward for Johnson in his concurring opinion—sided with the rest of the conservative Justices, dooming Johnson to potentially excruciating pain in his final moments.

In her dissent, Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor repeatedly cited Kavanaugh's own concurring opinion in Bucklew that suggested the path for requesting a firing squad as an alternative method, subtly noting the conservative Justice's own hypocrisy.

She wrote:

"Bucklew suggested that plaintiffs in exactly this situation should have little trouble identifying an available alternative. ... (opinion of KAVANAUGH, J.) ... ('[A]n inmate who contends that a particular method of execution is very likely to cause him severe pain should ordinarily be able to plead some alternative method of execution that would significantly reduce the risk of severe pain'). Johnson seeks only to take Bucklew up on that promise. Denying him leave to amend his complaint under these circumstances renders this Court's words an empty gesture."

People agreed that Kavanaugh's opinion in Bucklew, only to deny Johnson mercy two years later, was indeed an "empty gesture."






They praised Sotomayor for calling him out.



It's unclear when Johnson's execution will be carried out.

More from News

Donald Trump
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Trump Blasted For Announcing New Additions To The White House Lawn As Global Tensions Escalate

President Donald Trump was criticized after announcing that two new flagpoles would be added to the North and South Lawns of the White House—not the greatest look amid heightened global unease as tensions between Israel and Iran ramp up.

According to the Associated Press, Trump watched as a crane installed the newest flagpole on the South Lawn, remarking, “It’s such a beautiful pole.” He later returned to the site to salute as the American flag was raised for the first time.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshots of Donald Trump from CNN supercut
CNN

Trump Mocked For 'Two Weeks' Iran Deadline With Supercut Of All His 'Two Weeks' Promises

President Donald Trump has a history of promising to resolve problems within "two weeks," and a new viral supercut mocks him for all the times he's said as much—including right now with tensions in the Middle East higher than ever.

Trump said Thursday he will decide within two weeks whether to involve U.S. forces directly in the escalating conflict between Israel and Iran, citing what he called a “substantial chance” for renewed nuclear negotiations with Tehran.

Keep ReadingShow less
red flag with pole on seashore
Seoyeon Choi on Unsplash

People Break Down The 'Silent Red Flags' Folks Tend To Ignore In Relationships

A red flag has come to mean any warning sign in life, in addition to the literal red flags that are placed on beaches or industrial sites to warn people of danger.

People will respond to situations by saying, "That’s a red flag." But before that language evolved, they'd just call them "warning signs."

Keep ReadingShow less
Ted Cruz; Tucker Carlson
The Tucker Carlson Show

Tucker Carlson And Ted Cruz Get Into Shouting Match Over Iran In Bonkers Interview Clip

Texas Republican Senator Ted Cruz—a harsh Donald Trump critic-turned-MAGA minion—sat down with fired Fox News personality Tucker Carlson for the conservative influencer's self-produced online content,The Tucker Carlson Show, for the Tucker Carlson Network.

On Tuesday, Carlson shared a 1.5-minute clip revealing that things got contentious when the pair touched on the Trump administration's escalating tensions with Iran.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump; Barack Obama
Suzanne Plunkett-Pool/Getty Images; Scott Olson/Getty Images

Resurfaced Trump Tweet Criticizing Obama Over Iran Comes Back To Bite Him

Amid tensions with Iran, President Donald Trump was criticized for hypocrisy after social media users resurfaced a 2013 tweet in which he accused former President Barack Obama of planning an attack on Iran because of his "inability to negotiate properly."

Trump has declined to clarify whether the U.S. is edging closer to launching strikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities, following a warning from Iran’s supreme leader against any attack and a rejection of Trump’s demand for surrender.

Keep ReadingShow less