Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

The State of the Gerrymanders: What Happened to the Big GOP Advantage That Democrats Feared?

The State of the Gerrymanders: What Happened to the Big GOP Advantage That Democrats Feared?
LOGAN CYRUS/AFP via Getty Images

With headlines about Congressional maps being tossed by the courts and Democratic state legislatures evening the score from GOP gerrymanders in other states, it’s time to review the state of play for redistricting. The news so far is better than many had expected: With the GOP in control of so many states during the map-drawing process, many had expected the GOP to net as many as 12-13 House seats due to aggressive packing and stacking of voters. Instead, the current outlook appears more or less a wash, with even the possibility that the Dems might fare better on this map than they did after the 2010 maps emerged.


A little more than half of the states have now completed their maps, and it’s clear that the GOP has moved conservatively to protect their existing seats while ceding many seats to the Democrats. A good example of this is Texas, where the GOP moved the number of competitive seats from 13 down to just 1 while increasing both the number of safe GOP seats and by extension the number of safe Democratic seats. This of course is not good for democracy, as it renders Congressmembers not truly beholden to anyone but the most extreme partisans in their districts. But the bottom line is that Texas failed to capitalize on its trifecta control of the state.

The opposite has been true in Democratically-controlled states, which have been willing to draw more districts to only “lean” a bit Democrat but have taken risks by keeping them within striking distance. It’s a strategy that could result in a rout should a red wave election occur but keeps alive Democratic hopes to hold their majority. This effectively has created a national map where some Democrats now predict the “typical” district will shift from leaning to the right of the national vote to actually matching it, thereby ending the distorted advantage the GOP has enjoyed for the last five House elections. “We have stymied their intent to gerrymander their way to a House majority,” said Kelly Ward Burton, head of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, summing up the state of the maps.

The aggressively drawn seats in Democratic-controlled states appear to have caught the GOP somewhat off-guard, given that party’s own conservative moves to shore up their incumbents. Most Republican House seats are likely unassailable absent a crushing blue tsunami, but if the GOP outperforms Democrats even by a little bit nationally, they will win a commanding majority in Congress.

That’s a risk Democrats appear willing to accept. Whether they have 180 or 200 seats in the House will matter little, after all, if they don’t have 218.

Meanwhile, a few wild cards remain. In litigation, the courts have been ruling against Republican maps somewhat unexpectedly, including recent losses before the Republican controlled Ohio Supreme Court last week and before a GOP majority three-judge panel in a federal district court in Alabama just yesterday. While the Ohio legislature will get another crack at the map and the Alabama case will be appealed, so far the judges hearing the cases—even those appointed by Trump, like two of the panelists in Alabama—have seen through Republican efforts to diminish minority voting power or thwart the intent of the voters, as in Ohio where the legislature blatantly ignored a state constitutional amendment intended to bar partisan gerrymandering. And in another key state redistricting case, the North Carolina gerrymanders face an uncertain future as they wind their way up to a skeptical Supreme Court that comprises four Democrats and three Republicans.

There remain a few big unknowns in large states such as New York, where on Monday, after two years of effort, the redistricting commission failed to reach a compromise on map drawing, throwing the process back to the legislature which is dominated by Democrats. It is expected that this will result in a few more blue House seats should that body aggressively gerrymander the state, as many partisans have urged. On the opposite end there is Florida, where Governor DeSantis, unhappy with the more cautious maps drawn by the GOP-controlled legislature there, produced maps of his own that would tip at least two more seats to the Republicans and reduce the number of truly competitive seats.

When the dust settles, it’s already clear that the danger of a +12 or +13 advantage on new maps going into the midterms has largely evaporated, and we are now looking at a far fairer playing field. If Democrats lose the House, it will very likely not be because they faced gerrymanders that were worse than in 2020. This should provide some glimmer of hope for them to not lose their majority in 2022. And even should that occur, as many expect, the new maps point to a brighter chance in 2024 to retake it.

For more political analysis, check out The Status Kuo newsletter.

More from News

Country Singer Gavin Adcock went on a drunken rant over Beyonce's "Cowboy Carter" success.
Danielle Del Valle/Getty Images; Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for The Recording Academy

Country singer rants over Beyoncé album

Country singer Gavin Adcock became the title of his next album, “Own Worst Enemy,” after going on an unhinged rant about the legitimacy of Beyoncé's Grammy-winning and record-breaking Cowboy Carter in the country music genre.

Adcock, whose upcoming album is set for release next month, was filmed during a live performance last weekend, complaining that Beyoncé and her album are not “country music.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Dionne Warwick; Tiny Chef
Astrida Valigorsky/Getty Images; @ToonHive/X

Dionne Warwick Is Ready To Go To War With Nickelodeon Over 'Tiny Chef' Cancellation

You know your campaign against a show's cancellation is achieving widespread attention when you get people like venerated singer Dionne Warwick advocating for you.

Nickelodeon's The Tiny Chef Show was recently cancelled, much to the dismay of its viewers and creators. It was also a genuinely surprising decision, since the show has won an Emmy.

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman relaxing in sunhat and sunglasses
Photo by Jordan Bauer on Unsplash

People Explain Which 'Small Luxuries' They Can't Live Without

Many of us have committed to being fairly financially frugal and not overspending on silly, unnecessary things.

That is to say, sometimes, it's fun to splurge on something one time to see what it's like to experience that small luxury.

Keep ReadingShow less
two women in emotional distress seated on couch
Ben White on Unsplash

People Who've Experienced Grief Share The Most Tone-Deaf Things They've Heard

Grief, loss, trauma are all part of life. But for most people, the emotions and reactions that go with them are difficult to witness.

So they rely on platitudes to fill any holes in conversation. That's rarely a good idea.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump
Mehmet Eser/Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images

Trump Demands 'Boss Of AT&T' Fix Equipment After Failed Conference Call In Bizarre Meltdown

When most of us have technical difficulties, we contact tech support or customer service.

But if you're President of the United States, just ranting on social media—then having your White House Press Secretary post a screenshot of your post on a social media platform people actually use—is apparently the answer.

Keep ReadingShow less