Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Judge Faces Suspension After Suggesting That Sexual Assault Victim Could've Just Closed Her Legs

Judge Faces Suspension After Suggesting That Sexual Assault Victim Could've Just Closed Her Legs
Alessandro De Carli / EyeEm / Getty Images

Sexual assault trials are always going to be difficult for the victims; they require discussing the assault and all of its intimate details. It is usually safe to hope, however, that the judge presiding over the trial won't actively make things worse.

But in a 2016 case presided over by New Jersey Superior Court Justice John Russo, that is exactly what he did.


An ethics committee was asked to evaluate Justice Russo's behavior and determine if he violated any judicial rules during the case.

Russo was questioning the victim, apparently trying to determine if she resisted the assault, when he asked a particularly problematic series of questions.

"Do you know how to stop somebody from having intercourse with you?"
"Close your legs? Call the police? Did you do any of those things?"

This was neither a criminal trial nor a lawsuit; the woman was simply seeking a restraining order to protect herself and her child from her assailant, who was the father of her child. He had also threatened her life and made inappropriate comments to their five-year-old child.



Russo denies that he violated any judicial rules, claiming that he was simply trying to get information and wasn't trying to shame or humiliate the victim, in both court filings and at the hearing.

The ethics wrote a 45-page assessment of the situation and recommended that Russo be suspended without pay for three months as a result of Russo's behavior.

He has been on administrative leave since 2017. The committee further recommended that he be required to attend additional training on "appropriate courtroom demeanor."

They noted that Russo's behavior was:

"not only discourteous and inappropriate, but also egregious given the potential for those questions to re-victimize the plaintiff."
"This conduct constitutes a significant departure from the courtroom demeanor expected of jurists and impugns Respondent's [Justice Russo's] integrity and most notably that of the Judiciary."

One Twitter user brought up the point that situations like this are why sexual assault survivors do not disclose their assault: it will likely lead to their being humiliated and not protected anyway.

There were many who thought a three-month suspension was insufficient discipline for such an infraction.




There is a plethora of resources and trainings on how to treat sexual assault victims with dignity. Perhaps this judge should have read one.

Someone in a position of power like a superior court justice should never treat a victim like they are the one on trial.

More from Trending

Sarah Jessica Parker
Marc Piasecki/WireImage

Sarah Jessica Parker Claps Back At Conservative Critics Who Want Her To 'Shut Up' About Politics And 'Act'

Nothing seems to get conservatives' goats quite like celebrities having political opinions—well, liberal and leftist celebrities, anyway.

They seem to love it when weird right-wing celebs like Kevin Sorbo get on the internet and say bizarre, usually counterfactual nonsense, or when JK Rowling does her darnedest to make her legacy not about Harry Potter but about her weird obsession with trans people.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ann Coulter
Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic

Ann Coulter Faces Fierce Backlash After Saying 'We Didn't Kill Enough Indians' In Deleted Post

Far-right provocateur Ann Coulter is facing fierce criticism after she made a genocidal remark in a now-deleted post on X in response to University of Minnesota professor and Navajo Nation member Melanie Yazzie's speech about colonization.

Yazzie, in a speech at last year's annual Socialism Conference, said "decolonization is the only thing that is going to save us as a species" during a panel hosted by Red Nation, a Native American nonprofit that advocates for Palestinian and Native American rights. She also said that the United States is the "greatest predator empire that has ever existed" and said it should be dismantled.

Keep ReadingShow less
James Gunn
Matt Winkelmeyer/WireImage

James Gunn Bluntly Fires Back At 'Jerks' Who Criticize Superman's Pro-Immigrant Themes

Superman director James Gunn issued a response to the "jerks" who criticize the political themes inherent to the superhero's story, expressing his hope that seeing the movie will "make people a little nicer."

Speaking with The Times of London, Gunn stressed that the story of Superman is more relevant than ever considering the ongoing political turmoil in the United States largely centered around the Trump administration's immigration crackdown.

Keep ReadingShow less

Things People Do In Relationships That Seem Sweet But Are Actually Toxic

Content Warning: Controlling and Toxic Relationship Behaviors

We've all either been involved in or witnessed a relationship where we saw something that we thought was cute or sweet at first, but we eventually found the behavior to be troubling or "too much."

Keep ReadingShow less
A piggy bank surrounded by loose change.
coin bank

'Poor Person Habits' People Won't Give Up No Matter How Rich They Get

When money is tight, we look for every possible way to avoid spending it.

As much as we might find ourselves missing out on some of the nicer things life has to offer, we find ourselves contented by the fact that we will always have enough money in our bank accounts to pay our bills on time.

Keep ReadingShow less