Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

The Internet Is Very Confused by the New York Times' Newest Recipe

The Internet Is Very Confused by the New York Times' Newest Recipe
UniversalImagesGroup/Getty Images
Make us preferred on Google

On April 6, 2018, The New York Times ended the culinary world as we know it. They published a recipe in their Friday issue that has left readers perplexed, disgusted, and, honestly, a bit scared. Have you ever tried a peanut butter and pickle sandwich? One of the most prominent publications in the United States is now recommending it as a tasty treat.


Why would the NYT do this? Twitter brainstormed some explanations.

Regardless, the internet did NOT approve.

Even some New York Times staff were pretty upset by the recipe.

But just when it seemed the recipe was universally abhorred, fans began creeping out of the woodwork.

And sure enough, before long people began getting curious...

The author of the recipe penned an essay about PB&P sandwiches for the NYT in 2012. He describes them as an American classic:

My father passed them down to me. Peanut butter and pickle sandwiches got him through law school at West Virginia University. I've come to consider them the work-at-home writer's friend. The ingredients are always there for you, waiting loyally in the pantry when more glamorous lunch options (cold cuts, leftovers) aren't returning your calls.

The PB&P has been a minority enthusiasm in America for generations, lingering just under the radar. The sandwiches appeared on lunch-counter menus during the Great Depression and in extension-service cookbooks in the 1930s and '40s in recipes that generally called for a few spoonfuls of pickle relish. A lot of people's grandmothers used to eat them.

Despite this, many retained their...skepticism.

Some believe it's the worst recipe the Times has ever suggested.

And this isn't even the first time in recent memory the NYT has suggested culinary madness.

Which led one Twitter user to a novel idea!

More from Trending

Mark Ruffalo
Hoda Davaine/Getty Images

Mark Ruffalo Hits Back After Paramount Accuses Him Of Antisemitism Over His Merger Criticism

Actor and activist Mark Ruffalo has been speaking out for months about the proposed $110 billion merger between Paramount Skydance and Warner Bros Discovery. Like most critics, his concern lies with the loss of jobs, who would control the merged media giant, and the consolidation of media into an ever shrinking sphere of influence.

In August 2025, Skydance Media founder David Ellison, using his tech billionaire Oracle co-founder father Larry's wealth and influence, completed an $8 billion merger with Paramount. Installed as the Paramount Skydance CEO, the younger Ellison then set his sights on Warner Bros Discovery.

Keep Reading Show less
Hayden Panettiere attends amfAR Gala Los Angeles 2022 at Pacific Design Center.
Jon Kopaloff/Getty Images

Neutrogena Hit With Backlash After Finally Addressing Controversy Over Cutting Ties With Hayden Panettiere For Speaking Out About Postpartum Depression

For nearly a decade, Hayden Panettiere was closely associated with Neutrogena. Now, following her death, the brand’s treatment of the actor is back in the spotlight. The Heroes star died on August 16, 2026, at age 36 after being found unresponsive in cardiac arrest, with her cause of death still under investigation.

Panettiere worked with Neutrogena from 2005 to 2015 before the longtime partnership ended. Years later, she shed light on what happened behind the scenes. During a May 2026 appearance on On Purpose with Jay Shetty, Panettiere revealed that Neutrogena dropped her after she spoke publicly about postpartum depression.

Keep Reading Show less
Bryan Randall and Sandra Bullock
Jackson Lee/GC Images/Getty Images

Sandra Bullock Poignantly Opens Up About Losing Her Longtime Partner Three Years After His Death From ALS

With the return of Practical Magic, Sandra Bullock is stepping back into the spotlight after several years of silence—though she's only now beginning to share with the general public what made her step away in the first place.

While guest-starring on the SmartLess podcast, Bullock opened up to hosts Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, and Will Arnett about her longtime partner's illness and the impact it had on her and her children.

Keep Reading Show less
John Ritter and Jason Ritter during 2003 Sundance Film Festival - "Manhood" Premiere.
Clayton Chase/WireImage

Jason Ritter Opens Up About Seeing Most 'Beautiful Sunsets' Right After Dad John Died In Poignant New Interview

More than two decades have passed since John Ritter died unexpectedly, leaving his family to navigate a loss that Jason Ritter is still reflecting on today.

During a recent appearance on Joy 101 with Hoda Kotb, Jason Ritter, 46, talked about the surreal weeks and months that followed his dad’s death. As Jason recalled, “It felt like the world was upside down.”

Keep Reading Show less
A close up of Shirley MacLaine.
Amanda Edwards / Contributor/Getty Images

Shirley MacLaine Just Made A Rare Appearance At 92 To Promote A Screening Of 'Sweet Charity'—And Fans Are Loving It

One has to have a pretty impressive résumé or pedigree to be deemed a "legend." But few would argue that Academy Award Winner Shirley MacLaine is, indeed, a legend of the silver screen.

After being discovered by a Hollywood producer as an understudy in the Broadway musical The Pajama Game, MacLaine launched to almost instant Hollywood stardom after appearing in Alfred Hitchcock's The Trouble With Harry, going on to a prolific, almost 70-year career.

Keep Reading Show less