Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Tennessee Lawmaker Ripped for False Claim That Three-Fifths Compromise Was to 'End Slavery'

Tennessee Lawmaker Ripped for False Claim That Three-Fifths Compromise Was to 'End Slavery'
@therecount/Twitter
Make us preferred on Google

Republican lawmakers across the country are railing against comprehensive historical teaching in the nation's public schools, especially in regards to race. They argue that critical race theory—an academic approach examining the racism long embedded in systems of United States government and culture—is nothing more than indoctrination.

Former President Donald Trump banned any mention of systemic racism in federal diversity training programs and, most recently, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) called critical race texts like The 1619 Project "divisive nonsense" in a letter to Education Secretary Miguel Cardona, signed by three dozen of McConnell's Republican colleagues.


Republican state legislatures across the country have mobilized to introduce proposals banning The 1619 Project and other comprehensive texts on race from being taught to young adults.

A debate on such legislation was taking place this past week in Tennessee, where state Representative Justin Lafferty accidentally demonstrated the need for unflinching lessons regarding United States history..

Watch below.

Lafferty argued that the founding fathers actively combatted racism and chattel slavery by introducing on the Three-Fifths Compromise, which counted Black Americans as three-fifths of a whole person for the purposes of taxation and apportionment in Congress. Black Americans were still not granted voting rights.

At the 1787 Constitutional Convention, the South wanted Black Americans to be counted as whole people (again, without voting rights) to give the southern region a near-insurmountable advantage in regards to congressional representation.

Lafferty argued that, by the establishing the Three-Fifths Compromise, the founders were deliberately stifling slavery's ability to continue in the United States:

"By limiting the number of population in the count, they specifically limited the number of representatives that would be available in the slaveholding states, and they did it for the purpose of ending slavery. Well before Abraham Lincoln. Well before Civil War. Do we talk about that? I don't hear that anywhere in this conversation across the country ... Talking about incorporating another view of history while ignoring the writings we have access to is no way to go about it."

Lafferty's argument has been put forth before by conservatives looking to paint a rosier picture of the United States' founding and promote the idea that America is inherently exceptional, but that doesn't make the argument any more accurate.

In fact, at the very same Constitutional Convention Lafferty says the founders fought to end slavery, they actually adopted clauses that guaranteed its continuance. At the convention, it was decided the slave trade would be prohibited from ending before 1808, and even then it wouldn't be required to end. What's more, the founders also adopted policies ensuring the federal government would take the sides of slave owners, rather than enslaved peoples who rebelled or escaped.

But even without those, the Three-Fifths Compromise was far from beneficial for enslaved people.

Historian Paul Finkelman, who specializes in the history and legal impact of American slavery, wrote in a 2013 New York Times op-ed:

"[B]y giving the South power disproportionate to its free population, the three-fifths clause set the stage for Southern control of the federal government and, in conjunction with a difficult amendment process, guaranteed a continuation of slavery. James Madison believed in the direct election of the president but created the Electoral College, which, with the three-fifths clause in place, gave the South great power in presidential elections."

Historians like Dr. Joanne Freeman and Kevin Kruse soon weighed in.




But it didn't take a historian's expertise to know Lafferty was wrong.





Lafferty's Republican colleagues applauded his comments after the speech.

More from News

Kathy Hochul; Mike Lawler
Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images; Kena Betancur/Getty Images

Kathy Hochul Has A+ Reaction After Defeated MAGA Rep. 'Leaves Door Open' For Future New York Gubernatorial Run

New York Governor Kathy Hochul's press office had a hilarious response to a New York Post report that outgoing Republican Representative Mike Lawler is leaving the "door open" for a future run for governor of the state.

Lawler, a hardline supporter of President Donald Trump, was previously encouraged by GOP leaders a year and a half ago not to pursue a gubernatorial bid, hoping instead he’d help them keep the seat.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump Jr.
Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

Don Jr. Dragged After Looking High As A Kite In Bizarre Video Defending Russell Brand

Donald Trump Jr. turned heads after appearing intoxicated on a recent episode of his Triggered podcast while defending actor Russell Brand after Southwark Crown Court convicted Brand of rape and three counts of sexual assault and handed down a 10-and-a-half-year prison sentence.

Trump Jr. falsely asserted that Brand had been convicted despite the absence of forensic or DNA evidence and a contemporaneous police report. He also questioned why the allegations had not surfaced publicly sooner, while suggesting that Brand’s religious conversion and political positions were somehow relevant to the prosecution.

Keep ReadingShow less
Gordon Ramsay attends the 2026 Fox Upfront at New York City Center on May 11, 2026, in New York City.
Dia Dipasupil/Getty Images

Gordon Ramsay Shows Off His Ripped Abs In 60th Birthday Post—And Fans Are Impressed

Gordon Ramsay is a man of many talents. He's a world-renowned chef, a television personality, and the face behind the infamous “idiot sandwich” meme. But at 60, the culinary icon is serving something entirely different—and this time, it's not on the menu.

With Michelin stars, an international restaurant empire, and shows including Hell's Kitchen, MasterChef, and Kitchen Nightmares, Ramsay has enough accolades to make even his harshest critics think twice.

Keep ReadingShow less
Grace Hackett with cast of Chicago Fire
Grace Hackett/TikTok

Woman Goes Viral After Stumbling Upon 'Chicago Fire' Cast Right After Getting Dumped—And They Had Her Back

There's nothing worse than getting dumped. But getting hyped up by the cast of a hit show in the aftermath sure does help!

That's what happened to content creator Grace Hackett, who was walking home heartbroken after being dumped by her boyfriend when she stumbled upon the cast of Chicago Fire.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rosie O'Donnell; Megyn Kelly
Bruce Glikas/Getty Images; The Megyn Kelly Show

Rosie O'Donnell Rips Megyn Kelly With NSFW Post After She Called Russell Brand's Prison Sentence An 'Outrage'

After facing years of allegations of sexual assault from multiple women, actor and comedian Russell Brand went on trial in October for his crimes in his native Britain at London's Southwark Crown Court.

On Thursday, November 5, a jury convicted Brand for one rape and three sexual assaults—groping women in public in front of multiple witnesses—perpetrated against four different women. The jury didn't find sufficient evidence to convict Brand on three additional assaults.

Keep ReadingShow less