Most Read

Comic Sands © 2019
News

GOP Rep. Tries To Troll Doctor By Asking 'What's A Woman?'—And She's Having None Of It

John Sundholm
May. 23, 2022
GOP Rep. Tries To Troll Doctor By Asking 'What's A Woman?'—And She's Having None Of It
C-SPAN3

A House Judiciary hearing was held last week to discuss the issue of abortion rights, so naturally a Republican Congressman seized it as an opportunity to change the subject and attack transgender people.

During the testimony of Dr. Yashica Robinson of the organization Physicians for Reproductive Health, North Carolina Republican Representative Dan Bishop attempted to derail the discussion by asking Robinson to define what a "woman" is.

But Robinson was having none of it, using the moment to educate Bishop on gender issues, to his visible dismay.

See their exchange below.


The hearing was held to discuss the potential impacts of the Supreme Court's expected overturn of Roe v. Wadenext month in its decision on the Mississippi abortion-rights case Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health

Dr. Robinson is an abortion provider in the state of Alabama who was called to testify as an expert on the issue. But per the Republican Party's current grievances and obsessions, all Bishop wanted to talk about was pronouns and gender.

Attempting to "gotcha" the doctor, Bishop asked:

“In your written testimony, I noticed you said that you use she/her pronouns. You’re a medical doctor. What’s a woman?”

Robinson refused to take the bait. While Bishop repeatedly interrupted her to ask her what a woman is, Robinson instead educated him on the matter.

"I think it’s important that we educate people like you about why we’re doing the things that we do."
"So the reason I use she and her pronouns is because I understand that there are people who become pregnant that may not identify that way and I think it is discriminatory to speak to people or to call them in such a way as they desire not to be called."
"It’s important that we respect each individual person."

Bishop hated that answer, of course, and asked Robinson one more time to define what a woman is. She responded simply, "I’m a woman."

Bishop immediately shot back a snide question about whether that was "as comprehensive of a definition" as Robinson can give, and she was ready for him. She pointedly replied:

"That’s as comprehensive of a definition as I will give you today because I think that it’s important that we focus on what we’re here for, and it’s to talk about access to abortion."

On Twitter, people applauded Robinson for the way she dispatched with Bishop's bad-faith interrogation.



Now that is how you handle a bad-faith argument.