Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Trump's Own Intelligence Watchdog Debunks Trump's Latest Conspiracy Theory About the Whistleblower Complaint

Trump's Own Intelligence Watchdog Debunks Trump's Latest Conspiracy Theory About the Whistleblower Complaint
President Donald Trump speaks on the telephone in the State Dining Room of the White House in Washington, DC, on December 24, 2018. (Photo by Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images)

Nice try tho.

Since Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) announced a formal impeachment inquiry to be conducted by the House of Representatives, President Donald Trump, members of his administration and allies in Congress scrambled to subvert Article I, Section 2, Clause 5 of the United States Constitution.

To that end, Senate Judiciary Committee member and fervent Trump supporter Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) claimed Sunday on Face the Nation that the regulations for federal whistleblowers changed recently making the President's actions eligible for the whistleblower to file a complaint. President Trump and those who spread his message online repeated Graham's claim.


Three more Republican Senator's contacted Inspector General for the Intelligence Community (IGIC) Michael Atkinson for clarification. Graham and Trump focused on first-hand versus second-hand knowledge as a requirement for a valid whistleblower complaint.

Unlike Graham, the Senators made no claim of regulation changes. Instead, GOP Senators Chuck Grassley of Iowa, Mike Lee of Utah and Ron Johnson stated no laws had changed and they were unaware of any requirements for first-hand knowledge by a whistleblower.

But Graham stated on Face the Nation:

"This is a sham as far as I am concerned. I want to know who told the whistleblower about the phone call. I want to know why they changed the rules about whistleblowers not—the hearsay rule was changed just a short period of time before the complaint was filed."

Graham's Sunday TV appearance led the President to tweet:

In his response to committee chairs Grassley, Lee and Johnson, IGIC Atkinson said:

"Although the form requests information about whether the Complainant possesses first-hand knowledge about the matter about which he or she is lodging the complaint, there is no such requirement set forth in the statute."

The official ICIG statement added:

"In fact, by law the Complainant–or any individual in the Intelligence Community who wants to report information with respect to an urgent concern to the congressional intelligence committees–need not possess first-hand information in order to file a complaint or information with respect to an urgent concern."

Since Senator Graham's false claims on Face the Nation, President Trump and his most dedicated followers used the defense that the whistleblower complaint was "fake" because it was a "second-hand description."

However as ICIG Atkinson pointed out, the whistleblower has both first and second-hand knowledge of the urgent national security concern—negating Graham's entire point. Both Trump and Graham focused on whether the whistleblower had the legal ability to file the complaint, not whether the complaint was true and accurate.

Online, people attempted to put Graham's false claims to rest by breaking it all down into easily digestible bites.

Still some people insisted that Graham's claim that three other GOP Senators also disputed as inaccurate was true as well as ignoring, again, that the whistleblower did have first-hand knowledge of some aspects of the complaint.

But why would the ICIG accept second-hand knowledge?

According to federal employee training–unless their first line supervisor is involved in the actions they are reporting–employees follow a chain of command for reporting urgent security concerns. Reports are filed up the chain of command until successful resolution or until a level fails to take appropriate action on the report.

Therefore, those with first-hand knowledge may report a credible urgent concern to their supervisor, then anyone within that chain can file a whistleblower complaint if appropriate actions are not taken by the agency or administration. This process necessitates allowing those with second-hand knowledge to file whistleblower complaints.

Whether President Trump, Senator Graham and the other Trump fans acknowledge or continue to cling to Graham's false claim as a means to exonerate Trump from impeachment remains to be seen.

The book The U.S. Constitution and Other Writings, available here, includes the Constitution and related documents as well as The Federalist Papers, the Articles of Confederacy and texts of important presidential speeches.

*****

Listen to the first season of George Takei's podcast, 'Oh Myyy Pod!' where we explore the racially charged videos that have taken the internet by storm.

Be sure to subscribe here and never miss an episode.

More from People/donald-trump

Screenshots from Dove's ad featuring transgender women
Dove

'One Million Moms' Calls For Dove Boycott Over Hair Care Ad Featuring Trans Woman

The vehemently transphobic conservative group One Million Moms (OMM)—an arm of the Christian fundamentalist nonprofit American Family Association (AFA)—called for a boycott of Dove products after the company featured a transgender woman in an advertisement for their Damage Therapy Intensive Repair Conditioner.

The ad garnered attention after it was shared by the social media account Libs of TikTok—run by the anti-LGBTQ+ conservative Chaya Raichik—which described the ad as an example of "another woke company trying to erase women."

Keep ReadingShow less
Alyssa Milano; Julian McMahon
Michael Kovac/Elton John AIDS Foundation/Getty Images; Marcus Ingram/The Surfer/Getty Images

Alyssa Milano Shares Poignant Tribute To 'TV Husband' Julian McMahon After His Death At 56

Actor Julian McMahon lost his battle with cancer at the age of 56 earlier this week, and to say that the Charmed, Nip/Tuck, and Fantastic Four actor touched many lives would be an understatement.

When the news of McMahon's passing went public, his Charmed costar and "TV wife" Alyssa Milano came forward and expressed her sadness and condolences on Instagram. The pair were a favorite couple on Charmed, and it was clear from her post that their care for each other extended beyond the screen.

Keep ReadingShow less

People Who Slept With Their Best Friend Describe The Aftermath

When two people have a deep and meaningful friendship, the question might eventually come up of whether or not they could be more. Agreeing that their friendship might deserve more, they might try to date or at least explore physical intimacy.

But crossing that line carries with it consequences, and it's only once the pair crosses that line that they'll find out if crossing it was good or bad.

Keep ReadingShow less
child writing on chalkboard
Leonardo Toshiro Okubo on Unsplash

Bilingual People Explain Which Words They're Surprised Don't Exist In English

According to one report, approximately 3.3 billion people worldwide—43 % of the population—are multilingual, meaning they speak at least two languages. According to the last Census, 21.6% of people in the United States speak more than one language, while in the United Kingdom, the number is 36%.

More multilingual people speak English as a second language than English speakers who have learned another language besides English. Worldwide, people who learned English as a first language rate among the lowest in multilingual rates.

Keep ReadingShow less
Andrew Garfield at the 2025 Glastonbury Festival
Harry Durrant/Getty Images

Andrew Garfield meets fan with wild tweet!

American actor Andrew Garfield had a funny yet awkward reunion with a fan from a viral “Thirst Tweet” featured on Buzzfeed Celeb.

The Thirst Tweet compilation shows celebrities reading a collection of scandalous tweets from fans commenting on their looks, attractiveness, and sex appeal. Blushing stars include James McAvoy, Renee Rapp, Keanu Reeves, Anthony Mackie, and more recently, Brad Pitt and Javier Bardem, as they promote F1 the Movie that was released in theaters last week.

Keep ReadingShow less