Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

The Most Successful Lies In All Of History

Scrabble tiles spelling speak truth
brown wooden blocks on white table
Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

Reddit user clueless-game asked: 'What is the most successful lie in the history?'

We've all lied, or been lied to at least once in our lives.

Some lies are easy to spot, right from the get-go, while others might have you fooled for years, if not your entire life.

Then there are the lies that made international headlines, and had the world fooled for years.

From Anna Anderson fooling the world that she was the Grand Duchess Anastasia Romanoff, to Mill Vanilli (need I say more?), some people were so convincing with their deception, that we are still kicking ourselves for being fooled.

Indeed, there are some who may have died peacefully knowing they had everyone fooled till the end of their life.


Redditor clueless-game was eager to hear what the Reddit community considered the greatest lie ever told, leading them to ask:
"What is the most successful lie in the history?"

"Honesty Is The Best Policy"... Or Is It?

"If you tell the truth you won't be in trouble'."

"Yeah mom, I fell for that a few times and learned that lesson quickly."- glucoseintolerant

Always One Step Ahead...

"During WW2 the British put faked documents on a corpse and dropped the body in the waters to be found by the Axis."

"It detailed an attack that never happened."

"Here’s the best part."

"The plans for D-Day were found in a similar manner."

"The actual plans."

"But they were ignored cause the nazi leaders thought it was just another ruse."- Happy-Personality-23

We Can All See More Clearly Now...

"One of the most impressive ones was when Great Britain convinced everyone during WWII that carrots were the reason why their vision was great when it was really the recently discovered airborne interception radar technologies."

"I still know people that are convinced eating carrots as kids will ensure 20/20 vision for life."- KickArseDuke·

hamster GIFGiphy

The King Of All Lies

"The lie that made a man the ruler of a third or quarter of humankind."

"Darius the Great (r. 522–486 BC) governed the Achaemenid Empire at its peak."

"His rule extended from the Indus valley to mainland Greece and from the Scythian steppes to Egypt."

"A remarkably high and possibly unparalleled percentage of the world population were his subjects."

"Darius reorganized the satrapies, which made the administrative system of his empire more efficient, and introduced major financial reforms as well."

"It was never a secret that Darius became the King of Kings after a successful coup."

"He and a small group of other aristocrats (primary sources refer to seven men in total) infiltrated the residence of the previous ruler and killed him after a brief clash with his guards."

"Shortly afterwards, Darius, who was also a member of the royal house, emerged as the leader of the conspirators and assumed full power."

"So far so good."

"Things become strange when it comes to the identity of Darius’ predecessor."

"As far as the primary sources are concerned, Cyrus the Great (r. 559–530 BC) had two sons: Cambyses (r. 530–522 BC) and Bardiya."

"The former succeeded him as King of Kings, while the latter was given governorship over the eastern provinces."

"Fearful of opposition, Cambyses had his brother assassinated, but kept it a secret."

"Then he undertook the campaign that ended up bringing Egypt into the Persian fold."

"While Cambyses was in Egypt, he started acting cruelly and erratically: suspected everyone, disrespected the local traditions and the sort."

"Then a rebellion broke out back in Persia led by a magus (Zoroastrian priest) named Gaumata."

"The man claimed to be Bardiya, and the people, ignorant of the latter’s death, flocked to his banner."

"It also helped that he took short-term populist measures such as tax cuts."

"Cambyses rushed home to quell the revolt, but died on the journey."

"His death was listed as an accident or even a suicide out of desperation for the usurpation."

"Gaumata got to rule as Bardiya and even took over the latter’s harem."

"Almost nobody suspected he was an impostor, because on top of everything else he also bore an uncanny physical resemblance to the dead prince."

"The first man to suspect something was off was a nobleman named Otanes, who would later become one of Darius’ six companions."

"Otanes knew about Gaumata’s existence and was also aware that at some point his ears had been cut off as a punishment."

"So he asked his daughter, who was Bardiya’s (and now Gaumata’s) wife, to check his ears while he slept."

"The truth was brought to the light."

"Needless to say, the story was very convenient for Darius."

"By killing Gaumata, he saved the empire from a fraudulent, cunning and ruthless liar who had gone as far as to assume a dead man’s identity and risk civil war in order to take the throne for himself."

"Darius simply punished him for his crimes and reinstated the royal office to the house it belonged to: the Achaemenid dynasty."

"But what if the whole story was a lie?"

"What if there was no Gaumata, and the man Darius killed was the real Bardiya?"

"Indeed, scholars have noticed a lot of problems with the traditional narrative, apart from its convenience."

"How could the real Bardiya’s death be kept secret for so long from everyone except a simple magus — and what for?"

"How likely is it that Bardiya had a doppelganger who had also the knowledge, courage and brains necessary to take his place at the right moment?"

"And how is it possible that not even Bardiya’s wives and inner circle were able to see through Gaumata’s lies?"

'Some scholars go as far as to suspect that Cambyses’ madness might have been the product of Darius’ propaganda."

"Herodotus, for example, narrates that the King looted Egyptian temples, insulted the local gods and even killed the sacred bull Apis."

"The problem is, none of that appears in any contemporary Egyptian source — in fact, there are inscriptions showing that Cambyses honored the bull that died in 524 BC with a rich sarcophagus."

"If things were so, it cannot be excluded that Cambyses was also assassinated by Darius, who we know served as his spear-bearer."

"His death might have prompted his brother Bardiya to take power, since Cambyses was childless."

"Darius proceeded to eliminate him too and then created the lie about Gaumata."

"Of course, it cannot be excluded that Bardiya did indeed rebel against Cambyses — that doesn’t change the crux of the matter, which is the story about Gaumata."

"So there you have it."

"One of the most powerful monarchs of antiquity and a possible lie that went unquestioned for millennia by almost everyone."- bradlux01

Gold Crown King GIF by SureYeahGiphy

Or The Fact That Wrestling Is Scripted Entertainment...

"Maybe in the old days, but there was a time I used to believe without a doubt, that Undertaker and Kane were brothers, and Kane wore a mask because Undertaker threw acid on his face out of animosity."- ufc_007

Added To Prolong Your Agony...

“'Please listen carefully as our menu items have recently changed'.”- Raspberries-Are-Evil

All In Moderation

"'Fat will make you fat'."

'Eating that full of sugar premade meal won't'."- Rhaenelys

No Doubt Some Actually Do

"'I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the above Terms and Conditions'."- K333N4N

It's An Ongoing Search

"We don't know the most successful lie because it's a lie we don't know of yet."- lolhappypoo

You Wonder How They Got Their Names...

"Iceland and Greenland."- SuvenPan

Giphy

Strange How This Was Also The Case Yesterday...

“'We are experiencing higher than normal call volume'."

"'Your call is very important to us'.”

"Every. single. customer service line."- depikT

Name Brand Isn't Everything...

"Just get good marks in high school."

"Once you go to a top tier college, your life is practically set and sorted."- from_my_future

Beauty Does, Indeed, Come From Within...

"'You are not beautiful'."

"'But you could be with this product'." Reddit

Skin Care Pink GIF by Mary Kay, Inc.Giphy

It's highly debatable whether or not there is, in fact, such a thing as a "good lie".

Even so, a lie that has the whole world fooled for any stretch of time deserves a commendation of some sort or another.

More from Trending/best-of-reddit

Donald Trump
Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

People Bring Receipts After White House Claims Photo Of Trump Asleep During Oval Office Event Was Just Him 'Blinking'

After President Donald Trump appeared to fall asleep during an event on maternal health in the Oval Office on Monday, people brought the receipts when an official White House account claimed he was simply "blinking."

The event was used to launch moms.gov, a new federal resource hub focused on prenatal care, nutrition, and postpartum support, along with information on employer fertility benefits and expanded childcare options, including assistance for stay-at-home parents.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dr. Mehmet Oz
Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

Dr. Oz Just Made An Alarming Comment About Fertility Rates That Sounds Straight Out Of 'The Handmaid's Tale'

Dr. Mehmet Oz, President Donald Trump's administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, made an alarming comment about fertility rates, declaring that 1 in 3 Americans are "under-babied."

In the United States, infertility affects roughly 9% of men and 11% of women, while globally the figure is estimated at about one in six people.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump Jr.; Donald Trump
Andrew Harnik/Getty Images; Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images

Don Jr.'s Old Tweet Praising His Father For Avoiding War With Iran Just Resurfaced—And It's Aged Like Milk

As President Donald Trump's war with Iran rages on, his son Donald Trump Jr. is facing criticism after an old tweet he wrote praising his father for avoiding war with Iran resurfaced.

Back in April 2024, the president's eldest son wrote the following on X:

Keep ReadingShow less
Images of Savannah and Nancy Guthrie
@savannahguthrie/Instagram

Savannah Guthrie Shares Heartfelt Video Of Her Missing Mom On Mother's Day: 'We Miss You With Every Breath'

Today co-host Savannah Guthrie's mother, 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, was declared missing on February 1, 2026, after she did not routinely arrive at church that morning, and a well-check confirmed that her home was empty and the door was left wide open.

Due to her need for multiple medications, including for her pacemaker, and her limited mobility, the Pima County Police Department deemed her case a high priority, soon welcoming the help of the FBI.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump; Robert Jeffress
Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images; Fox News

Trump Backs Pastor's Claim That He Has A 'Better Understanding' Of The Bible Than Pope Leo—And People Are Furious

On Saturday, MAGA Republican President Donald Trump chose to promote an interview with controversial anti-LGBTQ+ Baptist minister Robert Jeffress by posting a clip from Fox News on Truth Social. In the interview, Jeffress repeatedly stroked Trump's ego, flattering him incessantly.

A Fox News contributor, Jeffress was on to talk about Secretary of State Marco Rubio's visit to the Vatican to give Pope Leo XIV a crystal football.

Keep ReadingShow less