Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Justice Elena Kagan Rips Texas Lawyer By Educating Him On What Constitutional Rights Actually Are

Justice Elena Kagan Rips Texas Lawyer By Educating Him On What Constitutional Rights Actually Are
Erin Schaff/Pool/Getty Images
Make us preferred on Google

Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan took Texas Solicitor General Judd Stone II to task on constitutional rights as the Court hears arguments about Texas's anti-abortion law.

On Monday, November 1, the Court began hearing arguments in Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson, a lawsuit challenging the law, which prohibits virtually all abortions after a heartbeat is detected and empowers citizens to file lawsuits against abortion providers suspected of violating the new policy.


There was friction between Stone and Kagan, and you can hear what happened in the video below.

youtu.be

It all began when Stone argued that the Supreme Court cannot stop the law from being implemented, saying that federal courts "don't enjoin laws, they enjoin officials who enforce the laws."

His remarks were questioned by Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who called it a "loophole" to constitutional rights that could apply to any right, even Second Amendment rights, and asked Stone to consider a scenario in which a state didn't ban guns but made anyone who sells an AR-15 "liable for a million dollars to any citizen."

Stone responded by claiming that his argument "does not turn on the nature of the right." He said only an act of Congress would stop states from passing such laws, adding that the Supreme Court would not be able to do anything.

That was when Kagan stepped in–and ripped Stone for his reasoning.

"Your answer to Justice Kavanaugh, which is go ask Congress, I mean, isn't the point of a right that you don't have to ask Congress?"
"Isn't the point of a right that it doesn't really matter what Congress thinks or what the majority of the American people think as to that right?"

According to Stone, the Supreme Court has to assume that Texas state court judges will "faithfully apply the Constitution," in this case Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision that protects a pregnant woman's right to choose reproductive healthcare without excessive government restriction.

The Supreme Court, he said, would only be able to weigh in on the law following appeals in the event a Texas state court doesn't apply Roe correctly and awards a $10,000 bounty to anyone who sues over an otherwise legal abortion.

Kagan also disapproved of that argument, noting that an appeal could come "many years from now" and cause "a chilling effect that basically deprives people who want to exercise the right from the opportunity to do so in the maybe long-term interim."

Many have praised Kagan for her remarks.









The exchange between Kagan and Stone is but one example of the remarks Kagan made about the Texas law.

Earlier, she said the law is creating a "procedural morass" by placing the Court in a position where it would have to undo lower court orders:

"Tell me if I'm wrong on this, that just the procedural morass we've got ourselves into with this extremely unusual law is that we would really be telling the Fifth Circuit, again, if your position prevailed, that the district court had to be allowed to continue with its preliminary injunction ruling."

And, commenting on what might happen if the Supreme Court allows states to enforce laws much in the way Texas has crafted its anti-abortion law, she said:

"I mean, that was something that until this law came along no state dreamed of doing."
"And, essentially, we would be like, you know, we're open for business — you're open for business. There's nothing the Supreme Court can do about it. Guns, same-sex marriage, religious rights, whatever you don't like, go ahead."

In September, Jonathan Mitchell, the former Texas solicitor general considered the abortion law's architect, wrote an amicus brief to the United States Supreme Court ahead of its ruling on Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health, a Mississippi case limiting abortion to 15 weeks.

The brief questions "lawless" pieces of legislation, namely the Lawrence v. Texas ruling, which decriminalized gay sex nationwide, and the Obergefell v. Hodges ruling, which legalized same-sex marriage.

Mitchell's approach has drawn heavy criticisms that it seeks to evade the process of judicial review, which is the power of courts to decide the validity of acts of the legislative and executive branches of government.

More from News

Jensen Huang
Soeren Stache/picture alliance via Getty Images

People Are Debating Whether They Could Be Seduced By A Spy—And Their Hot Takes Are Hilariously On Point

Could you ever be seduced by a spy?

That's the question many are asking after the latest bonkers thing to hit the news: that ousted Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang had an affair with a Chinese spy—ALLEGEDLY.

Keep Reading Show less
Tom Carney; Ron DeSantis
Mayor Tom Carney/Facebook; Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images for SiriusXM

Florida Mayor Rages After St. Patrick's Day Parade Is Canceled Thanks To DeSantis' Anti-'DEI' Law

In April of 2026, Florida MAGA Republican Governor Ron DeSantis signed the GOP authored and backed SB 1134 to take effect in January of 2027.

Dubbed the anti-DEI law, it bans Florida counties and municipalities from "funding, promoting, or taking official action" related to diversity, equity, and inclusion, which the law defines as: "with reference to race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation."

Keep Reading Show less
Shakira; Abdul El-Sayed
Michael Loccisano/Getty Images; Finn Gomez/Getty Images

Shakira Just Responded To Abdul El-Sayed's Quip About 'Shakira Law'—And Fans Are Obsessed

Pop star Shakira had social media users cackling after finally responding to then-Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed's joke about Michiganders who fear "Shakira Law" back in October.

El-Sayed was able to fend off Islamophobic attacks against him over many months, actions that culminated in his historic defeat of Michigan Republican Mike Rogers in the state's U.S. Senate race. He repeatedly faced accusations that he is a member of the Muslim Brotherhood and wants to impose Sharia law nationwide.

Keep Reading Show less
Gerrymandered North Carolina map
Win McNamee/Getty Images

North Carolina Is Now The Textbook Definition Of A 'Dummymander' After Their Gerrymandering Efforts Backfired Massively

North Carolina Republicans are making waves on Wikipedia after the site used them as a prime example of "dummymandering" now that Democrats made historic wins in last week's midterm elections.

Before the elections, Republicans held 10 of the state's 14 U.S. House seats. However, Democrats have now flipped most of those despite the GOP's decision to redraw congressional districts in an attempt to hold onto more seats.

Keep Reading Show less
Andrew Rannells attends the Television Academy's Inaugural Televerse Festival in Los Angeles.
Chris Delmas / AFP via Getty Images

Andrew Rannells Calls Out Theatergoer Who Chastized Him For Not Showing Up At Stage Door After Broadway Show

For Broadway fans, the final curtain call doesn't always mean the night's over. There's still the stage door, where a little patience and a Sharpie might score an autograph, a selfie, or a few unforgettable seconds with an iconic performer.

Of course, some theatergoers seem to have confused a Broadway ticket with an all-access backstage pass.

Keep Reading Show less