Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Justice Elena Kagan Rips Texas Lawyer By Educating Him On What Constitutional Rights Actually Are

Justice Elena Kagan Rips Texas Lawyer By Educating Him On What Constitutional Rights Actually Are
Erin Schaff/Pool/Getty Images
Make us preferred on Google

Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan took Texas Solicitor General Judd Stone II to task on constitutional rights as the Court hears arguments about Texas's anti-abortion law.

On Monday, November 1, the Court began hearing arguments in Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson, a lawsuit challenging the law, which prohibits virtually all abortions after a heartbeat is detected and empowers citizens to file lawsuits against abortion providers suspected of violating the new policy.


There was friction between Stone and Kagan, and you can hear what happened in the video below.

youtu.be

It all began when Stone argued that the Supreme Court cannot stop the law from being implemented, saying that federal courts "don't enjoin laws, they enjoin officials who enforce the laws."

His remarks were questioned by Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who called it a "loophole" to constitutional rights that could apply to any right, even Second Amendment rights, and asked Stone to consider a scenario in which a state didn't ban guns but made anyone who sells an AR-15 "liable for a million dollars to any citizen."

Stone responded by claiming that his argument "does not turn on the nature of the right." He said only an act of Congress would stop states from passing such laws, adding that the Supreme Court would not be able to do anything.

That was when Kagan stepped in–and ripped Stone for his reasoning.

"Your answer to Justice Kavanaugh, which is go ask Congress, I mean, isn't the point of a right that you don't have to ask Congress?"
"Isn't the point of a right that it doesn't really matter what Congress thinks or what the majority of the American people think as to that right?"

According to Stone, the Supreme Court has to assume that Texas state court judges will "faithfully apply the Constitution," in this case Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision that protects a pregnant woman's right to choose reproductive healthcare without excessive government restriction.

The Supreme Court, he said, would only be able to weigh in on the law following appeals in the event a Texas state court doesn't apply Roe correctly and awards a $10,000 bounty to anyone who sues over an otherwise legal abortion.

Kagan also disapproved of that argument, noting that an appeal could come "many years from now" and cause "a chilling effect that basically deprives people who want to exercise the right from the opportunity to do so in the maybe long-term interim."

Many have praised Kagan for her remarks.









The exchange between Kagan and Stone is but one example of the remarks Kagan made about the Texas law.

Earlier, she said the law is creating a "procedural morass" by placing the Court in a position where it would have to undo lower court orders:

"Tell me if I'm wrong on this, that just the procedural morass we've got ourselves into with this extremely unusual law is that we would really be telling the Fifth Circuit, again, if your position prevailed, that the district court had to be allowed to continue with its preliminary injunction ruling."

And, commenting on what might happen if the Supreme Court allows states to enforce laws much in the way Texas has crafted its anti-abortion law, she said:

"I mean, that was something that until this law came along no state dreamed of doing."
"And, essentially, we would be like, you know, we're open for business — you're open for business. There's nothing the Supreme Court can do about it. Guns, same-sex marriage, religious rights, whatever you don't like, go ahead."

In September, Jonathan Mitchell, the former Texas solicitor general considered the abortion law's architect, wrote an amicus brief to the United States Supreme Court ahead of its ruling on Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health, a Mississippi case limiting abortion to 15 weeks.

The brief questions "lawless" pieces of legislation, namely the Lawrence v. Texas ruling, which decriminalized gay sex nationwide, and the Obergefell v. Hodges ruling, which legalized same-sex marriage.

Mitchell's approach has drawn heavy criticisms that it seeks to evade the process of judicial review, which is the power of courts to decide the validity of acts of the legislative and executive branches of government.

More from News

Nicholas Hoult; Robert Pattinson
Taylor Hill/FilmMagicl; Lia Toby/Getty Images for BFI

Fans Think Nicholas Hoult Already Knew He Wasn't Cast As James Bond In Awkward Interview Days Before Robert Pattinson Was Announced

In case you missed it, Daniel Craig's reign as Agent 007 has officially come to a close.

After years of speculation that everyone from Idris Elba to Jacob Elordi would be the next James Bond, it was announced Monday that Robert Pattinson will be taking over the role in the as yet unnamed next iteration of the franchise.

Keep Reading Show less
Screenshot of James P. Sullivan
@atrupar/X

Trump Judicial Nominee Epically Flails During Confirmation Hearing After Being Asked Simple Question About Constitution

James P. Sullivan, President Donald Trump's nominee to serve on the U.S. Court for the Western District of Texas, was criticized after he completely flubbed a simple question about the 22nd Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

Senator Chris Coons of Delaware, a Democrat, began his line of questioning by asking Sullivan if he can "just tell me what the 22nd Amendment provides."

Keep Reading Show less
Mariah Carey; Nick Cannon
Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images for Gucci; Johnny Nunez/WireImage

Mariah Carey's Kids With Nick Cannon Call Out His 'Unsustainable' Lifestyle In New Docuseries Trailer—And Fans Are Seated

Nick Cannon makes the news most often now for his support of MAGA Republican President Donald Trump, his sexist double standards for his teenage daughter, and the number of children he's had with multiple women, with seven of the 12 arriving between December of 2020 and December of 2022.

Elon Musk still has him beat with numbers—14 children—but is behind Cannon with women, with only four mother's of his children to Cannon's six.

Keep Reading Show less
Lauren Boebert; Donald Trump; Barack Obama
Joe Raedle/Getty Images; Aaron Favila/POOL/AFP via Getty Images; Alex Wong/Getty Images

Lauren Boebert Resurfaces Trump's Mind-Numbing 2014 Dig About Obama Amid Tech Outages—And Nobody's Laughing

Outgoing Colorado Republican Representative Lauren Boebert was harshly criticized after she revived President Donald Trump's racist conspiracy theory "joke" from 2014 about former President Barack Obama amid tech outages.

Trump has long embraced the reactionary politics that gave rise to the Tea Party movement, a conservative populist social and political movement that called for lower taxes and for a reduction of the national debt and federal budget deficit.

Keep Reading Show less
Screenshot of Donald Trump
@Acyn/X

Trump 'Jokes' About Wanting Same Honor Bestowed On General MacArthur During Philippines Visit—And We're Cringing Hard

President Donald Trump had observers cringing after he, speaking in the Philippines, quipped that he wanted to have the same honor bestowed upon him that General Douglas MacArthur once did, referring to a title conferred to him by former Philippine President Manuel Quezon.

Trump landed in the Philippines on Tuesday. He is expected to meet with regional partners and formalize a trade deal. His trip abroad, the first since Republicans lost seats to Democrats in the midterm blue wave, will include three-way nuclear talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Keep Reading Show less