Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Why Haven’t Republicans Learned From Their Primary Missteps?

Ronna McDaniel
Allen J. Schaben/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Over the weekend, Republican National Committee Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel—recently reelected to her position after a challenge from the far right—made a remarkable statement.

She indicated on CNN’s State of the Union all Republicans seeking the party’s nomination for president would be required to sign a pledge to support whoever ultimately is the party’s nominee, and that pledge would be a precondition to participating in the GOP primary debates.


“I suspect that a pledge will be a part of it,” McDaniel said to CNN’s Dana Bash, reminding her they had this requirement back in 2016, too.

“I think it’s a no-brainer."
"If you’re going to be on the Republican National Committee debate stage, asking supporters to support you, you should say, ‘I will support the voters and who they choose as the nominee'.”

It’s only been eight years, but McDaniel is ignoring the party’s history with the very person this is all aimed at: Donald Trump.

Let’s take a look at why McDaniel is maneuvering to secure this pledge at this moment and then review the history behind such pledges. You’ll see why those of us who remember that history are left wondering why it is Republicans didn’t learn their lesson.

Donald Trump already isn’t keen on making the pledge.

Trump was on conservative talk radio host Hugh Hewitt’s show recently, and he was asked about whether he would support someone like Ron DeSantis as the nominee. “It would depend. I would give you the same answer I have in 2016 during the debate," Trump said.

“It would have to depend on who the nominee was.”

Asked about McDaniel’s threat of a required pledge, a Trump campaign spokesperson shot back:

“President Trump will support the Republican nominee because it will be him.”

Hoo boy. McDaniel and the rest of the GOP leadership understand that there are likely only two outcomes here.

Either Trump gets the nomination, or he sets about to destroy whoever actually does get it by, say, running as a third party candidate and taking his 30 percent of MAGA voters with him. Biden of course would cruise to victory in such a situation.

But what about the pledge? Couldn’t that work? Let’s look back at 2015 for a moment.

Reince Priebus tried this before.

Both the Trump campaign and those more familiar with how Trump operates are laughing at the idea of a signed pledge requirement.

Back in 2015, then RNC chair Reince Priebus went to then candidate Trump with precisely such a document and emerged triumphantly from Trump Tower with a promise in writing to support the party’s eventual nominee, whoever it would be, and not to run as a third party candidate.

The fact that Priebus (and soon, it seems, McDaniel) felt so self-satisfied about securing that pledge proves how readily the GOP wrongly believes it can appease a determined bully. This delivered some real Neville Chamberlain vibes, TBH.

Erstwhile GOP strategist turned chief Republican critic Rick Wilson wrote about Priebus’s supposed triumph in his book, Everything Trump Touches Dies.

Wilson recounted:

"Not long after Trump entered the race, Priebus feared Trump would bolt the party, run as an independent, and wreck the GOP’s chances against Hillary Clinton."
"He absurdly believed if he convinced Trump to sign a GOP loyalty pledge, Trump would support the party after he lost the primary and that the oath would moderate some of Red Hat Don’s more grotesque excesses."
"So Priebus went to Trump Tower with a cheesy parchment that looked like it was extracted from a bin of discount award certificates at Office Depot and run through a knockoff-brand inkjet printer and had Trump sign it."
"The chairman of the party of Lincoln got rolled like a rube off the cheap bus to Atlantic City on a Friday night. What Reince saw as a solemn oath, Trump saw as a reality-TV stunt."

The ruse of course was clear once the GOP primary debates actually got going.

There was this unforgettable moment in 2015, which McDaniel apparently still somehow forgot, when Trump was the sole candidate to raise his hand saying he would not pledge to support the eventual GOP nominee, whoever it was.

But wait!

Trump signed the pledge! How could he go back on his word? What a liar!

Anyone who thinks Trump honors actual legally binding contracts, let alone non-binding pledges, really ought not to be negotiating anything with him on behalf of the GOP or anyone for that matter.

This is the same guy who said, over and over, that he would release his taxes, that he would build the wall and get Mexico to pay for it, and that it was going to be infrastructure week any time now.

None of it was true. Trump could sign anything he’d like with McDaniel, but the minute he’s on that stage, it’s worthless.

The only possible reason I’ve seen anyone propose for why Trump might ultimately support the GOP candidate other than himself is if Trump were facing federal criminal charges or has been convicted of them and would like to angle for a presidential pardon.

And that raises one more rather insane but quite possible scenario next year in the upside down of the GOP: The most likely nominee of that increasingly broken party in 2024 is an ex-President facing multiple indictments for his criminal efforts to try and remain president by overturning the 2020 election.

In other words, the GOP will most likely nominate a criminal rather than risk him taking his voter base for himself.

And with that, the GOP will have reached yet another new bottom in its there-is-no-bottom universe.

More from News/2024-election

Gavin Newsom; Kid Rock
JP Yim/Getty Images for Clinton Global Initiative; Andrew Harnik/Getty Images

Gavin Newsom Epically Shuts Down Suggestion That Kid Rock Should Be Doing Super Bowl Halftime Show

Earlier this week, the NFL announced that worldwide superstar Bad Bunny would be the headliner for the 2026 Super Bowl Halftime Show, causing right-wing heads to explode over the news.

After far-right provocateur Nick Adams suggested that the singer, a fierce critic of the Trump administration, should not have been chosen for the halftime gig, California Governor Gavin Newsom's press office took to X to mock him in the account's now familiar Trump-esque style.

Keep ReadingShow less
One hand pouring pills into another.
person holding white round ornament

Absurd 'Cures' People With Chronic Illnesses Were Told To Try

Those suffering from a chronic illness often find themselves in over their heads with medication prescribed by their doctors.

Even so, many people add some homeopathic medications that won't be found at a pharmacy, but help them through their day-to-day lives.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bill Berrien
WISN 12 News/YYouTube

MAGA GOP Governor Candidate Drops Out After He's Caught Following Nonbinary Adult Performer Online

Wisconsin businessman and MAGA Republican Bill Berrien ended his 2026 gubernatorial campaign days after his online activities went public. A vocal transphobe, Berrien positioned himself as a strong supporter of MAGA Republican President Donald Trump and as the conservative "family values" GOP candidate.

He would have faced off against two Republican opponents in the GOP primary to see who would make it onto the the November 2026 general election ballot.

Keep ReadingShow less
David Cross
Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images

David Cross slams Saudi gig

It was no laughing matter when dozens of comedians signed on to perform at Saudi Arabia’s Riyadh Comedy Festival, which premiered last week and runs through October 9. Marketed as the “world’s largest comedy festival,” the event has been billed as a milestone for the kingdom’s entertainment industry.

Organized by Turki Al-Sheikh, Chairman of the General Entertainment Authority, the festival is part of Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 initiative to position the country as a hub for global cultural events. The lineup includes Kevin Hart, Aziz Ansari, Pete Davidson, Andrew Schulz, Jo Koy, Bill Burr, Jessica Kirson, Jimmy Carr, and Louis C.K.—yes, the same Louis C.K. accused by multiple women of sexual harassment in 2017.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bad Bunny
John Nacion/Variety via Getty Images

MAGA Fans Are Losing Their Minds After Latino Rapper Bad Bunny Is Picked For Super Bowl Halftime Show

Puerto Rican rapper and singer Bad Bunny has sent angry MAGA fans into overdrive after he, a vocal critic of the Trump administration, was announced as the performer set to headline the 2026 Super Bowl Halftime Show.

Bad Bunny will be the first Latin male artist to headline football's largest event, a historic achievement that he acknowledged in the following statement:

Keep ReadingShow less