Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Woman Who Pushed Commuter To Her Death In Front Of An Oncoming NYC Subway Train Sentenced

Woman Who Pushed Commuter To Her Death In Front Of An Oncoming NYC Subway Train Sentenced
CBS New York/YouTube

33-year-old Melanie Liverpool-Turner admitted to pushing Connie Watton, 49, off of the Times Square subway platform in 2016.

The crime incited a fear felt by many New Yorkers, and in doing so, propelled the story to the forefront of public awareness.


According to her attorney, Aaron Wallenstein, Liverpool-Turner had just been released from a psychiatric facility 5 days before she killed Watton. Before being admitted to the facility, she had falsely claimed to have pushed another person onto the subway tracks.

Police determined that individual had actually committed suicide, but prosecutors asserted that witnessing the suicide influenced her to kill Watton. Assistant District Attorney David Drucker argued in a court filing that it had "helped put in her mind the ideas and thoughts that led to" Watton's killing.

Prosecutors claimed that Liverpool-Turner's false statement indicated that she had:

"a motive or reason to commit this otherwise senseless and purposeless crime."

You can view CBS New York's coverage of the trial below:

Woman Who Pushed Stranger To Her Death On Subway Tracks Gets 20 Years To Lifewww.youtube.com

The attack against Watton was witnessed by other commuters, and one followed Liverpool-Turner to point her out to the police who responded. When police confronted her, prosecutors said that she told them that she had pushed someone onto the tracks.

Liverpool-Turner pleaded guilty to second degree murder last month and was sentenced on Friday to 20 years to life in prison.

Wallenstein commented on her taking responsibility for the killing:

"A woman lost her life and Ms. Liverpool took responsibility. She led an exemplary life until she had these illnesses and issues."

He further told The Associated Press that the case is a "tragedy, no matter how you look at it" and that Liverpool is remorseful, but intends to appeal the sentence.

After assigning the longest possible sentence for second degree murder, Justice Michael Obus characterized Watton's death:

"Thousands of people ride the subway every day. This is truly the quintessential urban nightmare - when a total stranger takes it upon themself to snuff out someone else's life."



The murder and the sentence raises questions about mental illness and the justice system. And unfortunately there are no easy answers.

More from Trending

Dolly Parton donating one million dollars to Hurricane Helene Relief
@yashar/X (Twitter)

Dolly Parton Pledges Massive Aid To Hurricane Helene Relief With Emotional Rendition Of 'Jolene'

In just days, Hurricane Helene has caused devastation across the southern and midwestern U.S., including a 500-mile path of destruction, terrible storms, and life-changing flooding.

Many have lost their homes. Some who did not lose their homes are without power, and others have lost more sentimental things, like the furry members of their family.

Keep ReadingShow less
Will Smith with Tommy Lee Jones from 'Men in Black'
Columbia Pictures

'Men In Black' Director Reveals Will Smith's Farts Were So Bad They Had To Evacuate The Set

Will Smith apparently left a lingering impression on Men in Black film director Barry Sonnenfeld, who raised a stink about Smith's intense farts on set.

"You really don't wanna be inside a very small hermetically sealed space with a Will Smith fart," said Sonnenfeld while recalling his time working with Smith in the 1997 sci-fi comedy film about government agents monitoring and policing extraterrestrials.

Keep ReadingShow less
Maye Musk and Elon Musk
Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic

Elon Musk's Mother Gets Blunt Fact-Check From X After Urging Republicans To Commit Voter Fraud

Maye Musk, the mother of Elon Musk, received a blunt fact-check after she posted a call for Republicans to "vote 10 times" and commit voter fraud.

Maye Musk quoted a post from her son before he spoke at former President Donald Trump’s rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, on Saturday. In the post, the billionaire urged:

Keep ReadingShow less
Andrew Garfleld; 'We Live in Time' movie poster
Carlos Alvarez/Getty Images, A24

Andrew Garfield Pays Hilarious Tribute To Horse That Went Viral For Photobombing Him

Andrew Garfield showed up at The Late Show With Stephen Colbert and cheekily paid a fashion homage to the wacky carousel horse that upstaged him and Florence Pugh in the poster for their new rom-com.

In August, a promotional first look of We Live in Time featured an image of the starring actors getting cuddly riding a carousel.

Keep ReadingShow less
Matthew Modine; Millie Bobby Brown
Mike Marsland/WireImage/Getty Images; Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images for Netflix

Matthew Modine Has Hilarious Reaction To Pic Of Him Officiating Millie Bobby Brown's Wedding

Matthew Modine officiated Millie Bobby Brown's wedding to Jake Bongiovi, son of rocker Jon Bon Jovi, and the actor left a hilarious comment on a post celebrating the occasion.

Modine, who played Dr. Martin Brenner, a.k.a. "Papa," opposite Brown's "Eleven" on Stranger Things, made an appearance on the final slide of Bongiovi's Instagram carousel, standing between the couple as the groom read his vows.

Keep ReadingShow less