Emails reviewed by The New York Times and authenticated by people who worked on the Trump campaign at the time show that Phoenix-based lawyer Jack Wilenchik regularly referred to "fake" electors, people who the campaign suggested be assembled and instructed to be Electoral College electors for then-President Donald Trump in battleground states he lost during the 2020 general election.
The so-called electors "were intended to provide Vice President Mike Pence and Mr. Trump’s allies in Congress a rationale for derailing the congressional process of certifying the outcome" of Democrat Joe Biden's win, per Times reporters Maggie Haberman and Luke Broadwater, who broke the story.
\u201cSCOOP: @lukebroadwater and I reviewed dozens of emails between Trump campaign officials and lawyers, including one in which a lawyer described the slates of electors they were putting together as \u201cfake\u201d https://t.co/P36lgMtFuA\u201d— Maggie Haberman (@Maggie Haberman) 1658856913
In one email dated Dec. 8, 2020, and sent to Boris Epshteyn, a strategic adviser for the Trump campaign, Wilenchik wrote the following:
“We would just be sending in ‘fake’ electoral votes to Pence so that ‘someone’ in Congress can make an objection when they start counting votes, and start arguing that the ‘fake’ votes should be counted."
In a follow-up email, Wilenchik wrote that “‘alternative’ votes is probably a better term than ‘fake’ votes," adding a smiley face emoji. This is what legal experts call consciousness of guilt.
In another email, Wilenchik said that Kelli Ward—a Republican who was aware of the "fake" electors plan—recommended trying “to keep it under wraps until Congress counts the vote Jan. 6th (so we can try to ‘surprise’ the Dems and media with it) — I tend to agree with her.”
Wilenchik proved to be quite passionate about these plans, and in the email on Dec. 8, 2020, he mentioned that he had been working on the following plan proposed by Kenneth Chesebro, an ally of Trump attorney John Eastman:
“His idea is basically that all of us (GA, WI, AZ, PA, etc.) have our electors send in their votes (even though the votes aren’t legal under federal law — because they’re not signed by the Governor); so that members of Congress can fight about whether they should be counted on January 6th."
"Kind of wild/creative — I’m happy to discuss."
"My comment to him was that I guess there’s no harm in it, (legally at least) — i.e. we would just be sending in ‘fake’ electoral votes to [Vice President Mike] Pence so that ‘someone’ in Congress can make an objection when they start counting votes, and start arguing that the ‘fake’ votes should be counted.”
Although the group went so far as to appoint a "point person" who was tasked with coordinating with electors who had agreed to sign false documents, the plan fell apart when they found that governmental authorities were not willing to cooperate.
The news quickly gained traction and Wilenchik was called out in particular, with many calling for him to be disbarred.
\u201c\ud83e\udd14Will Jack Wilenchik, a Phoenix-based lawyer who helped organize the pro-Trump \u201cfake electors\u201d in Arizona lose his license to practice law\u2049\ufe0fEmails reveal the details of the fake electors plan - which Jack advised should be called \u201calternative electors.\u201d https://t.co/3cecigyWCs\u201d— Venture Capital (@Venture Capital) 1658859832
\u201cJack Wilenchik should be disbarred for this\u201d— Brion Neeley-Ryder \ud83c\udff3\ufe0f\u200d\ud83c\udf08 (@Brion Neeley-Ryder \ud83c\udff3\ufe0f\u200d\ud83c\udf08) 1658861489
\u201c\u201cWe would just be sending in \u2018fake\u2019 electoral votes to Pence \u2026[.]\u201d #JackWilenchik\n\nDisbar every single attorney involved in this attempted overthrow. EXPEDITIOUSLY.\u201d— \ud80c\udc65 Glaistig \ud80c\udc80 (@\ud80c\udc65 Glaistig \ud80c\udc80) 1658863048
\u201cSeems like Jack Wilenchik is gonna be going through some things.\u201d— j-dub (@j-dub) 1658862056
\u201c\u201cAlternative" votes is probably a better term than fake votes. \ud83d\ude42\n\n- Real email quote from AZ attorney Jack Wilenchik (complete with emoji) on the fake elector scheme to overturn the will of the American people. \n\nLock. Them. Up.\u201d— MM (@MM) 1658887388
\u201cNYTimes indicates today that John \u201cJack\u201d D. Wilenchik knew he was sending "fake" electors to Wash. DC to gum up the works.\n\nCall his office like I did today and complain that he is destroying democracy. He should be in jail.\n\n(602) 606-2810\n\nhttps://t.co/ZKWl5YBQkS\u201d— \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\udde6 Author of Concerning Trump: Historical Quotes (@\ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\udde6 Author of Concerning Trump: Historical Quotes) 1658861536
\u201cAmerica, meet Jack Wilenchik,seen here digesting the kitten he had for lunch.\n\nJack is a Phoenix lawyer who helped tfg & Team Crazy devise the #FakeElector scheme to overthrow the election.\n\nNewly released emails by the Jan 6 Committee reveal that Jack knew the scheme was illegal\u201d— Earthen Vessel Sanctified By Almighty God (@Earthen Vessel Sanctified By Almighty God) 1658888030
\u201cJack Wilenchik is a perfect Grisham novel name for the strip mall lawyer who spoils the whole conspiracy.\u201d— zeddy (@zeddy) 1658861453
\u201cJack Wilenchik thinks that committing election fraud and plotting a coup is funny.\u201d— Venture Capital (@Venture Capital) 1658859832
The emails, part of a larger trove of communication showing how multiple members of Trump's inner circle conspired to help him overturn the results of an election Biden won decisively, are the latest development in a larger story largely focused on Trump's actions on January 6, 2021, the day a mob of his supporters attacked the United States Capitol on the false premise the election had been stolen.
Emails were regularly sent to Epshteyn, who coordinated with people inside and outside the Trump campaign and the White House. Epshteyn was in regular contact with John Eastman, who openly planned to derail the certification of the Electoral College on January 6.
Epshteyn also passed along messages to Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani—even sending him the detailed plan Eastman had mapped out—but also handled "questions about how to pay Mr. Eastman and made the arrangements for him to visit the White House on Jan. 4, 2021," per the report.
While multiple individuals were involved in the plot, none of the emails were shared with other lawyers or the lawyers in the White House Counsel’s Office, who had informed the White House that the "fake" electors plan had no legal standing.
During its most recent hearing, the House Select Committee tasked with investigating the January 6 insurrection presented a cohesive timeline of what Trump did—and did not do—during a crucial 187-minute period while the attack was underway.
The committee said that Trump had shown "complete dereliction of duty" after witnesses testified that he ignored pleas to condemn the violence and call off the mob.
White House officials said that Trump did not make any calls to the Secretary of Defense, the Attorney General or the Secretary of Homeland Security during the attack and that he sat in the dining room and watched the attack on television.
