Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

South Carolina Court Sides With School That Rejected 4th Grader's Pro-Trans Essay For Not Being 'Age-Appropriate'

South Carolina Court Sides With School That Rejected 4th Grader's Pro-Trans Essay For Not Being 'Age-Appropriate'
FluxFactory/Getty Images

The South Carolina Fourth Circuit court has ruled in favor of Anderson Mill Elementary School, a public school in Moore, SC, for disincluding a student's pro-trans inclusion essay in a school publication, calling the subject "not age appropriate."

Principal Elizabeth Foster initially rejected the student's essay on the basis that its content "make other parents upset … due to the type of school this is, the people that work here and the students and families of the students that go here."

The student's essay (in part) read:

"I don't know if you know this but peoples view on Transgenders is an issue. People think that men should not dress like a woman, and saying mean things. They think that they are choosing the wrong thing in life. In the world people can choose who they want."

Foster told the student's mother that the essay would be rejected because it was "not age-appropriate to discuss transgenders, lesbians and drag queens outside of the home," and suggested that the student change their subject to bullying instead.

The family then took the matter to court, claiming that Anderson Mill and Foster violated the child's first amendment right to free speech by blocking the essay, and that Foster caused the child and parent emotional harm.

Unfortunately, U.S. Circuit Judge Stephanie Thacker (Fourth Circuit) rejected the claim and sided with the school.

Pointing to a precedent set by a 1988 case Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier, in which the court ruled that a school could censor its students for anything "reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns," which in this case seems to include learning about anti-trans prejudice.

The school's argument that they "need to be able to account for the emotional maturity level of the intended audience" was accepted by Thacker, though she did raise concerns surrounding the "pedagogical efficacy of shielding fourth graders from topics like sexuality and gender identity."

"Fourth graders can understand the basic principle of treating all people with dignity and respect, including a grandparent who also happens to be transgender," said Paul D. Castillo, a lawyer and students' rights activist with pro-LGBTQ+ legal group Lambda Legal.

"Even the youngest elementary school student can grasp the anti-bullying concept that 'hate hurts.'"

Thacker's decision to allow the censorship to stand was a little less explicit surrounding the actual content.

"Principal Foster's initial refusal to include [the student's] essay in the fourth grade class's essay booklet was actuated at least in part by her concern that the essay's topic was 'not age appropriate' for fourth graders."

The other two sitting judges, Paul V. Niemeyer, appointed by George H.W. Bush, and Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson, appointed by Ronald Reagan, did not offer a dissenting opinion.

However, the fight may not be over for the student and her parents. According to Castillo, similar cases have found that there is nothing "inherently age-inappropriate about speaking in support of an LGBTQ family member." The student's grandfather, in this case, is reportedly gay and an activist.

Castillo also says that the school publishing these essays removes their ability to completely censor the topic.

"We call that a public forum, or at least a limited one, where you're inviting them to that case the regulation the school can do is only the time, place and manner, but not under a particular viewpoint."

It is unclear if the family will pursue the case further.

More from News

shocked woman
Olivia Hutcherson on Unsplash

People Break Down The Most Brutal Insults They've Ever Heard

Let's be honest, it doesn't take any talent to insult someone.

After all, by the time children learn to speak in complete sentences, they're hurling sophisticated comebacks like:

Keep ReadingShow less
Dubai Princess Publicly Demands 'Divorce' From Cheating Royal Husband In Blunt Instagram Post

Dubai Princess Publicly Demands 'Divorce' From Cheating Royal Husband In Blunt Instagram Post

In an unexpected move, Her Highness Sheikha Mahra bint Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, the Dubai princess, addressed her husband's infidelity on Instagram, declaring their divorce.

Sheikha Mahra, who is daughter of the UAE Vice President and Prime Minister, His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, wrote a scathing and short message to her husband.

Keep ReadingShow less
TikTok screenshot of Jodi Benson watching daughter sing; Ariel from the 1989 'The Little Mermaid'
@coolzjay/TikTok; Disney

'Little Mermaid' Star Jodi Benson Tears Up Watching Daughter Sing 'Part Of Your World' On Stage

A clip of the original voice of Ariel, Jodi Benson, watching her daughter Delaney play the lead role in a stage production of The Little Mermaid has gone viral, and Benson revealed she was moved to tears by the performance.

Posted to TikTok, the video has already garnered more than 4.2 million views in only a few days, and people on the platform said they got a bit emotional, as well.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kate Beckinsale

Kate Beckinsale's Custom Swimsuit Sends Blunt Message To Her Haters Online

British actor Kate Beckinsale has no time for trolls criticizing her looks.

Instead of addressing haters' unsolicited assessments of her online, the 50-year-old actor came for them with a fierce fashion statement that said it all.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kit Connor
Karwai Tang/WireImage/GettyImages

Kit Connor Is Rumored To Be Top Choice For Gay MCU Superhero—And 'Heartstopper' Fans Are So Into It

Fans of Heartstopper were absolutely chuffed and crossing their fingers after hearing rumors that British actor Kit Connor was being considered to play a known LGBTQ+ superhero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

The 20-year-old has been acting since he was just 8 in numerous TV and film projects, including roles in the 2018 films The Mercy, and The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. He also portrayed a teenaged Elton John in 2019's Rocketman and voiced Pantalaimon in the HBO fantasy series His Dark Materials.

Keep ReadingShow less