Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

South Carolina Court Sides With School That Rejected 4th Grader's Pro-Trans Essay For Not Being 'Age-Appropriate'

South Carolina Court Sides With School That Rejected 4th Grader's Pro-Trans Essay For Not Being 'Age-Appropriate'
FluxFactory/Getty Images

The South Carolina Fourth Circuit court has ruled in favor of Anderson Mill Elementary School, a public school in Moore, SC, for disincluding a student's pro-trans inclusion essay in a school publication, calling the subject "not age appropriate."

Principal Elizabeth Foster initially rejected the student's essay on the basis that its content "make other parents upset … due to the type of school this is, the people that work here and the students and families of the students that go here."



The student's essay (in part) read:

"I don't know if you know this but peoples view on Transgenders is an issue. People think that men should not dress like a woman, and saying mean things. They think that they are choosing the wrong thing in life. In the world people can choose who they want."



Foster told the student's mother that the essay would be rejected because it was "not age-appropriate to discuss transgenders, lesbians and drag queens outside of the home," and suggested that the student change their subject to bullying instead.

The family then took the matter to court, claiming that Anderson Mill and Foster violated the child's first amendment right to free speech by blocking the essay, and that Foster caused the child and parent emotional harm.

Unfortunately, U.S. Circuit Judge Stephanie Thacker (Fourth Circuit) rejected the claim and sided with the school.




Pointing to a precedent set by a 1988 case Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier, in which the court ruled that a school could censor its students for anything "reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns," which in this case seems to include learning about anti-trans prejudice.

The school's argument that they "need to be able to account for the emotional maturity level of the intended audience" was accepted by Thacker, though she did raise concerns surrounding the "pedagogical efficacy of shielding fourth graders from topics like sexuality and gender identity."

"Fourth graders can understand the basic principle of treating all people with dignity and respect, including a grandparent who also happens to be transgender," said Paul D. Castillo, a lawyer and students' rights activist with pro-LGBTQ+ legal group Lambda Legal.

"Even the youngest elementary school student can grasp the anti-bullying concept that 'hate hurts.'"



Thacker's decision to allow the censorship to stand was a little less explicit surrounding the actual content.

"Principal Foster's initial refusal to include [the student's] essay in the fourth grade class's essay booklet was actuated at least in part by her concern that the essay's topic was 'not age appropriate' for fourth graders."

The other two sitting judges, Paul V. Niemeyer, appointed by George H.W. Bush, and Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson, appointed by Ronald Reagan, did not offer a dissenting opinion.

However, the fight may not be over for the student and her parents. According to Castillo, similar cases have found that there is nothing "inherently age-inappropriate about speaking in support of an LGBTQ family member." The student's grandfather, in this case, is reportedly gay and an activist.

Castillo also says that the school publishing these essays removes their ability to completely censor the topic.

"We call that a public forum, or at least a limited one, where you're inviting them to speak...in that case the regulation the school can do is only the time, place and manner, but not under a particular viewpoint."

It is unclear if the family will pursue the case further.

More from Trending

Country Singer Gavin Adcock went on a drunken rant over Beyonce's "Cowboy Carter" success.
Danielle Del Valle/Getty Images; Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for The Recording Academy

Country singer rants over Beyoncé album

Country singer Gavin Adcock became the title of his next album, “Own Worst Enemy,” after going on an unhinged rant about the legitimacy of Beyoncé's Grammy-winning and record-breaking Cowboy Carter in the country music genre.

Adcock, whose upcoming album is set for release next month, was filmed during a live performance last weekend, complaining that Beyoncé and her album are not “country music.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Dionne Warwick; Tiny Chef
Astrida Valigorsky/Getty Images; @ToonHive/X

Dionne Warwick Is Ready To Go To War With Nickelodeon Over 'Tiny Chef' Cancellation

You know your campaign against a show's cancellation is achieving widespread attention when you get people like venerated singer Dionne Warwick advocating for you.

Nickelodeon's The Tiny Chef Show was recently cancelled, much to the dismay of its viewers and creators. It was also a genuinely surprising decision, since the show has won an Emmy.

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman relaxing in sunhat and sunglasses
Photo by Jordan Bauer on Unsplash

People Explain Which 'Small Luxuries' They Can't Live Without

Many of us have committed to being fairly financially frugal and not overspending on silly, unnecessary things.

That is to say, sometimes, it's fun to splurge on something one time to see what it's like to experience that small luxury.

Keep ReadingShow less
two women in emotional distress seated on couch
Ben White on Unsplash

People Who've Experienced Grief Share The Most Tone-Deaf Things They've Heard

Grief, loss, trauma are all part of life. But for most people, the emotions and reactions that go with them are difficult to witness.

So they rely on platitudes to fill any holes in conversation. That's rarely a good idea.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump
Mehmet Eser/Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images

Trump Demands 'Boss Of AT&T' Fix Equipment After Failed Conference Call In Bizarre Meltdown

When most of us have technical difficulties, we contact tech support or customer service.

But if you're President of the United States, just ranting on social media—then having your White House Press Secretary post a screenshot of your post on a social media platform people actually use—is apparently the answer.

Keep ReadingShow less