Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Designers of Donald Trump's Border Wall Prototypes May Have to Go Back to the Drawing Board After They Failed Multiple Tests

Designers of Donald Trump's Border Wall Prototypes May Have to Go Back to the Drawing Board After They Failed Multiple Tests
US President Donald Trump inspects border wall prototypes at Otay Mesa near San Diego, California on March 13, 2018. (Photo by MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images)

Uh-oh.

Back in March, President Donald Trump took a trip to Otay Mesa near San Diego to look at various prototypes for his border wall. A sample section of eight options were built on the site at the cost of $300,000-$500,000 each—with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) paying the $2.4 million-$4 million bill.

Back in September 2017, DHS awarded eight contracts to companies to develop prototypes for the Trump administration’s proposed wall along the nearly 2,000 mile US-Mexico border. Contracts were split evenly into concrete and non-concrete walls.


Border Wall Prototypes during the Wall Prototype Construction Project near the Otay Mesa Port of Entry. (DHS/CBP Photo by: Mani Albrecht)

Eight prototypes—used as a visual aid for President Trump's visit to Otay Mesa—remain untouched on site. Vice President Mike Pence also reviewed the prototypes during a separate visit.

If possible, DHS could eventually incorporate some or all of these display models in the finished border wall infrastructure. For now, the multi-million dollar project acts as the banner photo for the Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) website.

Banner image on CBP website. (cbp.gov)

In addition to the Otay Mesa set of prototypes, contractors built eight duplicates at an undisclosed location so DHS could conduct testing of the walls for: breaching, climbing, digging, stability and other safety protocols according to the original plans. DHS paid another $2.4 million-$4 million for those as well.

The next phase began with teams from CBP and the US military's Special Operations Command and members of the U.S. Marine Corps. That step did not go so well according to a heavily redacted report released by CBP.

Teams breached prototypes 13 times. Test crews made one prototype wall completely "unstable" to the point of collapse.

A representative for CBP stated—in defense of the prototypes failing grade—that specialized equipment and planning went into the successful breaches. But Andrea Guerrero of Alliance San Diego, a non-profit supporting social equality and immigrants, stated:

"It's troubling because this wall is a wasteful wall, a harmful wall and an irresponsible wall. The report confirms what we've always believed: that this is a bad idea."

The tactical teams tried to breach, scale or otherwise penetrate the walls in a real-life scenario. However the report makes no mention of tunneling or digging tests despite original plans and the documented frequency of this method in real life situations.

In a CBP statement issued Monday, they clarified:

"As is the case with any barrier, the eight border wall prototypes were not and cannot be designed to be indestructible. Rather, this capability enables Border Patrol to impede or deny efforts to scale, breach, or dig under such a barrier, giving agents time to respond."

CBP did not include any information on how the multi-billion dollar proposed wall improves over the walls already along the southern border that also enable Border Patrol to impede or deny efforts to scale, breach, or dig under such a barrier, giving agents time to respond.

The project already at $20 million for just the prototypes requires significant improvements before any final decisions or construction plan implementation. But with all prototypes failing the "impenetrable" test, some may need to be scrapped completely.

But how much will that cost?

A General Accounting Office (GAO) report released this summer warned of underestimated costs for the proposed border wall. Prototypes in Otay Mesa stand on flat ground, but the 2,000 mile border covers a great variety of topography.

CBP union spokesman Joshua Wilson said:

"The wall is never going to be all end all, but what it is able to do is it able to slow down illegal traffic crossing the border and gives the border patrol not only a safer environment to work in, but it also allows us time to identify and interdict that traffic and deploy appropriate resources to deal with it."

"What I think we'll see is a hybrid of several different designs taking the best features of each."

But the trial and error is coming at taxpayer expense, which is unusual in and of itself.

When the Defense Department (DoD) decides they need a new military aircraft or ship design, contractors produce and test prototypes on their own dime. Then their tested and completed prototypes compete to win the eventual contract for design and building.

Research and development for military prototypes is funded by the contractors competing for the job, not the government. So why is DHS going against convention? Why are contractors not performing all R&D to produce prototypes that will fully meet the needs specified by DHS, then pitting their fully tested design against the others?

DHS took over the expense of the design and testing phase on a project already flagged by GAO as being more expensive than originally anticipated. And with the complete failure of all prototypes, the $20 million already spent on this phase is essentially wasted.

In addition to funding improved or redesigned prototypes, there are other costs GAO flagged that the Trump administration did not include in their original wall cost analysis.

Issues related to land ownership also increase the final cost. While land can be taken under eminent domain, fair market value must be paid to the land holders. And an assessment to determine fair market value must be paid for as well.

In addition to seizing land from private individuals with property near the border, the Tohono O'odham Nation's traditional homeland straddles the border with Mexico. The tribe stated many times they will not allow the wall to be built on their sovereign land.

The Tohono O'Odham work with the CBP and already greatly reduced border incursions through their land. They maintain, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it."

After several attacks by those in favor of the wall misrepresenting their views, the tribe created a video to explain their stance against the wall.

And none of this addresses the effectiveness of a wall when statistically, more people enter the United States through conventional transportation—like planes, boats and buses with valid visas—than walk across the southern border.

Most enter the United States legally on temporary work or student or tourist visas. When their visas expire, they remain in the US.

Immigration experts maintain using funds being spent on Trump's wall could be better used creating effective methods of keeping track of people on temporary visas.

While "Build the Wall" played well in rallies for Trump, the cost, the lack of effectiveness and now the failure of his prototypes is proving that reality is more difficult than the President ever imagined.

More from People/donald-trump

Screenshots of Will Thilly breakdancing
New York Post/YouTube

Guy Breakdances His Way Into Town Hall Meeting To Ask Why Taxes Went Up—And Becomes An Instant Legend

Cranford, New Jersey town council candidate Will Thilly went viral after dancing his way up to the podium at a recent town hall meeting to ask why property taxes in Cranford have gone "up so much."

Thilly's unique tax protest began when he danced his way up to the podium and continued to dance even after a Cranford Township official said, "Mr. Thilly, I started your time." People laughed when Thilly held up a finger to stop the official and continued to dance anyway.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Brian Kilmeade
Fox News

Fox News Host Apologizes After His Suggestion That Homeless People Be Euthanized Sparks Outrage

Fox and Friends host Brian Kilmeade was criticized for suggesting that homeless people with mental health issues get "involuntary lethal injection" after the murder of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska on a train in North Carolina—and was swiftly condemned for an insincere apology several days after the fact as many are calling for Fox News to terminate his contract.

Zarutska was stabbed to death at the East/West Boulevard station on the Lynx Blue Line in Charlotte last month; her killer, a homeless man with a history of mental health issues, has since been charged with first-degree murder.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sofía Vergara
Bryan Steffy/Getty Images

Sofía Vergara Reveals She Missed Presenting At The Emmys Due To 'Craziest' Medical Emergency

Almost everyone has a favorite television show they like to turn on at the end of a rough day or binge-watch for a bit of nostalgia, and most of us pretty frequently check out new shows to see if we can spot a favorite.

Needless to say, the Emmys award show is a huge deal every year, honoring all of the people involved in the projects that are currently gracing the small screen, and basically anyone who's anyone will attend.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rep. Nancy Mace
CNN

Nancy Mace Just Tried To Claim She's Never 'Dehumanized' Her Colleagues—And The Internet Brought The Receipts

South Carolina Republican Representative Nancy Mace was called out for hypocrisy after she claimed on CNN that Democrats in Congress have been "dehumanizing" Republicans, a move she would "never" do—despite her record of doing just that.

Speaking to anchor Katie Bolduan while the search for the suspect who killed far-right activist Charlie Kirk was ongoing, Mace objected to Bolduan's observation that she was using "us v. them" language, only saying that things are "very one-sided right now." She also suggested that the situation is so bad for her that she's actually afraid of "just walking out in public."

Keep ReadingShow less
A younger man stand on top of a mountain with his arms outreached and his face looking to the sky. It's a beautiful day and lakes and mountains are the backdrop.
Photo by Kyle Loftus on Unsplash

People Who Quit Their High-Paying Jobs For Happiness Explain How It Turned Out

Sometimes money isn't the goal.

It is a BIG goal for many.

Keep ReadingShow less