Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Film Critic Dragged After Penning Scathing Review Of 'Shrek' For The Film's 20th Anniversary

Film Critic Dragged After Penning Scathing Review Of 'Shrek' For The Film's 20th Anniversary
Dreamworks

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

But that isn't to say people won't argue against those opinions like they've taken another full-time job.


So when film critic Scott Tobias of The Guardian shared his criticism of Shrek, and on its 20th Anniversary no less, ogre fans were ready for him.

The article dropped on Tuesday this week and was full of punches against the quirky film.

Tobias wrote:

"The fairytale comedy was a hit with critics and audiences but its toilet humor, glibness, and shoddy animation mark it out as a misfire."

He felt the film contributed nothing positive to the world of animation.

"Twenty years later, that flushing sound (at the beginning of the film) seems to signify the moment when blockbuster animation circled the drain."
"Shrek is a terrible movie. It's not funny. It looks awful."
"It would influence many unfunny, awful-looking computer-animated comedies that copied its formula of glib self-reference and sickly sweet sentimentality."
"Three of those terrible movies were sequels to Shrek and one was a spin-off with a sequel in the works. The curse has eased but not lifted."

To his mind, it didn't do anyone any favors, period.

"In the end, Shrek didn't save DreamWorks from setting itself off a few years later."
"It didn't extend [Mike] Myers's career past a hard expiration date. And Katzenberg went on to found Quibi."
"The entire enterprise is better left in the past."

Tobias was so proud of his critique, he even boasted about it on Twitter.

But fans of Shrek and those excited for the 20th Anniversary weren't about to take this sitting down.

Some couldn't believe anyone would even write such a critique.




Others were really miffed with specific aspects of the review.

They had their rebuttals ready.



Some were simply offended or felt they had been betrayed.




But... there were those small few who understood where Tobias was coming from.




The old saying goes, "You can't make everyone happy," and that strands true, whether it's for a much-loved animated film like Shrek or for a critique of the film by Scott Tobias.

There are going to be avid fans and lackluster never-watched-its, as well as those who wildly disagree or quietly nod their heads.

More from Trending

Pete Hegseth; Kid Rock
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images; Nathan Posner/Anadolu via Getty Images

Pete Hegseth Just Took Kid Rock For A Joy Ride In An Army Helicopter—And People Are Furious

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was called out after announcing in a post on X that he'd taken MAGA musician Kid Rock along for "a ride this morning" in a U.S. Army Apache helicopter.

Kid Rock—real name Robert James Ritchie—was invited by Hegseth to discuss the Iran War and the blockade in the Strait of Hormuz with members of the military and other officials.

Keep ReadingShow less
A young boy cries inside a claw machine as firefighters work to rescue him.
@eric_hz143/X

Wisconsin Firefighters Go Viral After Rescuing Boy Who Got Stuck Inside Claw Machine—And The Internet Has Questions

There are plenty of childhood rites of passage, like scraped knees, questionable snack choices, and an unwavering belief that the claw machine is winnable. (Hint: it's not.) But one Wisconsin kid took that curiosity a step further, somehow ending up inside the very game designed to relieve him of his allowance.

How he landed in there is a mystery, but he was rescued from the machine almost as soon as firefighters arrived. As crews moved into position, the boy clutched the pile of plush toys around him, peering out through the glass.

Keep ReadingShow less
Courteney Cox, winner of the 'Artists' Inspiration Award', Jennifer Aniston, and Lisa Kudrow attend SAG-AFTRA Foundation.
Gregg DeGuire/Getty Images for SAG-AFTRA Foundation

Lisa Kudrow Just Sounded Off On The Gross Behind-The-Scenes Treatment Her Female 'Friends' Costars Were Subjected To

Two decades after Friends defined a generation of sitcom television, Lisa Kudrow is pulling back the curtain on what she describes as a “mean” and at times inappropriate behind-the-scenes culture that didn’t treat its female stars equally.

While the NBC hit sold audiences on the easy chemistry of six tight-knit friends, Kudrow talked about a writers’ room dominated by men and shaped by behavior that often crossed the line. In a recent interview with the Times, Kudrow pointed to an overwhelmingly male writers’ room of 12–15 people as a key force shaping that dynamic.

Keep ReadingShow less
Millie Bobby Brown
Netflix

Millie Bobby Brown's Upcoming 'Enola Holmes' Sequel Is Getting Roasted After Fans Notice Bizarrely Modern Detail In Promo Pic

One thing about beauty standards is that they change drastically over time. That does not seem to have occurred to the good people at Netflix, however.

The platform just released first looks at the third film in its series Enola Holmes, set in the 1800s and starring Stranger Things actor Millie Bobby Brown.

Keep ReadingShow less
AT&T Stadium at Texas Tech
John E. Moore III/Getty Images

Texas Tech Just Banned The Teaching Of All LGBTQ+ Topics In Classrooms—And Critics Are Sounding Off

A new memo issued by the Texas Tech University System (TTUS) chancellor impacting programs and course content across their five campuses drew sharp criticism for its bigotry in the form of restrictions on LGBTQ+ topics in the classroom to comply with the state's Reforming Faculty Senates Act.

TTUS is a public, state-funded group established in 1999 and includes Texas Tech University, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, Angelo State University, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center El Paso, and Midwestern State University.

Keep ReadingShow less