Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Film Critic Dragged After Penning Scathing Review Of 'Shrek' For The Film's 20th Anniversary

Film Critic Dragged After Penning Scathing Review Of 'Shrek' For The Film's 20th Anniversary
Dreamworks
Make us preferred on Google

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

But that isn't to say people won't argue against those opinions like they've taken another full-time job.


So when film critic Scott Tobias of The Guardian shared his criticism of Shrek, and on its 20th Anniversary no less, ogre fans were ready for him.

The article dropped on Tuesday this week and was full of punches against the quirky film.

Tobias wrote:

"The fairytale comedy was a hit with critics and audiences but its toilet humor, glibness, and shoddy animation mark it out as a misfire."

He felt the film contributed nothing positive to the world of animation.

"Twenty years later, that flushing sound (at the beginning of the film) seems to signify the moment when blockbuster animation circled the drain."
"Shrek is a terrible movie. It's not funny. It looks awful."
"It would influence many unfunny, awful-looking computer-animated comedies that copied its formula of glib self-reference and sickly sweet sentimentality."
"Three of those terrible movies were sequels to Shrek and one was a spin-off with a sequel in the works. The curse has eased but not lifted."

To his mind, it didn't do anyone any favors, period.

"In the end, Shrek didn't save DreamWorks from setting itself off a few years later."
"It didn't extend [Mike] Myers's career past a hard expiration date. And Katzenberg went on to found Quibi."
"The entire enterprise is better left in the past."

Tobias was so proud of his critique, he even boasted about it on Twitter.

But fans of Shrek and those excited for the 20th Anniversary weren't about to take this sitting down.

Some couldn't believe anyone would even write such a critique.




Others were really miffed with specific aspects of the review.

They had their rebuttals ready.



Some were simply offended or felt they had been betrayed.




But... there were those small few who understood where Tobias was coming from.




The old saying goes, "You can't make everyone happy," and that strands true, whether it's for a much-loved animated film like Shrek or for a critique of the film by Scott Tobias.

There are going to be avid fans and lackluster never-watched-its, as well as those who wildly disagree or quietly nod their heads.

More from Trending

John Oliver
HBO

John Oliver Lands Guest-Starring Part On 'General Hospital' And 'Days Of Our Lives' After Begging For 'Juicy' Soap Role—And Fans Are Pumped

What's comedian and late-night host John Oliver's next big project? Something incisively and hilariously political like his HBO show Last Week Tonight, right?

Wrong! It's soap operas. Yes, those soap operas, the afternoon melodramas that have been running every weekday for decades and decades.

Keep ReadingShow less
Abigail Velez
ABC7

Bosnia Claps Back Hard After U.S. Soccer Reporter Brags That She Can't Find The Country On A Map

ABC7 Los Angeles reporter Abigail Velez faced online anger over an ignorant jab at one of the nations competing in the FIFA World Cup.

Velez was covering the U.S. national team’s match on Thursday, a 3-2 loss to Turkey, when she noted the team's next match-up. Bosnia and Herzegovina is slated to face off against the United States in the round of 32 on Wednesday.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Peter Doocy and Fox host talking overlooking the Great American State Fair
Fox News

Fox News Dragged For Claiming 'People Are Still Coming Out' To Trump's Great American State Fair As Live Video Shows Otherwise

Fox News was widely mocked after White House correspondent Peter Doocy said on the air that "people are still coming out" to President Donald Trump's Great American State Fair despite their live footage showing hardly anyone in attendance.

Crowds were relatively light, according to several news organizations, with The Washington Post reporting that opening-day attendance was "relatively sparse compared with past National Mall events." The Post even said that “The crowd thinly covered an area about the length of the National Museum of American History, smaller than some more outdoor movie screenings.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Zohran Mamdani
Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images

'New York Post' Roasted Over Eyeroll-Worthy Headline About Mamdani Jumping In NYC Pool For Summer Tradition

The New York Post drew widespread mockery after publishing a story accusing New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani of "violating dress code rules" when he jumped into the Thomas Jefferson Pool in East Harlem wearing his signature suit, socks, and dress shoes instead of changing into swimwear as he joined residents cooling off.

The publication posted an article to X titled "Zohran Mamdani jumps into NYC pool to kick off summer tradition - while violating dress code rules" complete with photos of Mamdani jumping into the pool.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump
Andrew Harnik/Getty Images

Trump Dragged For Not Understanding How Passports Work After Claiming New Ones Featuring His Image Will Include Bizarre Warning Phrase

President Donald Trump was widely mocked after appearing not to understand how passports work while unveiling a new rendering of a special-edition U.S. passport marking America's 250th anniversary that he claims will include the phrase "Welcome, but be good!"

Trump's post comes weeks after the State Department announced it will issue a limited run of commemorative passports for the 250th anniversary of the country's founding featuring an image of Trump, making him the first living president ever depicted on a U.S. passport.

Keep ReadingShow less