Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Film Critic Dragged After Penning Scathing Review Of 'Shrek' For The Film's 20th Anniversary

Film Critic Dragged After Penning Scathing Review Of 'Shrek' For The Film's 20th Anniversary
Dreamworks

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

But that isn't to say people won't argue against those opinions like they've taken another full-time job.


So when film critic Scott Tobias of The Guardian shared his criticism of Shrek, and on its 20th Anniversary no less, ogre fans were ready for him.

The article dropped on Tuesday this week and was full of punches against the quirky film.

Tobias wrote:

"The fairytale comedy was a hit with critics and audiences but its toilet humor, glibness, and shoddy animation mark it out as a misfire."

He felt the film contributed nothing positive to the world of animation.

"Twenty years later, that flushing sound (at the beginning of the film) seems to signify the moment when blockbuster animation circled the drain."
"Shrek is a terrible movie. It's not funny. It looks awful."
"It would influence many unfunny, awful-looking computer-animated comedies that copied its formula of glib self-reference and sickly sweet sentimentality."
"Three of those terrible movies were sequels to Shrek and one was a spin-off with a sequel in the works. The curse has eased but not lifted."

To his mind, it didn't do anyone any favors, period.

"In the end, Shrek didn't save DreamWorks from setting itself off a few years later."
"It didn't extend [Mike] Myers's career past a hard expiration date. And Katzenberg went on to found Quibi."
"The entire enterprise is better left in the past."

Tobias was so proud of his critique, he even boasted about it on Twitter.

But fans of Shrek and those excited for the 20th Anniversary weren't about to take this sitting down.

Some couldn't believe anyone would even write such a critique.




Others were really miffed with specific aspects of the review.

They had their rebuttals ready.



Some were simply offended or felt they had been betrayed.




But... there were those small few who understood where Tobias was coming from.




The old saying goes, "You can't make everyone happy," and that strands true, whether it's for a much-loved animated film like Shrek or for a critique of the film by Scott Tobias.

There are going to be avid fans and lackluster never-watched-its, as well as those who wildly disagree or quietly nod their heads.

More from Trending

Screenshot of Cindy Hyde-Smith; a cow in a pasture
WLOX News Now; Silas Stein/Picture Alliance via Getty Images

MAGA Senator Faces Backlash For Dodging Question About High Beef Prices—And People Are Having A Cow

Mississippi Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith is facing backlash after dodging a question about high beef prices amid the nationwide affordability crisis and telling WLOX news viewers that they have "so many proteins to choose from."

Last month, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins claimed that food prices were coming down, even as the Consumer Price Index shows grocery costs rose 0.7% in December. Beef, which Rollins elevated near the top of the food pyramid in the dietary guidelines she recently unveiled, increased 1% over the month and was up 16.4% compared with a year earlier.

Keep ReadingShow less
Jamie Lee Curtis (left) pens a tribute to Robert Carradine (right) about their decades-long careers in Hollywood.
JC Olivera/Variety via Getty Images; Steve Granitz/FilmMagic via Getty Images

Jamie Lee Curtis Pens Poignant Tribute To 'First Love' Robert Carradine After His Tragic Death

Jamie Lee Curtis is remembering her “first love.”

The Oscar winner took to Instagram on Tuesday to mourn Robert Carradine, the beloved character actor best known for portraying Lewis Skolnick in Revenge of the Nerds and Sam McGuire in Lizzie McGuire. He was 71.

Keep ReadingShow less
Katherine Short and Martin Short
Gregg DeGuire/FilmMagic/Getty Images

Fans Are Being Reminded Of How Much Tragedy Martin Short Has Experienced After The Death Of His Daughter

There's a saying that the funniest people among us are typically the ones who have suffered the greatest losses or who struggle the most with their mental health, and Martin Short is unfortunately no exception.

While we've all experienced losses, Martin Short has suffered too much loss for one person, starting from a young age.

Keep ReadingShow less
Flavor Flav Extends Vegas Party To All U.S. Female Olympic Medal Winners After Trump Diss—And We Love To See It
Andrew Milligan/PA Images via Getty Images

Flavor Flav Extends Vegas Party To All U.S. Female Olympic Medal Winners After Trump Diss—And We Love To See It

Rap icon and TV personality Flavor Flav is really outdoing himself at the game of being a stand-up guy, especially where female Olympians are concerned!

Flav was one of the first celebrities to speak out after Donald Trump's disgusting sexist comments about the U.S. women's hockey team while congratulation the men's team on their gold medal.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump; Robert De Niro
Andrew Harnik/Getty Images; Monica Schipper/Getty Images

Trump Calls For Robert De Niro To Be Deported After His Blistering 'State Of The Swamp' Speech

President Donald Trump lashed out at actor Robert De Niro, threatening him with deportation after the legendary actor joined fellow celebrities and Democratic politicians for an alternative "State of the Swamp" event during Trump's rambling State of the Union address.

The event was put together by the anti-Trump organization Defiance.org alongside the artist-activist collective Portland Frog Brigade and the advocacy media network Courier. Organizers described it as a response to what they describe as "abuses of power" by Trump, as well as by figures who have previously served in his orbit.

Keep ReadingShow less