Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Your Online Genetic Data Could Be Used To Help Catch A Serial Killer—But Is It Ethical?

Open-source genealogy websites are being used to track down murder suspects, and questions are being raised on where the line should be drawn between the right to privacy and the need to protect the public.


In April of 2018, the Golden State Killer was caught after detectives used the DNA of the suspect's relatives to track him down. The genetic information had been shared on a public DNA website by distant cousins, which investigators were able to match to DNA found at various crime scenes.

Paul Holes, an individual who worked on the case, explained the painstaking work involved with using open-source DNA to solve open murders.

"That is a huge undertaking. It took us four months of genealogy work to eventually find the two top people that fit our offender's profile. It's not something you're going to do on a burglary or a petty theft. It is going to be on your major, major homicide cases because it is so manpower-intensive.

It is tough, tough work."

And while catching a serial killer is certainly a noble cause, concerns are arising over the lack of protections and limits on such personal data.


"We all want a serial killer caught," genealogist CeCe Moore told Bloomberg last week. "But what other applications could it be used for that maybe we would not be so in favor of?"

Jennifer Lynch, a senior attorney with Electronic Frontier Foundation, also told Bloomberg that there need to be protections on how personal genetic data can be accessed and used by law enforcement.

"Criminal court cases thus far have treated DNA data like a fingerprint. There are no meaningful protections. And we need them."

The American Civil Liberties Union has also weighed in on this issue, warning companies that collect DNA information from the public that their customers' data cannot be used in criminal investigations.

"All of these companies should make clear that the genetic material they collect from users is not available to serve as legal proof and that law enforcement cannot use their services to test prisoners and arrested individuals or to conduct investigations," wrote the ACLU's Vera Eidelman in an op-ed in the Washington Post. "Otherwise, the public may have to choose between accessing the benefits of genetic science and maintaining its privacy rights."

23andMe has said that it does not voluntarily share genetic data with law enforcement and that the company has "successfully challenged" requests for data from law enforcement.

"We treat law enforcement inquiries, such as a valid subpoena or court order, very seriously," 23andMe Inc.'s privacy chief, Kate Black, said in an interview. "23andMe policies prohibit our voluntary cooperation with law enforcement in order to protect our customers' privacy. To date, we have successfully challenged the law enforcement requests we've received."

Online genetic databases are also subject to hacking. "Israel-based MyHeritage said last week that 92 million accounts were compromised," reported Bloomberg.

More from Trending

Jasmine Crockett Calls Out Trump's Hypocrisy By Pointing Out How Melania Got Her Visa
Leigh Vogel/Getty Images for SiriusXM; Kayla Bartkowski/Getty Images

Jasmine Crockett Calls Out Trump's Hypocrisy By Pointing Out How Melania Got Her Visa

Texas Democratic Representative Jasmine Crockett pointed out President Donald Trump's hypocrisy on immigration considering how First Lady Melania Trump's pathway to citizenship was possible because she received an "Einstein visa," which is usually reserved for an individual with "some sort of significant achievement."

Speaking during a House Judiciary Committee hearing titled “Restoring Integrity and Security to the Visa Process,” Crockett noted that “the idea that Trump and my Republican colleagues want to restore integrity and security in the visa process is actually a joke," and harshly criticized the Trump administration's immigration crackdown and visa restrictions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshots of Jennifer Griffin and Pete Hegseth
The Hill

Fox Host Comes To Reporter's Defense After Pete Hegseth Berates Her At Pentagon Briefing

Fox News' chief political analyst Brit Hume came to the defense of Fox national security reporter Jennifer Griffin after their former colleague, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, criticized Griffin as the reporter "who misrepresents the most intentionally what the president says” in a Pentagon news conference.

Hegseth, a former Fox News anchor, had criticized media outlets—including his former network—for what he described as unpatriotic reporting. Hegseth took particular aim at early intelligence assessments suggesting that President Donald Trump's bombing of Iran may not have significantly crippled Iran’s nuclear capabilities.

Keep ReadingShow less

Teachers Share The Questions Students Asked In Class That Broke Their Hearts

Being a teacher is a calling.

It is not for the meek or weak of heart.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Emily Compagno
Fox News

Fox Host Slams Dem For Dropping An F-Bomb After Praising Trump For The Same Thing Just Minutes Earlier

Fox News host Emily Compagno was criticized after she praised Donald Trump's use of the "f-bomb" earlier this week before condemning Texas Democratic Representative Jasmine Crockett's use of the same word—on the same episode of her show, no less.

Trump made headlines this week after admonishing Israel and Iran for violating a ceasefire agreement he'd announced on Truth Social. Although he claimed the ceasefire had been "agreed upon," Iran fired at least six missile barrages at Israel after it was supposed to take effect.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ken Jennings; Emily Croke
@Jeopardy/Instagram

Champ's Wild Final Jeopardy Connection

In a dramatic conclusion on last Monday’s Jeopardy!, a contestant revealed a surprising relationship to the final clue's answer. Hailing from Denver, Emily Croke made it to the final write-in portion of the game show with $12,200 in earnings.

In the category of “Collections,” host Ken Jennings read the clue:

Keep ReadingShow less