A controversial new trend has seen businesses across the United States begin offering retouching services so parents can control blemishes and whiten their children's teeth in school pictures.
The trend was captured on Twitter by user Jenn Greene after she noticed there was an option to add retouching to her child's photo package by the company that was hired by her child's school to take photos.
I'm going to need someone to explain to me why @Lifetouch offers PHOTO RETOUCH for KIDS school pics?! What the hell?! #parenting pic.twitter.com/x63hGFz4YS
— Jenn Greene (@traveljenn) September 29, 2021
In talking to the New York Post, Greene said that she "completely disagree[d]" with offering the option to retouch a child's school photos.
"Because it's teaching kids that they need to look perfect all the time and that they can change [a perceived flaw] with the click of a mouse."
I started to develop cystic acne on my face in third grade. I hated picture day because my pictures were, in my opinion, awful and I never wanted anyone to see them. Once retouching started to be offered, my Mom let me add it. But it was always my choice to get it.
— Terry Simson (@TerrySimson) October 28, 2021
You pay extra for the retouch option. So that would mean that the parents paid for it. I refused retouching on my kids pictures all the way through high school.
— Jamaica&Co (@jamaicamichelle) October 28, 2021
Didn't see the segment on the show but it says it is offered. That makes it sound like an option. I don't have a problem with that.
— William M. (@nocnurse2) October 28, 2021
Im actually GLAD they offered this service when I was in 4th grade. Kids can pick on you for the smallest reason and those pictures LIVED with us - IDs, yearbooks, etc. It was one less thing to worry about! Something this small can make a kid's day. Let them choose ♥️
— Ashley A (@ashleylinda32) October 28, 2021
Most people, in replying to the topic on Twitter, agreed that while a forced retouch would be a problem, a choice of extra pay for retouch doesn't seem like all that bad an idea.
"When I was in high school I had a sty in my eye on senior picture day," wrote one user.
"They retouched it and you couldn't even tell! I was so glad."
I received my Daughter's package to purchase and found this disturbing as well. My daughter is a Senior in HS and I feel it's disgusting to try and tell them that they're not okay the way they are. pic.twitter.com/DjNduBzGFH
— 💀⚾Bigtomk22⚾💀 (@Bigtomk22YT) October 28, 2021
Go glad you disagree as well! I spoke up on the news this morning about it! https://t.co/F1GMfbkslp
— Jenn Greene (@traveljenn) October 28, 2021
Who needs Instagram induced shame and insecurities when it can be provided by your own school officials ? 😞
— volprofi (@volprofi) October 28, 2021
No! This is where it begins! The low self esteem Not being happy with your natural beauty
— Loni (@LoniloveLoni) October 28, 2021
Still, those who have paid for minor retouches have gotten photos back with changes they neither wanted nor authorized.
For example, one mom found, to her horror, the retoucher had edited out the child's hearing aids.
@thesedeafkidsrock Maybe it was the lighting with new ear molds? #sahm #sahd #mom #deaf #hearingaids #asl #schoolphoto #photoediting #greenscreen
And so even though the service may not have been problematic at face value, it certainly got more problematic when viewers could see the job the service was actually doing.
@thosedeafkidsrock/TikTok
@thosedeafkidsrock/TikTok
@thosedeafkidsrock/TikTok
@thosedeafkidsrock/TikTok
So, buyer beware.
Even if you think the service may only edit out your child's dark circles, they might edit out something about them you love or think makes them special as well as negatively affect your child's self image.