Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

John Oliver Takes on US Immigration Courts: 'We Are Going to Need Big Changes'

John Oliver Takes on US Immigration Courts: 'We Are Going to Need Big Changes'
Last Week Tonight/YouTube

Once again, John Oliver nails it.

John Oliver went on an epic 18-minute rant on Sunday's episode of Last Week Tonight, tearing through the injustices that permeate immigration courts.


Oliver explains that as terrifying as deportation is, immigration courts can make life hell for immigrants, due to their enormous power and the often life or death consequences that ensue from their rulings.

Oliver begins with footage of ICE agents conducting raids, adding that before immigrants are deported, they often end up in immigration court, where they are often forced to defend themselves against governmental policies which rarely work in their favor.

"There are around sixty of them all over the country, and hundreds of thousands of people go through them every year, pleading their case against deportation. They are hugely consequential, and the stakes in these cases can be incredibly high."

"No child should have to worry about whether they'll be murdered."

One girl, "Vanessa," was asked, "what would happen if we sent you home?" Her chilling reply was that "they're going to kill me. They're gonna kill me and they're gonna kill my family."

Oliver continued. "So this is a critical and potentially life and death process. Sadly, the system is a complete mess, and don't take that from me, take that from multiple and current immigration court judges." Former Arlington Immigration Court Judge Paul Scmidt emphasized Oliver's point.

"I think most people would be incredulous at what really happens in immigration court and what sometimes passes for due process."

Former Baltimore Immigration Court Judge John F. Gossart Jr. added to this sentiment.

"Our courts today are dysfunctional."

Judge Dana Leigh Marks of the National Association of Immigration Judges told PBS's News Hour:

"In essence, we're doing death penalty cases in a traffic court setting."

Oliver explains that increased immigration from Latin America, combined with stricter immigration law enforcement and a shortage of judges are the cause of "a massive backlog of cases." Backlogs, Oliver says, that result in hastily-dispensed justice and a complete lack of due process for defendants. The number of backlogged immigration cases has doubled since 2009 to more than 617,000. Wait times for court dates often stretch as long as five years, and defendants are left with little to no options except to wait. Years-long wait times can cause "evidence to go stale," and can often lead to witnesses disappearing before a case is heard.


Oliver also clarifies that immigration courts, like traffic courts, are civil courts, and only have the power to decide whether or not immigrants can stay in the country, regardless if they have never committed a crime.


Most importantly, defendants are not entitled to legal representation like they are in criminal courts. This leaves potential deportees with two options: go at it alone, or hire a lawyer they probably can't afford. Oliver points out that only 37 percent of defendants in immigration courts show up with an attorney.

Where immigrants live also has an effect on whether or not they get deported. As Last Week Tonight explains:

"The truth is, whether you have a lawyer or not, your odds of success to a frightening degree may be dictated by where you are. In San Francisco, immigrants are deported in 36 percent of cases. In Charlotte, the number jumps to 84 percent. In New York City, only 24 percent of cases result in deportation. In Atlanta, the rate is almost 90 percent."

Perhaps most alarmingly is the fact that immigration courts are part of the Department of Justice under the executive branch, which means they are "subject to changing political priorities." Potential injustices are amplified by Attorney General Jeff Session's ambivalence toward immigrants.

"Sessions has a weird amount of power over immigration courts. He can refer cases to himself, which means stepping in and personally reviewing decisions...the point here is, when you combine all of these factors—backlogged courts, lack of representation, and judges without full independence, you can have cases that don't even seem to resemble justice."

Oliver later concludes that change is needed, and needed now, because lives hang in the balance."

"The truth here is we are going to need big changes," says Oliver. "Ideally the biggest change would be to make the courts fully independent from the DOJ, which is something that can't happen overnight or, under this particular congress, probably at all. But at the very least we should absolutely fix the stupidest problem of all, which is that nobody, particularly children, should have to represent themselves in these courts — because children do not understand the law."

More from News

Billy Crudup and Naomi Watts
John Nacion/GG2025/Penske Media/Getty Images

Naomi Watts Hilariously Details How Billy Crudup Put Her At Ease Their First Time Being Intimate

As much as we might not like to admit it, most of us lean more heavily into trying to look and feel young for longer, rather than aging gracefully. When we're struggling with this, having a supportive partner by our side can really help.

And it looks like actorNaomi Watts found exactly the type of partner she needed at just the right time.

Keep ReadingShow less
Will Ferrell
The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Will Ferrell Hilariously Rips Oscars For Snubbing His Trans Documentary 'Will & Harper'

Actor Will Ferrell comically slammed the Academy for snubbing his 2024 documentary Will & Harper during an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert.

The critically acclaimed documentary follows the Anchorman actor on a 17-day road trip accompanying his friend and former SNL head writer Harper Steele after she completed her gender transition.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tracey Gold
Bobby Bank/Getty Images

Tracey Gold Opens Up About How Cruel 'Growing Pains' Fat Jokes Fueled Her Anorexia

Former child actor Tracey Gold, known for her role as teenager Carol Seaver on the '80s sitcom Growing Pains, reflected on her time working on the show and revealed that it wasn't all great memories.

The 55-year-old appeared on the Let's Be Clear With Shannen Doherty podcast and opened up about her experiences on Growing Pains that eventually led to her struggle with anorexia.

Keep ReadingShow less
Mara Wilson; Donald Trump
Tara Ziemba/Getty Images; Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

Actor Mara Wilson Perfectly Blasts Trump Over His Order Banning Trans Women In Female Sports

Matilda star Mara Wilson ripped President Donald Trump over his order banning transgender women in female sports, pointing out the hypocrisy of Trump being so fixated on whatever goes on in women's locker rooms.

Wilson spoke out after Trump signed an executive order Wednesday banning transgender women and girls from competing in female sports. Titled the “No Men in Women’s Sports Executive Order,” it marks the fourth executive action targeting transgender individuals since he took office on January 20.

Keep ReadingShow less
Aaron Craig Gleason
Okaloosha Dept. of Corrections

Christian Writer Who Claimed LGBTQ+ People Are 'Grooming' Kids Arrested For Child Molestation—Because Of Course

Well, well, well, if it isn't yet another far-right evangelical Christian getting arrested for sexually victimizing children after making a career accusing LGBTQ+ people of being "groomers." Every accusation is a confession, as they say.

Aaron Craig Gleason is a Christian writer who has written several anti-LGBTQ+ articles for outlets like The Daily Wire, The Federalist, and The Imaginative Conservative in which he has painted queer people as latent child molesters.

Keep ReadingShow less