Conservatives lashed out at Lizzo after the singer twerked while playing a 200-year-old French crystal flute that once belonged to James Madison, the nation's fourth President.
Lizzo is currently on tour promoting her latest album, Special, which was released during the summer. The flute was on loan from the instrument collection at the Library of Congress (LOC). A curator from the LoC was on hand to present it to Lizzo ahead of her performance.
Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden tweeted an invitation to Lizzo—a classically trained flutist—to visit the library's extensive flute collection while she was in Washington D.C. for her concert.
\u201cThe @librarycongress has the largest flute collection in the world with more than 1,800. It incl Pres James Madison\u2019s 1813 crystal flute. \n@lizzo we would love for you to come see it and even play a couple when you are in DC next week. Like your song they are \u201cGood as hell.\u201d\ud83d\ude09\u201d— Carla Hayden (@Carla Hayden) 1663945459
The LOC later shared video of Lizzo's visit.
It included an impromptu concert with the crystal flute.
\u201cHearing @lizzo play some of the Library's priceless antique instruments on Monday was such a gift, and we were honored and happy to help her share that gift with her concert audience Tuesday night. Here is some more behind-the-scenes footage of her Library tour. #LizzoAtLOC\u201d— Library of Congress (@Library of Congress) 1664394003
You can see a video of Lizzo's brief Tuesday performance below.
\u201cYALL\u2026\n\nI PLAYED THE 200-YEAR-OLD CRYSTAL FLUTE FROM THE LIBRARY OF CONGRESS ON STAGE IN D.C. \ud83d\ude2d\ud83d\ude2d\ud83d\ude2d\ud83d\ude2d \n\n@LibnOfCongress thank you \u2764\ufe0f\u201d— FOLLOW @YITTY (@FOLLOW @YITTY) 1664342363
The flute is made of sheer crystal and was gifted to Madison by Claude Laurent, a Parisian watchmaker and mechanic who invented the technology to produce glass flutes that became a novelty of the early 19th century.
Claude Laurent glass flute, an early 19th century novelty.Sepia Times/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
It is rumored the flute was among the valuable items rescued during the Burning of Washington—a British invasion during the Chesapeake Campaign of the War of 1812.
The obvious joy the musician felt playing the instrument was something to celebrate.
\u201cNOBODY HAS EVER HEARD THIS FAMOUS CRYSTAL FLUTE BEFORE\n\nNOW YOU HAVE\n\nIM THE FIRST & ONLY PERSON TO EVER PLAY THIS PRESIDENTIAL 200-YEAR-OLD CRYSTAL FLUTE\u2014 THANK YOU @librarycongress \u2764\ufe0f\u201d— FOLLOW @YITTY (@FOLLOW @YITTY) 1664345126
For most people.
But conservatives—many of whom likely did not know the item existed before this week—decried the performance calling it disrespectful to the country's history as well as one of its most prized artifacts.
Right-wing provocateur Ben Shapiro said Lizzo did something "deliberately controversial."
He also attempted to slut-shame her for not wearing a "semi-modest outfit."
\u201cIf all we had seen was the clip of Lizzo playing the flute in the halls of the Library of Congress while wearing a semi-modest outfit, everyone would have shrugged. But that's not the clip everyone championed as groundbreaking: it was the clip where she bragged about twerking.\u201d— Ben Shapiro (@Ben Shapiro) 1664453915
California Republican Senate candidate James Bradley suggested Lizzo had "taken a dump on the American flag."
\u201cLizzo twerking nearly naked while playing the #JamesMadison flute somehow feels like somebody took a dump on the American flag.\u201d— James Bradley (@James Bradley) 1664453895
Conservative commentator Nick Adams said Lizzo's performance showed the Biden administration "is making a mockery of the country."
\u201cLizzo isn't talented enough to play music on a $20 Yamaha Plastic Recorder off Amazon let alone a crystal flute once owned by James Madison.\n\nThe Biden Administration is making a mockery of the country.\u201d— Nick Adams (@Nick Adams) 1664352705
Matt Walsh, another prominent conservative commentator, suggested the performance "was a form of racial retribution" orchestrated by "the woke left."
\u201cLizzo playing James Madison's flute was a form of racial retribution, according to the woke Left. And I actually have no doubt that this is part of the reason why the Library of Congress facilitated this spectacle.\u201d— Matt Walsh (@Matt Walsh) 1664401251
But many others said there was nothing wrong with the performance.
\u201cLizzo, you've played #JamesMadison's flute, now come visit his house! \ud83d\ude4f\n@lizzo \n\n#Lizzo #Flute @librarycongress #Yitty @Yitty\u201d— Madison's Montpelier (@Madison's Montpelier) 1664379360
\u201c\ud83d\udc97Lizzo is a joy \ud83d\ude0a\u201d— DezziDelight (@DezziDelight) 1664388658
\u201cAs someone who spent a large portion of her childhood playing the flute\u2026this is very very cool \ud83d\ude0d\u201d— Dominique Rowell (@Dominique Rowell) 1664397444
\u201cWhite people freaking out over Lizzo playing a slaver\u2019s flute is my favorite Twitter right now.\u201d— Elie Mystal (@Elie Mystal) 1664414453
Others mocked the performative outrage of conservatives.
\u201cHOW DARE THEY! It seems like the only reasonable thing to do now is for the @librarycongress to let every single world-class, top selling, Grammy Award winning, Billboard topping, flute playing, badass POC woman-identified artist play that crystal flute. Fair is fair. @lizzo\u201d— Brian Sims (@Brian Sims) 1664409372
\u201cFascinating to see Ben Shapiro histrionically claim that Lizzo playing that crystal flute is "controversial", but for some reason, he doesn't actually explain why he feels it's controversial. No explanation for that. Gee, I wonder why.\u201d— Charlotte Clymer \ud83c\udff3\ufe0f\u200d\u26a7\ufe0f\ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\udde6 (@Charlotte Clymer \ud83c\udff3\ufe0f\u200d\u26a7\ufe0f\ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\udde6) 1664474779
\u201cAre republicans still mad about @lizzo playing a flute that none of them knew existed three days ago?\u201d— Molly Jong-Fast (@Molly Jong-Fast) 1664468130
\u201cracism is so funny, how are conservatives mad at Lizzo for playing an old flute right now \ud83d\ude2d\ud83d\ude2d\ud83d\ude2d\u201d— Pierpoint & Co. Chief Executive Officer (@Pierpoint & Co. Chief Executive Officer) 1664415895
\u201cFlushing all of my flutes down the toilet in protest of the wokes disrespecting that other flute.\u201d— Cody Johnston (@Cody Johnston) 1664401320
Lizzo has been playing flute since the fifth grade.
At one point, she considered studying at the Paris Conservatory before pursuing her rapping and singing career.
Her own flute—which she named Sasha Flute—even has its own Instagram page.
She said the experience of playing Madison's highly delicate artifact felt "like playing out of a wine glass" but that "history is freaking cool."