Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Trump's Lawyers Just Made a Questionable Argument for Why Congress Doesn't Have the Power to Investigate Trump, and People Are Rolling Their Eyes

Trump's Lawyers Just Made a Questionable Argument for Why Congress Doesn't Have the Power to Investigate Trump, and People Are Rolling Their Eyes
WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 14: U.S. President Donald Trump waves as he walks toward Marine One before departing from the White House on May 14, 2019 in Washington, DC. President Trump is traveling to Louisiana. (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images)

Wow.

Last month, President Donald Trump's legal team filed a lawsuit to stop a subpoena issued by House Oversight Committee Chairman Elijah Cummings (D-MD) to accounting conglomerate Mazars USA, which is in possession of Trump’s coveted tax returns.

The subpoena seeks to confirm testimony by Trump’s former lawyer Michael Cohen, who alleged that Trump over and under-inflated the value of his assets.


On Tuesday, Trump's lawyers proposed an ambitious challenge to Congress's authority to investigate the president in federal court.

William Consovoy, Trump's personal attorney, argued that the Constitution does not grant the House of Representatives law enforcement powers and that the multiple investigations in the House serve no legislative purpose.

“That is law enforcement,” Consovoy said. “Are you complying with federal law?”

US District Court Judge Amit Mehta asked Consovoy if a president could be investigated for corruption while in office, which Consovoy dismissed.

“I don’t think that’s the proper subject of investigation as to the president,” he replied.

What happened next is almost unbelievable.

Consovoy suggested that the Watergate and Whitewater investigations may have been unconstitutional.

Brad Heath of USA Today reported US District Court Judge Amit Mehta's reaction:

"Mehta sounded incredulous, asking whether Congress could have investigated Watergate, which led to President Richard Nixon's resignation, and Whitewater, which led to President Bill Clinton's impeachment. Consovoy initially said he’d have to look at the basis for those investigations."

“They were inquiring as to violations of criminal law,” Mehta said. “It’s pretty straightforward – among other things.”

“That is still law enforcement," Consovoy said.

So yeah, that happened.

If this seems ridiculous, that's because it is.

Douglas Letter, the House's general counsel, blasted Trump's defense as nonsense.

“His main client, President Trump, has taken the position really that Congress and particularly the House of Representatives is a nuisance and we’re just getting in his way when he’s trying to run the country,” Letter said. “The problem with that is that this is a total and basic and fundamental misunderstanding of the system that is set up by the Constitution.”

Trump's personal finances are "totally legitimate things for Congress to look into,” Letter said. “President Trump has no chance of success here on the merits of his claim."

Indeed, the Constitution explicitly states in Article II, Section 4:

"The President, Vice President and all Civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors."

But the president's lawyers are making the case that Trump is above the law.

Mehta, unconvinced, hinted that precedent may not favor Trump's case because not since 1880 has a court found that Congress has abused its subpoena power.

Mehta agreed to fast track the case last week and gave both parties until Saturday to submit any additional information.

"The sole question before the court — Is the House Oversight Committee's issuance of a subpoena to Mazars USA LLP for financial records of President Donald Trump and various associated entities a valid exercise of legislative power? — is fully briefed, and the court can discern no benefit from an additional round of legal arguments," he said Tuesday.

More from People

Yassamin Ansari; Screenshot of Kellyanne Conway
Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images; Fox News

Dem Rep. Epically Shuts Down Kellyanne Conway's Claim Sydney Sweeney Ad Is Causing Liberal 'Panic'

Actor Sydney Sweeney recently faced backlash over her American Eagle ad campaign titled “Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans.” The campaign plays on the words “jeans” and “genes,” which some critics claim alludes to eugenics—a theory widely discredited as scientifically inaccurate and ethically dangerous.

According to former presidential counselor Kellyanne Conway—who gave us the term "alternative facts"—the campaign has sparked "panic on the left."

Keep ReadingShow less
Lisa Kudrow in 'Death to 2020'
Netflix

Lisa Kudrow's Portrayal Of A MAGA Spokesperson Resurfaces—And It's Eerily Accurate

Actor Lisa Kudrow has gone viral after her performance in the Netflix mockumentary Death to 2020 as a truth-denying spokesperson for President Donald Trump went viral—prompting many to point out that her portrayal is still spot on.

The film, from the minds of Black Mirror creators Charlie Brooker and Annabel Jones, centers on a group of fictional characters reflecting on major U.S. and U.K. events of 2020, such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the U.S. presidential election.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Molly Martinez
RSBN

White House Reporter Reacts After Video Glitch Sparks Conspiracy Theory That She's A 'Lizard Person'

White House reporter Molly Martinez responded after a White House livestream glitched and caused her eyes to look completely white for a split-second—prompting conspiracy theorists to go wild and claim she is a "lizard person" who is secretly controlling the government.

Martinez, a Washington-based journalist for local TV chain Gray Television, appeared on camera June 19 in the White House press room, smiling at a friend. A glitch in the original footage made her eyes look entirely white—something conspiracy theorists seized on as “evidence” she’s a lizard person.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Ben Ferguson and Abby Philip
CNN

Right-Wing Podcaster Blasted After Making Absurd Claim About Trump And Crime Rates In 2024

Conservative podcaster Ben Ferguson left hs fellow CNN panelists stunned after he made the bizarre claim that falling crime rates in 2024 were due to President Donald Trump's policies—even though Trump didn't begin his second term until January 2025.

Ferguson spoke after Trump—who presented fake crime statistics—announced his decision to federalize police in Washington, D.C., and deploy the National Guard in an effort to fight crime.

Keep ReadingShow less
A bride and a groom holding hands
man and woman holding hands focus photo

People Who Attended Multiple Weddings For The Same Person Describe The Differences

Weddings are a wonderful celebration of love and commitment.

That being said, all of us have likely been to a wedding where we have wondered "how long do you think it's going to last".

Keep ReadingShow less