Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

People Break Down Ideas That Seemed Terrible On Paper But Worked Out Brilliantly

Person writing on notepad
Kenny Eliason/Unsplash

Reddit user treny0000 asked: 'What's an example of an idea that's terrible on paper but worked brilliantly in reality?'

Make us preferred on Google

Some of the best ideas start as vague concepts in written form, and not all of them translate to reality successfully.

Imagine the first time people heard of how retrieving information and communicating with others long before the advent of the digital age when people used rotary phones.


The number of times that written introduction must've been laughed off must've been a common occurrence.

But no matter how awful it sounds, bold concepts have to start somewhere, right?

Curious to hear from strangers online about exceeding expectations, Redditor treny0000 asked:

"What's an example of an idea that's terrible on paper but worked brilliantly in reality?"

People's lives have benefitted from these major life-changing ideas.

Information Evolution

"As someone who spent a lot of time around 2005 trying to describe it to some very skeptical people, I would definitely say Wikipedia."

– vanityklaw

"I can't believe this is so low. There's no reason Wikipedia should work. Yet it's really one of mankind's greatest accomplishments."

– gsfgf


Driving Benefits

"Let's drive a car with a GPS and a camera down EVERY STREET ON EARTH!"

– A_Monsanto


Breakfast Staple

"Toast."

"'Hey let's take something we already finished baking and heat it up again.' The person who first came up with it must have sounded crazy."

– Crafty_Soul


When people's lives are at stake, there are no bad ideas.

Bold Rescue

"A plane has crashed in the jungles of New Guinea. Three survivors have found a village and managed to get communication. There's no way to get an airplane room to land and take off, and helicopters can't make it into the valley."

"I know! We'll airdrop medical personnel and supplies for a glider, assemble it, and slingshot it into the air! Then, we'll catch it with a tow-plane."

"It worked."

New Guinea Gremlin Crash

– algae429

Trapped Soccer Team

"The way they extracted those kids from the cave in Thailand. The diver and anesthesiologist (first off, how f'king lucky to find somebody with that overlap in skills) who was consulted and joined the effort said it was a terrible idea. It was only when presented with the other options that he realized this terrible idea was truly their best option."

"They rescued all the kids and their coach successfully."

– pittstop33

Someone fortunately listened to these ideas with an open mind, and the world was forever changed.

The Big Dreamer And Doer

"In the 1700s, this guy named Timothy Dexter had a few of these."

"Bed warmers are useful in cold climates, but he took a shipload of them to the Caribbean for sale. They were sold to the molasses industry as ladles and turned a handsome profit."

"He took a load of mittens to the same place. Some Asians bought them to sell onward to Siberia."

"Newcastle was a major coal-mining area. He took a shipload of coal there for sale, arrived during a major miner's strike, and turned a big profit."

"He did the mittens thing again, this time to the South Seas, and arrived just in time to sell them to some Portuguese traders on their way to China."

– existentialpenguin

The Cynic

"What, Sir? Would you make a ship sail against the wind and currents by lighting a bonfire under her deck? I pray you excuse me, I have no time to listen to such nonsense.”

"Napoleon Bonaparte, regarding the steam engine."

– nicetrylaocheREALLY

Going Places

"Louis Brennan, inventor of the gyro monorail. His monorail was a single-track train that used a gyroscope-based balancing system to remain upright. The designs look insane on paper but it was crazy innovative, safe for passengers, and was apparently even faster than the regular trains (of those days)."

– NervousSeagull

Cats deserved their own category.

The Memory That Doesn't Go Away

"CATS, the Broadway musical. A nonsense fever dream about horny catpeople competing to die and be reborn (yes, that is the plot, insofar as CATS has one), based on a book of silly short poems by T.S. Eliot that are not really related to each other except all being about cats. Just catpeople introducing themselves and rubbing on each other for several hours, then one of them "ascends" aka dies."

"To date, CATS has made over a billion dollars worldwide."

– ScaryBoyRobots

"To date the only production I’ve walked out of midway through. I had no idea what it was about. Figured, CATS is famous, sure I’ll go. Intermission: I confirmed there was actually no plot and was just done."

– Brideshead


It's Raining Cats

"Dropping a whole bunch of cats by parachute over Borneo to stop the spread of plague."

– ceruleanbear8


Medical science research papers must've looked insane.

Finding A Cure

"Attempting to cure syphilis with malaria. Brilliantly worked is a stretch, though."

– bitsplease_

"The inventor won a Nobel prize for it, too. Gotta love early 19th-century medical solutions."

– Nafeels

"sounds similar to modern chemo. Let's poison you and hope it kills cancer faster than it kills you."

– aliensheep


You have to take risks.

Watch What Happens

"Putting out oil well fires by blowing them up."

– The_Real_Scrotus

"Similarly, controlling the spread of forest fires by lighting pre-emptive fires."

– xkulp8

It always doesn't have to be life-changing, but sometimes, you just gotta go for broke.


Unusual Pet

"Have you ever heard of the 'Pet Rock' phenomenon? It sounded absurd to sell rocks as pets. On paper, it was a headache, but in reality, in the 70s, people went crazy about it. Sometimes, the craziest ideas spark the most!”

– FinelyTrail

"The guy made a million dollars! You know.. I had an idea like that once. It was a JUMP to conclusions mat! You'd have this mat, and on it would be different CONCLUSIONS that you could JUMP to!"

– JPMoney81


Playing God

"The Sims computer game. It sounds like the stupidest idea ever - who would want to control a Sim character doing all the mundane sh*t we do every day. How boring. But I played the sh*t out of the Sims, then the subsequent versions."

– mst3k_42


Back In The Day

"A movie rental company that mails you DVDs. I thought it was the sh*ttiest idea when it first came out when I could drive 5 minutes to Blockbuster and get whatever I wanted then."

– biscovery


We take them for granted now, but I imagine the written proposal for the first smartphones must've been wild.

The fact that an iPhone could be used to guide 120,000,000 Apollo-era spacecraft to the moon is incomprehensible.

It's true. Smartphones are exponentially more powerful than the guidance computer used by NASA for the famed Apollo 11 mission that enabled man's first spaceflight to the moon.

Nowadays, we use all that juice on my phone for crushing candies.

More from Trending/best-of-reddit

Jensen Huang
Soeren Stache/picture alliance via Getty Images

People Are Debating Whether They Could Be Seduced By A Spy—And Their Hot Takes Are Hilariously On Point

Could you ever be seduced by a spy?

That's the question many are asking after the latest bonkers thing to hit the news: that ousted Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang had an affair with a Chinese spy—ALLEGEDLY.

Keep Reading Show less
Tom Carney; Ron DeSantis
Mayor Tom Carney/Facebook; Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images for SiriusXM

Florida Mayor Rages After St. Patrick's Day Parade Is Canceled Thanks To DeSantis' Anti-'DEI' Law

In April of 2026, Florida MAGA Republican Governor Ron DeSantis signed the GOP authored and backed SB 1134 to take effect in January of 2027.

Dubbed the anti-DEI law, it bans Florida counties and municipalities from "funding, promoting, or taking official action" related to diversity, equity, and inclusion, which the law defines as: "with reference to race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation."

Keep Reading Show less
Shakira; Abdul El-Sayed
Michael Loccisano/Getty Images; Finn Gomez/Getty Images

Shakira Just Responded To Abdul El-Sayed's Quip About 'Shakira Law'—And Fans Are Obsessed

Pop star Shakira had social media users cackling after finally responding to then-Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed's joke about Michiganders who fear "Shakira Law" back in October.

El-Sayed was able to fend off Islamophobic attacks against him over many months, actions that culminated in his historic defeat of Michigan Republican Mike Rogers in the state's U.S. Senate race. He repeatedly faced accusations that he is a member of the Muslim Brotherhood and wants to impose Sharia law nationwide.

Keep Reading Show less
Gerrymandered North Carolina map
Win McNamee/Getty Images

North Carolina Is Now The Textbook Definition Of A 'Dummymander' After Their Gerrymandering Efforts Backfired Massively

North Carolina Republicans are making waves on Wikipedia after the site used them as a prime example of "dummymandering" now that Democrats made historic wins in last week's midterm elections.

Before the elections, Republicans held 10 of the state's 14 U.S. House seats. However, Democrats have now flipped most of those despite the GOP's decision to redraw congressional districts in an attempt to hold onto more seats.

Keep Reading Show less
Andrew Rannells attends the Television Academy's Inaugural Televerse Festival in Los Angeles.
Chris Delmas / AFP via Getty Images

Andrew Rannells Calls Out Theatergoer Who Chastized Him For Not Showing Up At Stage Door After Broadway Show

For Broadway fans, the final curtain call doesn't always mean the night's over. There's still the stage door, where a little patience and a Sharpie might score an autograph, a selfie, or a few unforgettable seconds with an iconic performer.

Of course, some theatergoers seem to have confused a Broadway ticket with an all-access backstage pass.

Keep Reading Show less