Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

MAGA Is Hoping Trump Returns to Politics Before 2024—as Speaker of the House

MAGA Is Hoping Trump Returns to Politics Before 2024—as Speaker of the House
James Devaney/GC Images
Make us preferred on Google

There is a MAGA fever dream over the idea of Donald Trump returning to politics much sooner than the presidential primaries in 2023. Pointing to a quirk in the rules, "many people are saying" that Donald Trump could be named House Speaker if the GOP regains its majority in 2022, even if he never runs for Congress.

The idea of Speaker Trump was first floated by erstwhile Trump ally Steve Bannon in February. Speaking to a group of Boston Republicans, Bannon suggested that Trump run for Congress as part of a Republican House majority, then displace Speaker Nancy Pelosi in 2023 before running for president again. In the middle of this, Bannon inserted the Big Lie as a rationale: "We totally get rid of Nancy Pelosi, and the first act of President Trump as Speaker will be to impeach Joe Biden for his illegitimate activities of stealing the presidency," Bannon said to shouts and applause. Later, Trump would muse on a radio appearance with far-right talk show host Wayne Allyn that the idea was "so interesting"—and a better one than running for the Senate, in his mind.


What Bannon and Allyn didn't realize, but what has some observers concerned, is that while tradition holds that the Speaker be a member of the governing majority in the House, there is nothing in the actual U.S. Constitution that requires this. Article 1, Section 2 states only that "The House of Representatives shall chuse their Speaker and other Officers" and by tradition they have done so by roll-call vote. A smattering of votes in the past have been cast for non-members, but if Trump stood for the position in a GOP-led House, it would present a serious challenge to Keven McCarthy.

First off, let's dispel the likelihood of a Trump Speakership. That chance that even someone as unprincipled as McCarthy would grovel so low as to cede power to Trump as Speaker, even should the GOP retake the House, is quite low. McCarthy will do what is best for himself and his own power, and that doesn't likely include giving it up without a fight. Moreover, McCarthy knows how to maneuver his own caucus and round up votes, or he wouldn't be where he is today.

This is not to say that the idea can't be very poisonous. McCarthy seemed flustered, for example, when asked directly about the possibility. On Friday on Fox News, Brian Kilmeade asked him, "Would you be for President Trump becoming Speaker?" McCarthy laughed nervously and stated, "You know, I've talked to President Trump many times. He tells me he wants [inaudible] to be Speaker, and I think he should be president." McCarthy's office hastily issued a clarification of what appears to have been an attempt at humor, with a press spokesperson telling a reporter that McCarthy misspoke: "He meant and said 'me' to be Speaker, but understand that might not have sounded crystal clear in that he meant to say it was him Trump wants to be Speaker," the spokesperson explained.

Republicans in Congress understand that the Speaker's job is a critical, procedure-filled, and strategic job. It sets the agenda for the majority in legislation, and the Speaker is primarily responsible for holding that majority through electoral victory. Someone as inexperienced and full of bluster as Trump may appeal superficially to voters, but the members themselves know it would be an unmitigated disaster.

Perhaps more critically, the idea of Donald Trump being third in line for the presidency and back in the driver's seat of one of our branches of government is so repulsive to voters on the left and to a large swath in the middle that it could fuel massive turnout again in 2022. Should Trump actually campaign on this idea in order to turn out his base (again, unlikely), it could backfire for the GOP, which needs Democrats to sit out the midterms.

This is not to say that the ex-president won't have an outsized influence on the upcoming midterms. As I wrote about recently, Trump's chosen candidates could and likely will dominate the primaries, and Trump has not shied from endorsing the most loyal yet deplorable among them.

I can't help but draw a comparison here to the pandemic. If President Biden is the vaccine to Trump's virus, then the reemergence of Trump in 2022 is like the delta variant, more contagious and deadly to those who refuse to be grounded in reality, but also threatening to our entire recovery and our way forward as it takes holds and mutates. Meanwhile, we who are fully vaccinated feel secure in our decisions and ready to move on, but we may not completely understand what a resurgence could mean. Vigilance, truth and full civic engagement are the weapons we have against both scourges. We would be wise to deploy them early and meet the threat head-on.

More from People/donald-trump

Paul Rudd
Valerie Terranova/Getty Images for Cunard

Paul Rudd Was Just Spotted Peering Into The Brooklyn Store That's Feuding With Kelly Clarkson—And The Jokes Are On Point

Celebrities: They're just like us!

They get annoyed when they get bad customer service, like Kelly Clarkson, and they get hella nosey when the drama goes viral on the internet—like, it turns out, Paul Rudd.

Keep ReadingShow less
screenshot of Lisa Kearns' vandalized mayoral campaign sign
Lisa Kearns/Facebook

Canadian Candidate Goes Viral After Turning Defaced Campaign Signs Into Hilarious Viral Video

After pouring time and effort into a project, seeing all your hard work disrespected can draw justified anger. But a Canadian woman running for political office decided to turn the lemons life—or, more specifically, vandals—handed her into pitch perfect lemonade.

Lisa Kearns is a former city councilor who vacated her Ward 2 seat to run for mayor of Burlington, Ontario, Canada—a city of about 187,000 people on the western shore of Lake Ontario. Kearns discovered several of her campaign signs featuring her photo had been vandalized over the Canadian Thanksgiving (observed the second Monday of October) long weekend.

Keep ReadingShow less
Christina Ricci; Donald Trump
Gilbert Flores/Deadline via Getty Images; Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

Christina Ricci Just Dropped A Brutal Truth Bomb On A 71-Year-Old MAGA Voter—And Fans Are Applauding

Yellowjackets star Christina Ricci did not mince words after a 71-year-old MAGA voter on Threads vowed to "vote straight Red" in the upcoming midterm elections.

Threads user @janhunterlan, with the midterms just under two weeks away, identified herself as a 71-year-old with an entire family "in California, Texas, Arizona, and Michigan, plus Pensilvania [sic]" that "will be voting straight Red" on November 3.

Keep ReadingShow less
James Talarico; Elon Musk
Sergio Flores/Getty Images; Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

James Talarico Just Clapped Back Hard After Elon Musk Said There's 'Something Deeply Wrong' With Him

Texas Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico responded after trillionaire Elon Musk claimed "there's something deeply wrong" with him.

Just days ago, news outlets reported that Musk donated $158 million to a Republican super PAC, the Senate Leadership Fund, in September. The money he donated swelled the coffers of Texas PAC, a group that is backing Paxton, the Texas attorney general. Musk also made a $10 million donation to Lone Star Liberty PAC, another group that has thrown its support behind Paxton.

Keep ReadingShow less
LaMelo Ball #1 of the Minnesota Timberwolves celebrates a three-point basket against the Detroit Pistons.
David Berding/Getty Images

NBA Star Sparks Backlash After Saying That Changing His Infant Son's Diapers Is 'Not My Job'

It's 2026, but NBA star LaMelo Ball apparently hasn't gotten the memo that fatherhood has moved beyond the 1950s. The Minnesota Timberwolves point guard is catching heat after declaring that changing his infant son's diapers is "not my job."

The 25-year-old made the eyebrow-raising admission during an Inside the NBA interview with Ernie Johnson Jr. ahead of his October 21 debut with Minnesota.

Keep ReadingShow less