Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

People Break Down The Craziest True Crime Cases They've Ever Learned About

People Break Down The Craziest True Crime Cases They've Ever Learned About
do not cross police barricade tape close-up photography
Make us preferred on Google

Be it Law & Order, FBI, or CSI, or the work of James Patterson, countless people are simply addicted to crime themed TV shows, movies and books.

Others, however, are more fascinated by the real thing.

Be it scripted series, documentary style or podcast, many people are fascinated by true crimes, and can't learn enough about some of these cases.

But on some occasions, the crimes in question might simply be too gruesome, dramatic or heartbreaking to handle, resulting in even the most dedicated crime aficionados to take a step back.

Redditor Soupystains was curious to hear which true crime case fellow Reddit users simply couldn't handle, leading them to ask:

"What's a true crime case that was simply too much to handle?"


Judith Barsi

"Judith Barsi."

"That poor, sweet, innocent soul."

"Never had a fighting chance in the world."- Nuttonbutton

James Bulger

"The James Bulger case always left me with that sickening feeling."

"That poor trusting little boy that was lured away by two older children no less, and killed haunts me."- Mason3637

Gabriel Fernandez

"For me, Gabriel Fernandez."

"That sh*t f*cked me up for a while."- lightningspider97

Kelly Anne Bates

"The murder of Kelly Anne Bates."

"Happened just around the corner of where I live."

"She was 14, when her 48 year old 'boyfriend; groomed her and isolated her from her family."

"He then tortured her and gauged her eyes out, keeping her alive for a few more weeks, whilst starving her and stabbing things in her empty eye sockets, amongst other things."- Anonymark88

Mary Ann Dela Sala

"The 1967 murder of a neighbor, 17 year old Mary Ann Dela Sala of Hackensack, NJ."

"Left her after school job to walk home and was found floating in the Passaic River."- OilTankCzar.

The Delphi Murders

"While the investigation is still active today I have to go with the Delphi Murders."

"I keep thinking about what those girls had to watch the other endure before meeting her own fate."

"Someone still hasn’t been caught and it’s heartbreaking."- throwawaymeplease45

Susan Powell

"The murder of Susan Powell, but not the entire case itself."

"I listened to the podcast Cold and while the case as a whole interested me and was all sorts of f*cked up, it didn’t greatly disturb me."

"It was hearing the 911 calls of the social worker who was bringing the boys for a visit calling for help after Josh Powell lured his sons inside his home telling them he had a big surprise, locked the doors, killed both boys with an ax and then set the home on fire with all 3 of them inside."

"EMS was lost so the entire time the social worker is frantically trying to explain to them where they are, who he is, and what she’s worried is happening totally powerless to do anything to stop it, and then the house went up in flames."

"I had to take a 6month break from all true crime."- tigm2161130

Any case involving children.

"Murder of Tori Stafford."

"Also, the case of Karla Homolka and Paul Bernado."

"Basically, any case involving children."

"We don't have a death penalty in Canada for those who prey on children."- Hangingoutwithyou

Dylann Roof

"When Dylann Roof, the AME Church killer, was arrested, he told one of the officers, 'They were so nice to me, I almost didn't do it.'

"That's always really gotten to me."- notthesedays

The Toybox and Toolbox Killers

"Toybox killer is bad but toolbox killers is so much worse."

"There's footage on YouTube of people in the courtroom listening to the recordings of them with their victim and occasionally you just see people coming out of the courtroom crying or looking sick and you can hear the gutteral screams in the back."

Just the sound of the screams in the distance is so f*cked up."- Rackbone.

"The toy box killer —> nope."- CaffeinatedAsh

Sylvia Likens

"Sylvia Likens."

"Idk why I continued to read the whole story but reading about everything she endured, and all the extremely messed up things they did to her, I cried."

"I don’t know how you get to that point of dehumanizing someone like that."

"It makes me sick even thinking about it."- amaranthaxx

Ariel Castro

"The case of Michelle Knight, Amanda Berry and Gina DeJesus."

"They were kidnapped by Ariel Castro and were held captive in his house for 10-11 years."

"They were raped and Amanda became pregnant with a baby girl named Jocelyn."

"Thanks to her telling them Ariel wasn’t home they were released in 2013 which was only 9 years ago."- charlie_iscontagious

Bass Webb

"Google Bass Webb, Kentucky."

"He killed two women about ten minutes from my house."

"He's is a true psychopath."

"I had never heard of him until my husband hired a new guy and the guy was on probation for helping Bass bury one of his victims."

"She was that guy's cousin!"

"My husband didn't know it at the time of hiring obviously."- lifeinthefastlane999

The Turpins

"Definitely the Turpins."- Different-Ad6190

Michelle Blair

"Michelle Blair from Detroit."- Illustrious_Boss2991

Luka Rocco Magnotta

"Luka Rocco Magnotta, and the worst part is that everyone is able to see the whole murder online with a simple research."- ganesh420ganesh

Mr. Hands

"Mr Hands."

"Mr Hands had a kink for f*cking horses."

"He broke into a stable and chose the biggest horse in the stables and f*cked it."

"I’m pretty sure he got internal damage from… well you know and died in the hospital."- grahamcracker007

The Burari Case

"Burari death case."

"If you know, you know."

"That sh*t was really F*cked up."- Classic_Blueberry404

Peter Scully

"Peter Scully."

"Just horrible."- m0thb4lls

What might make reading the work of James Patterson and others easy for some people to read is the fact that they know it's fiction, perhaps loosely inspired by actual events.

But learning more and more about horrific crimes which actually happened and could happen again is enough to permanently ruin any chances of sleeping.

More from Trending/best-of-reddit

Taylor Swift; Dolly Parton
Rich Polk/Billboard/Getty Images; The Recording Academy/Getty Images

Taylor Swift Dedicates Her VMA For Video Of The Year To 'Ultimate Showgirl' Dolly Parton In Moving Speech

Taylor Swift has been sweeping headlines in the past few weeks, between becoming a popular internet meme while cheering on her husband and releasing four new songs for a deluxe "Encore" edition of The Life of a Showgirl.

After appearing at the MTV VMAs and winning Video of the Year for her song, "The Fate of Ophelia," she's the talk of the town again, thanks to making a very special dedication.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Donald Trump
@atrupar/X

Trump Just Tried To Boast About America's 'Poverty'—And It Went Instantly South

Speaking ahead of a trip to Illinois to attend the 2026 Presidents Cup golf tournament, President Donald Trump bragged to reporters that the United States has the "best poverty," sparking immediate critcism.

Trump made the remark even as inflation remains above the level recorded when former President Joe Biden left office, economic growth has slowed, and the cost of filling a gas tank has surged roughly 50% since the war against Iran began.

Keep ReadingShow less
Screenshot of Nicki Minaj
Fox News

Nicki Minaj Dragged With Blunt Reminder After Her Plea To Young Voters On Fox News Takes A Decidedly MAGA Turn

Rapper Nicki Minaj was criticized after she encouraged Fox News viewers to exercise their right to vote before fully backing Republicans in November's midterm elections.

Minaj spoke with President Donald Trump's daughter-in-law, Lara Trump, during an appearance on the network to stress that if people "want a say in what happens, the only way to have that is by voting, not just voting for the president but voting in all local elections."

Keep ReadingShow less
Matt Gaetz; Screenshot of Robbie G. Smither
Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP via Getty Images

Matt Gaetz Epically Dragged After Begging Lifelong Florida Republican Not To Vote For Dems Who Want To 'Trans Your Kids'

Former Florida Republican Representative Matt Gaetz was widely mocked after he made a transphobic claim about Democrats in response to remarks from X user and lifelong Florida Republican Robbie G. Smither, who earlier shared a video about why he's voting Democrat for the first time in his life.

In his post, Smither criticized President Donald Trump when he announced that "when I vote for a Democrat, [Florida gubernatorial candidate David Jolly], for the first time in my 41 years of life this November, it will not be because my values have changed, but because my party has abandoned our values for the sycophancy of a transactional leader who has none."

Keep ReadingShow less
Oreo’s viral spelling joke sparks a hilarious response from Merriam-Webster.
Kevin Carter/Getty Images; Brandon Bell/Getty Images

Oreo Just Made A Hilariously False Claim About Their Name—And Merriam-Webster's Response Is All Of Us

Oreo versus Merriam-Webster? That's one feud nobody had on their 2026 bingo card. But apparently, all it takes to start a fight with the dictionary is one questionable spelling lesson.

The cookie chaos went down on September 21, when Oreo decided that an old AI blunder deserved a second chance at internet fame.

Keep ReadingShow less