A grieving mother who lost her daughter Lexi in the mass shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas, earlier this year denounced the school for recently dress-coding her other daughter who is a student there.
According to a screenshot of the voicemail transcript provided by Kimberly Mata-Rubio, a staff member from the school informed her that her 11-year-old daughter was sent to the principal's office for wearing ripped jeans that were deemed inappropriate due to them having cuts that went “a little too high up."
The staff member suggested the mother drop whatever she was doing to bring another pair of pants or leggings to the school for her daughter to wear under the torn jeans.
But Mata-Rubio was not willing to comply.
Instead, the grieving mother argued that the school should focus on other matters like security—something which could have prevented the shooting on May 24 in which nineteen students, including her late daughter Lexi, and two teachers were fatally shot, and left seventeen others wounded.
“One thing we’re not going to do is dress code my 11-year-old for some ripped jeans," she said in a tweet with a screenshot of the transcript.
"UCISD, focus on school security. Maybe, if you had, my daughter, her little sister would still be alive.”
\u201cOne thing we\u2019re not going to do is dress code my 11-year-old for some ripped jeans. UCISD, focus on school security. Maybe, if you had, my daughter, her little sister would still be alive.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
@kimrubio21/Twitter
The controversial policy of dress codes is usually prevalent in high schools.
It has often been labeled as "sexist" since it is typically aimed at female students who are required to cover up to avoid distracting male students in the classroom.
The fact that this particular instance of dress-coding at an elementary school—involving a traumatized mother and daughter—is particularly unsettling, and it polarized users in the thread.
Some agreed that schools need to prioritize education instead of instituting measures that sexualize children.
\u201c@wayneq_88 @kimrubio21 Sounds like you need to stop checking out your underaged students\u2026creeper vibes.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@kimrubio21 Had a (male) principal who ruled female teachers couldn't wear sandals without a back strap or open toe shoes. Huh?\nBut male teachers wore slides, flip flops with no probs\n\nOh, but let's not talk about the low test grade scores of the students and daily fights in the halls\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@kimrubio21 @ParkerKrex The cuts are a little too high up? Maybe they shouldn\u2019t being sexualizing her.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@kimrubio21 They should monitor themselves, hold accountable those who have failed to protect our children, cuts on jeans will definetely not hurt anybody \ud83d\ude21\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@tweetmommybop @kimrubio21 But, but,\u2026. those other kids could get so easily distracted by potential glimpses of skin!\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
Others, however, argued that children need to understand discipline and know that there are consequences for not obeying set rules.
\u201c@kimrubio21 What's wrong with just following the rules?\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@kimrubio21 I know this is harsh due to the circumstances, but dress codes exist. Not just at school but almost every job. If it's unfair that's one thing. But how many jobs are going to let you show up in ripped jeans? Not very many.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@kimrubio21 As a teacher, I can tell you that dress codes are important. There are girls in middle school who come in wearing clothing that shows bare midriffs, cuts that show their \u201ccheeks\u201d etc. it\u2019s not about self respect or making them conform, it\u2019s about decency.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
Some remained compassionate while making their case.
\u201c@kimrubio21 Respect for your feelings. \u2764\ufe0f for your loss\u2026\nDress code & other \u201clittle\u201d rules & being taught to respect & follow them contributes to an increased respect for rules, authority, and community. \nFixing the small stuff helps fix the big stuff down the line. \n\u262e\ufe0f , \u2764\ufe0f, blessings.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
\u201c@kimrubio21 I grew up in Utah & we had a dress code that we never questioned. We could wear shorts only on the last day of school, no exposed shoulders, etc. Absolutely, there are more important issues to address. This one simply teaches kids to follow rules & have self-respect.\u201d— Kimberly Mata-Rubio (@Kimberly Mata-Rubio) 1666795106
Here is Mata-Rubio and her husband remembering their late daughter in an interview.
'I left my baby at that school': Texas shooting victim’s mom feels guiltyoutu.be
As if their grief wasn't enough, the school imposing a strict dress code on their daughter seems a bit out of touch given the circumstances.
Obeying rules is definitely an important lesson to teach in school, yes.
But there could be a more effective way to place emphasis on education rather than punishing a traumatized girl based on what she is wearing—torn fabric notwithstanding.