AI-Generated Artwork Gets 1st At CO State Fair, Sparking Outrage: PHOTO

Home>
Trending>

        Artists Furious After AI-Generated Artwork Comes In First Place At Colorado State Fair Competition
    

        @Sincarnate/Discord
    
By Ben AcostaSep 06, 2022
Ben Acosta
Ben Acosta is an Arizona-based fiction author and freelance writer. In his free time, he critiques media and acts in local stage productions.
 See Full Bio 
Top Stories
AI Powered

        Neil DeGrasse Tyson Reveals Just How Convincing AI Deepfake Videos Have Gotten—And Yikes
    

        Trump Dragged After Firing Off Panicked Posts Blaming Everyone But Himself For GOP Losses On Election Night
    
A controversial first place winner in the Colorado State Fair’s fine arts competition has the internet debating the nature of art itself.
Jason Allen, the Colorado-based owner of a tabletop gaming company, Incarnate Games, decided to enter the digital art competition with a piece generated by an artificial intelligence system. The artwork, titled Théâtre D'opéra Spatial, came in first place at the fair.
But not everyone is thrilled with the idea.
@GenelJumalon/Twitter
In the above Tweet, artist Genel Jumalon shared a screenshot of Allen’s post on Discord talking about his win. Allen, going by the name Sincarnate on the chat app, explains how he used Midjourney, an artificial intelligence image generator, by fine tuning settings and a special prompt to generate hundreds of images. 
He then curated the selection down to three images and submitted them to the competition.
According to Jumalon:
“Yeah that’s pretty f**king sh**ty.”A lot of artists were not thrilled with the idea of competing against AI generated images.
I'm not against AI generated art as a tool, but this is not how it should be used, in my opinion. I think it's useful for developers to quickly create project assets such as concept art and backgrounds and such, but it shouldn't be used to push down traditional artists.
— Toybox (@asktoybox) August 31, 2022 

This is the literal definition of "pressed a few buttons to make a digital art piece" 
AI artwork is the 'banana taped to the wall' of the digital world now.
— 🎃 Saphire Shear🎃 (@SaphireShear) August 30, 2022 

\u201cNaw dawg, this ain't right.\n\nhttps://t.co/y7h7hyftYm\u201d
 — Rionotrowe (@Rionotrowe)
        1662419638
\u201c@The_Galactabee @GenelJumalon people like this only think of the monetary incentive, it was like that for nfts too\n\nthe "huge win" is being able to generate dozens of art pieces at once and selling them out to the highest bidder for insane profit\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@TransformARTive @GenelJumalon Gotta love how short lived the era of digital art being recognized and accepted by mainstream fine art venues lasted before literally being able to just press a button actually did come along\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@ichibanhomo @GenelJumalon Yes, but they went the extra effort to choose the best car and tune it. /s\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201cI know there's more important ethical considerations with the AI art that won the Colorado State Fair, but aesthetically, it looks just like every other AI generated artwork. Anyone who spends even 1 day on Midjourney would see hundreds of other images that look exactly the same.\u201d
 — Eric Hart (@Eric Hart)
        1662220310
Allen posted in the Discord channel for users of the Midjourney AI software. According to him, he fully expected the pushback from his win.
He said:
“I knew this would be controversial. How interesting is it to see how all these people on Twitter who are against AI-generated art are the first ones to throw the human under the bus by discrediting the human element!”Allen insists that the human element is essential, as he spent so much time shaping and curating the resulting images generated by Midjourney.
The situation led to debate online about the validity of Allen’s art win.
For the record, I think AI can be a useful tool for artists. The issue I have at hand is someone straight up taking full credit and in this case not properly informing the judges what Midjourney is.

Going forward AI art should have it's own category. pic.twitter.com/6qBzVkfeey
— Genel Jumalon ✈️ ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@GenelJumalon) September 1, 2022 

\u201c@kaseysaus @GenelJumalon It's actually super cool. The exploratory process and guidance by a human is really something unique.\n\nJust cause it's not your niche, doesn't mean it's the end of your world lol. \n\nIf anything, you should learn to utilize it - even if it's just for inspiration.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@GenelJumalon The AI is not a person, but the person who generated it by typing words into the AI is not an artist. They created nothing. At best, they collaborated. A collaboration they can take credit for because there\u2019s no human on the other end. This should not be allowed. It\u2019s terrible.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@luxidea @GenelJumalon if this were true then burning a painting would result in no loss because only the result would be destroyed, not the process. art history is fine, provenance is fine, but never mistake it for the value of art. a mysterious masterpiece has more value than a well-known mediocrity.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@cecurry @Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon If the person who generated the art made the AI themselves, that would be a fair analogy.\nWhat actually happened is the equivalent of using symbolab or wolfram alpha to solve that equation; *everything* was done by the computer after the initial prompt was given.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon The news article about it said he spent 80 hours trying different combinations of words and Photoshopping the result. He was in the digital edited photography section, so that's probably similar to or more than the expected commitment\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@miraka_r @GenelJumalon I just made this in literally 20 seconds.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
Allen labeled his piece with the notation that he created it with Midjourney, but the judges didn’t know what that meant. Cal Duran, one of the judges, says that after learning the process, still thinks the piece deserves the win.
“I think this art, it had a voice, you know. I think the artist that made it had a voice creating it.”As time moves on, art submissions and competitions will have to decide how they want to handle AI-generated art. The most commonly suggested solution will be for it to have its own category.
Latest News
Trending
        Mom Dragged For Melting Down Over Daughter's Puberty Lesson After Ignoring School's Permission Slip
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
1h
Political News
        Seth Meyers Responds To Trump's 'Truly Deranged' Personal Attack Against Him With Hilarious Takedown
    
Alan Herrera
1h
Political News
        Lauren Boebert Slammed After Photos Of Her Racist ICE-Theme Halloween Costume Emerge
    
Alan Herrera
2h
Political News
        MTG Just Admitted The Awkward Truth About The Republican Healthcare Plan On 'The View'
    
Alan Herrera
3h
Don’t Miss Out

      Join the
      ComicSands.com
      community and make your opinion matter.
    

The Top 5

Discover More

A controversial first place winner in the Colorado State Fair’s fine arts competition has the internet debating the nature of art itself.

Jason Allen, the Colorado-based owner of a tabletop gaming company, Incarnate Games, decided to enter the digital art competition with a piece generated by an artificial intelligence system. The artwork, titled Théâtre D'opéra Spatial, came in first place at the fair.

But not everyone is thrilled with the idea.

@GenelJumalon/Twitter

In the above Tweet, artist Genel Jumalon shared a screenshot of Allen’s post on Discord talking about his win. Allen, going by the name Sincarnate on the chat app, explains how he used Midjourney, an artificial intelligence image generator, by fine tuning settings and a special prompt to generate hundreds of images.

He then curated the selection down to three images and submitted them to the competition.

According to Jumalon:

“Yeah that’s pretty f**king sh**ty.”

A lot of artists were not thrilled with the idea of competing against AI generated images.

I'm not against AI generated art as a tool, but this is not how it should be used, in my opinion. I think it's useful for developers to quickly create project assets such as concept art and backgrounds and such, but it shouldn't be used to push down traditional artists.
— Toybox (@asktoybox) August 31, 2022

This is the literal definition of "pressed a few buttons to make a digital art piece"
AI artwork is the 'banana taped to the wall' of the digital world now.
— 🎃 Saphire Shear🎃 (@SaphireShear) August 30, 2022

\u201cNaw dawg, this ain't right.\n\nhttps://t.co/y7h7hyftYm\u201d
— Rionotrowe (@Rionotrowe) 1662419638

\u201c@The_Galactabee @GenelJumalon people like this only think of the monetary incentive, it was like that for nfts too\n\nthe "huge win" is being able to generate dozens of art pieces at once and selling them out to the highest bidder for insane profit\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@TransformARTive @GenelJumalon Gotta love how short lived the era of digital art being recognized and accepted by mainstream fine art venues lasted before literally being able to just press a button actually did come along\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@ichibanhomo @GenelJumalon Yes, but they went the extra effort to choose the best car and tune it. /s\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201cI know there's more important ethical considerations with the AI art that won the Colorado State Fair, but aesthetically, it looks just like every other AI generated artwork. Anyone who spends even 1 day on Midjourney would see hundreds of other images that look exactly the same.\u201d
— Eric Hart (@Eric Hart) 1662220310

Allen posted in the Discord channel for users of the Midjourney AI software. According to him, he fully expected the pushback from his win.

He said:

“I knew this would be controversial. How interesting is it to see how all these people on Twitter who are against AI-generated art are the first ones to throw the human under the bus by discrediting the human element!”

Allen insists that the human element is essential, as he spent so much time shaping and curating the resulting images generated by Midjourney.

The situation led to debate online about the validity of Allen’s art win.

For the record, I think AI can be a useful tool for artists. The issue I have at hand is someone straight up taking full credit and in this case not properly informing the judges what Midjourney is.

Going forward AI art should have it's own category. pic.twitter.com/6qBzVkfeey
— Genel Jumalon ✈️ ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@GenelJumalon) September 1, 2022

\u201c@kaseysaus @GenelJumalon It's actually super cool. The exploratory process and guidance by a human is really something unique.\n\nJust cause it's not your niche, doesn't mean it's the end of your world lol. \n\nIf anything, you should learn to utilize it - even if it's just for inspiration.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@GenelJumalon The AI is not a person, but the person who generated it by typing words into the AI is not an artist. They created nothing. At best, they collaborated. A collaboration they can take credit for because there\u2019s no human on the other end. This should not be allowed. It\u2019s terrible.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@luxidea @GenelJumalon if this were true then burning a painting would result in no loss because only the result would be destroyed, not the process. art history is fine, provenance is fine, but never mistake it for the value of art. a mysterious masterpiece has more value than a well-known mediocrity.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@cecurry @Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon If the person who generated the art made the AI themselves, that would be a fair analogy.\nWhat actually happened is the equivalent of using symbolab or wolfram alpha to solve that equation; *everything* was done by the computer after the initial prompt was given.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon The news article about it said he spent 80 hours trying different combinations of words and Photoshopping the result. He was in the digital edited photography section, so that's probably similar to or more than the expected commitment\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@miraka_r @GenelJumalon I just made this in literally 20 seconds.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

Allen labeled his piece with the notation that he created it with Midjourney, but the judges didn’t know what that meant. Cal Duran, one of the judges, says that after learning the process, still thinks the piece deserves the win.

“I think this art, it had a voice, you know. I think the artist that made it had a voice creating it.”

As time moves on, art submissions and competitions will have to decide how they want to handle AI-generated art. The most commonly suggested solution will be for it to have its own category.

Related Articles Around the Web

More from Trending

        Kajetan Sumila on Unsplash
    

        People Share The Best Ways To Shut Down A Debate With A Flat Earther Family Member
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
Nov 05, 2025
The Flat Earth conspiracy theory is strictly a modern online movement, rumored to have begun as a prank, that gained momentum among people who mistrust authority through the power of social media.
 There is a persistent myth that Europeans in the Middle Ages believed the Earth was flat. But that is a 19th-century fabrication to sell Columbus Day, not historical reality.
Keep ReadingShow less
Most Read
Political News
        Don Jr. Called Out By His Former Mistress After He Tried To Slam Chelsea Clinton Over Ballroom Comments
    
Alan Herrera
29 October
Trending
        Bride Calls Out Her Trump Loving Dad For Wearing His MAGA Hat During Wedding Speech
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
29 October
Political News
        Gavin Newsom Expertly Trolls Trump Administration With Parody Spirit Halloween Costume Memes
    
Alan Herrera
03 November
Political News
        Blue States Are Taking A Page Out Of Trump's Playbook With Alerts About SNAP Benefits
    
Alan Herrera
03 November
Political News
        J.D. Vance Faces Backlash After Saying He Hopes His Wife Usha Will Be 'Moved' To Convert To Christianity
    
Alan Herrera
31 October

        NDZ/Star Max/GC Images/Getty Images; Samuel Corum/Getty Images
    

        Nicki Minaj Pushes Back After She's Called Out For Praising Trump's Threat To Nigeria Over Christian Persecution
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
Nov 04, 2025
In his latest round of flinging things at the wall to see what will stick—to distract his base from the Epstein Files, his obvious cognitive decline, the mockery of the United States by the world, and the Republican government shutdown—MAGA Republican President Donald Trump unleashed selective outrage over a Nigerian internal matter on Truth Social.
On Friday afternoon, Trump posted:
Keep ReadingShow less
Phillip Faraone/Getty Images for Teen Vogue

        Elon Musk's Trans Daughter Just Hilariously Fired Back At A Troll Who Asked To Hear Her 'Real Voice'
    
Morgan Allison Ross
Nov 04, 2025
Elon Musk’s daughter, Vivian Wilson, has once again reminded the internet that she’s not here for anyone’s transphobic nonsense, and she’ll roast you with flair if you try it.
The 21-year-old, one of five children Musk shares with Canadian author Justine Wilson, hails from the tech mogul’s first family—alongside her twin brother Griffin and triplets Kai, Saxon, and Damian.
Keep ReadingShow less

        @wickedmovie/Twitter (X); Taylor Hill/WireImage/Getty Images; @wickedmovie/Twitter (X)
    

        Jonathan Bailey's 'Wicked' Castmates Congratulate Him On Being Named 'Sexiest Man Alive' With Sweet Video
    
McKenzie Lynn Tozan
Nov 04, 2025
Hear ye, hear ye! People magazine has spoken, and Wicked star Jonathan Bailey made history on Monday as the first openly gay man to be named their "Sexiest Man Alive" for 2025.
Whether he's the charming Fiyero destined to become a scarecrow in Wicked: For Good or wooing maidens as the eldest Bridgerton brother, Jonathan Bailey is nothing short of a rare find, much like an antidote straight out of Jurassic World: Rebirth.
Keep ReadingShow less

        Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images
    

        Nancy Mace Ripped After Throwing Massive Tantrum Over Lack Of Police Protection At Airport
    
Alan Herrera
Nov 04, 2025
South Carolina Republican Representative Nancy Mace is facing heated criticism after she threw a tantrum and accused airport police in Charleston, South Carolina, of not showing up to protect her ahead of an early morning flight after she allegedly arrived late and at the wrong gate.
Airport police had arranged for Mace, who is also a Republican candidate in the South Carolina governor’s race, to be escorted to her flight upon arrival. However, a mix-up over which vehicle she was traveling in led to confusion, according to an incident report. Officers later found Mace attempting to enter through a doorway typically reserved for flight crew at a TSA security checkpoint.
Keep ReadingShow less
Load More

Coca-Cola Defends Decision To Use AI To Make New Holiday Commercial After Backlash

Artists Furious After AI-Generated Artwork Comes In First Place At Colorado State Fair Competition

Neil DeGrasse Tyson Reveals Just How Convincing AI Deepfake Videos Have Gotten—And Yikes

Latest News

Mom Dragged For Melting Down Over Daughter's Puberty Lesson After Ignoring School's Permission Slip

Lauren Boebert Slammed After Photos Of Her Racist ICE-Theme Halloween Costume Emerge

MTG Just Admitted The Awkward Truth About The Republican Healthcare Plan On 'The View'

The Top 5

Gavin Newsom Trolls Trump With Brutally Accurate New Nickname—And The Internet Brings The Jokes

White House Lashes Out Over Clip Of Trump Being Led Around By Japan PM—But The Full Video Is Even Worse

'The Daily Show' Transforms Video Of Trump Being Led Around By Japan's PM Into Dog Show Parody—And It Is Brutal

Democratic Senator Trolls Trump With Hilariously Petty Idea For What To Name Trump's Ballroom When He Leaves Office

Melania Trump's White House Halloween Decorations Spark Backlash Amid Government Shutdown

Discover More

More from Trending

People Share The Best Ways To Shut Down A Debate With A Flat Earther Family Member

Don't Bother

Pick Me!

Map It Out

Edgy

Why?

The Matrix

Look Up

Defining Moment

Out Crazy

Just Don't

Yes, And...

Historical Reference

Very Punny

Do Not Engage

Questions

Most Read

Don Jr. Called Out By His Former Mistress After He Tried To Slam Chelsea Clinton Over Ballroom Comments

Bride Calls Out Her Trump Loving Dad For Wearing His MAGA Hat During Wedding Speech

Gavin Newsom Expertly Trolls Trump Administration With Parody Spirit Halloween Costume Memes

Blue States Are Taking A Page Out Of Trump's Playbook With Alerts About SNAP Benefits

J.D. Vance Faces Backlash After Saying He Hopes His Wife Usha Will Be 'Moved' To Convert To Christianity

Elon Musk's Trans Daughter Just Hilariously Fired Back At A Troll Who Asked To Hear Her 'Real Voice'

Jonathan Bailey's 'Wicked' Castmates Congratulate Him On Being Named 'Sexiest Man Alive' With Sweet Video

Nancy Mace Ripped After Throwing Massive Tantrum Over Lack Of Police Protection At Airport