AI-Generated Artwork Gets 1st At CO State Fair, Sparking Outrage: PHOTO

Home>
Trending>

        Artists Furious After AI-Generated Artwork Comes In First Place At Colorado State Fair Competition
    

        @Sincarnate/Discord
    
By Ben AcostaSep 06, 2022
Ben Acosta
Ben Acosta is an Arizona-based fiction author and freelance writer. In his free time, he critiques media and acts in local stage productions.
 See Full Bio 
Top Stories
AI Powered

        American Men Are Flocking To Get Breast Reduction Surgery—And Everyone's Making The Same Powerful Point
    

        Someone Asked Grok To Grade The Oklahoma Student's Bible-Based Essay—And Cue The MAGA Outrage
    
A controversial first place winner in the Colorado State Fair’s fine arts competition has the internet debating the nature of art itself.
Jason Allen, the Colorado-based owner of a tabletop gaming company, Incarnate Games, decided to enter the digital art competition with a piece generated by an artificial intelligence system. The artwork, titled Théâtre D'opéra Spatial, came in first place at the fair.
But not everyone is thrilled with the idea.
@GenelJumalon/Twitter
In the above Tweet, artist Genel Jumalon shared a screenshot of Allen’s post on Discord talking about his win. Allen, going by the name Sincarnate on the chat app, explains how he used Midjourney, an artificial intelligence image generator, by fine tuning settings and a special prompt to generate hundreds of images. 
He then curated the selection down to three images and submitted them to the competition.
According to Jumalon:
“Yeah that’s pretty f**king sh**ty.”A lot of artists were not thrilled with the idea of competing against AI generated images.
I'm not against AI generated art as a tool, but this is not how it should be used, in my opinion. I think it's useful for developers to quickly create project assets such as concept art and backgrounds and such, but it shouldn't be used to push down traditional artists.
— Toybox (@asktoybox) August 31, 2022 

This is the literal definition of "pressed a few buttons to make a digital art piece" 
AI artwork is the 'banana taped to the wall' of the digital world now.
— 🎃 Saphire Shear🎃 (@SaphireShear) August 30, 2022 

\u201cNaw dawg, this ain't right.\n\nhttps://t.co/y7h7hyftYm\u201d
 — Rionotrowe (@Rionotrowe)
        1662419638
\u201c@The_Galactabee @GenelJumalon people like this only think of the monetary incentive, it was like that for nfts too\n\nthe "huge win" is being able to generate dozens of art pieces at once and selling them out to the highest bidder for insane profit\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@TransformARTive @GenelJumalon Gotta love how short lived the era of digital art being recognized and accepted by mainstream fine art venues lasted before literally being able to just press a button actually did come along\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@ichibanhomo @GenelJumalon Yes, but they went the extra effort to choose the best car and tune it. /s\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201cI know there's more important ethical considerations with the AI art that won the Colorado State Fair, but aesthetically, it looks just like every other AI generated artwork. Anyone who spends even 1 day on Midjourney would see hundreds of other images that look exactly the same.\u201d
 — Eric Hart (@Eric Hart)
        1662220310
Allen posted in the Discord channel for users of the Midjourney AI software. According to him, he fully expected the pushback from his win.
He said:
“I knew this would be controversial. How interesting is it to see how all these people on Twitter who are against AI-generated art are the first ones to throw the human under the bus by discrediting the human element!”Allen insists that the human element is essential, as he spent so much time shaping and curating the resulting images generated by Midjourney.
The situation led to debate online about the validity of Allen’s art win.
For the record, I think AI can be a useful tool for artists. The issue I have at hand is someone straight up taking full credit and in this case not properly informing the judges what Midjourney is.

Going forward AI art should have it's own category. pic.twitter.com/6qBzVkfeey
— Genel Jumalon ✈️ ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@GenelJumalon) September 1, 2022 

\u201c@kaseysaus @GenelJumalon It's actually super cool. The exploratory process and guidance by a human is really something unique.\n\nJust cause it's not your niche, doesn't mean it's the end of your world lol. \n\nIf anything, you should learn to utilize it - even if it's just for inspiration.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@GenelJumalon The AI is not a person, but the person who generated it by typing words into the AI is not an artist. They created nothing. At best, they collaborated. A collaboration they can take credit for because there\u2019s no human on the other end. This should not be allowed. It\u2019s terrible.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@luxidea @GenelJumalon if this were true then burning a painting would result in no loss because only the result would be destroyed, not the process. art history is fine, provenance is fine, but never mistake it for the value of art. a mysterious masterpiece has more value than a well-known mediocrity.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@cecurry @Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon If the person who generated the art made the AI themselves, that would be a fair analogy.\nWhat actually happened is the equivalent of using symbolab or wolfram alpha to solve that equation; *everything* was done by the computer after the initial prompt was given.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon The news article about it said he spent 80 hours trying different combinations of words and Photoshopping the result. He was in the digital edited photography section, so that's probably similar to or more than the expected commitment\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
\u201c@miraka_r @GenelJumalon I just made this in literally 20 seconds.\u201d
 — Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls)
        1661876994
Allen labeled his piece with the notation that he created it with Midjourney, but the judges didn’t know what that meant. Cal Duran, one of the judges, says that after learning the process, still thinks the piece deserves the win.
“I think this art, it had a voice, you know. I think the artist that made it had a voice creating it.”As time moves on, art submissions and competitions will have to decide how they want to handle AI-generated art. The most commonly suggested solution will be for it to have its own category.
Latest News
Political News
        Gavin Newsom Just Hilariously Trolled President Trump's New 'Walk Of Fame' With A Brutal One Of His Own
    
Alan Herrera
05 December
Political News
        The OU Student Who Got A Zero On Her Bible-Based Essay Was Just Honored By Republicans—Because Of Course
    
Alan Herrera
05 December
Political News
        Clip Of Trump Mocking Pete Buttigieg As His Cronies Laugh Feels Like It's Straight Out Of 'Austin Powers'
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
05 December
Political News
        Prince Harry Just Took A Hilariously Brutal Jab At Trump During Surprise Appearance On 'Colbert'
    
Alan Herrera
05 December
Don’t Miss Out

      Join the
      ComicSands.com
      community and make your opinion matter.
    

The Top 5

Discover More

A controversial first place winner in the Colorado State Fair’s fine arts competition has the internet debating the nature of art itself.

Jason Allen, the Colorado-based owner of a tabletop gaming company, Incarnate Games, decided to enter the digital art competition with a piece generated by an artificial intelligence system. The artwork, titled Théâtre D'opéra Spatial, came in first place at the fair.

But not everyone is thrilled with the idea.

@GenelJumalon/Twitter

In the above Tweet, artist Genel Jumalon shared a screenshot of Allen’s post on Discord talking about his win. Allen, going by the name Sincarnate on the chat app, explains how he used Midjourney, an artificial intelligence image generator, by fine tuning settings and a special prompt to generate hundreds of images.

He then curated the selection down to three images and submitted them to the competition.

According to Jumalon:

“Yeah that’s pretty f**king sh**ty.”

A lot of artists were not thrilled with the idea of competing against AI generated images.

I'm not against AI generated art as a tool, but this is not how it should be used, in my opinion. I think it's useful for developers to quickly create project assets such as concept art and backgrounds and such, but it shouldn't be used to push down traditional artists.
— Toybox (@asktoybox) August 31, 2022

This is the literal definition of "pressed a few buttons to make a digital art piece"
AI artwork is the 'banana taped to the wall' of the digital world now.
— 🎃 Saphire Shear🎃 (@SaphireShear) August 30, 2022

\u201cNaw dawg, this ain't right.\n\nhttps://t.co/y7h7hyftYm\u201d
— Rionotrowe (@Rionotrowe) 1662419638

\u201c@The_Galactabee @GenelJumalon people like this only think of the monetary incentive, it was like that for nfts too\n\nthe "huge win" is being able to generate dozens of art pieces at once and selling them out to the highest bidder for insane profit\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@TransformARTive @GenelJumalon Gotta love how short lived the era of digital art being recognized and accepted by mainstream fine art venues lasted before literally being able to just press a button actually did come along\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@ichibanhomo @GenelJumalon Yes, but they went the extra effort to choose the best car and tune it. /s\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201cI know there's more important ethical considerations with the AI art that won the Colorado State Fair, but aesthetically, it looks just like every other AI generated artwork. Anyone who spends even 1 day on Midjourney would see hundreds of other images that look exactly the same.\u201d
— Eric Hart (@Eric Hart) 1662220310

Allen posted in the Discord channel for users of the Midjourney AI software. According to him, he fully expected the pushback from his win.

He said:

“I knew this would be controversial. How interesting is it to see how all these people on Twitter who are against AI-generated art are the first ones to throw the human under the bus by discrediting the human element!”

Allen insists that the human element is essential, as he spent so much time shaping and curating the resulting images generated by Midjourney.

The situation led to debate online about the validity of Allen’s art win.

For the record, I think AI can be a useful tool for artists. The issue I have at hand is someone straight up taking full credit and in this case not properly informing the judges what Midjourney is.

Going forward AI art should have it's own category. pic.twitter.com/6qBzVkfeey
— Genel Jumalon ✈️ ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@GenelJumalon) September 1, 2022

\u201c@kaseysaus @GenelJumalon It's actually super cool. The exploratory process and guidance by a human is really something unique.\n\nJust cause it's not your niche, doesn't mean it's the end of your world lol. \n\nIf anything, you should learn to utilize it - even if it's just for inspiration.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@GenelJumalon The AI is not a person, but the person who generated it by typing words into the AI is not an artist. They created nothing. At best, they collaborated. A collaboration they can take credit for because there\u2019s no human on the other end. This should not be allowed. It\u2019s terrible.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@luxidea @GenelJumalon if this were true then burning a painting would result in no loss because only the result would be destroyed, not the process. art history is fine, provenance is fine, but never mistake it for the value of art. a mysterious masterpiece has more value than a well-known mediocrity.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@cecurry @Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon If the person who generated the art made the AI themselves, that would be a fair analogy.\nWhat actually happened is the equivalent of using symbolab or wolfram alpha to solve that equation; *everything* was done by the computer after the initial prompt was given.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@Sanguiphilia @GenelJumalon The news article about it said he spent 80 hours trying different combinations of words and Photoshopping the result. He was in the digital edited photography section, so that's probably similar to or more than the expected commitment\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

\u201c@miraka_r @GenelJumalon I just made this in literally 20 seconds.\u201d
— Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls (@Genel Jumalon \u2708\ufe0f ARTapalooza Cedar Falls) 1661876994

Allen labeled his piece with the notation that he created it with Midjourney, but the judges didn’t know what that meant. Cal Duran, one of the judges, says that after learning the process, still thinks the piece deserves the win.

“I think this art, it had a voice, you know. I think the artist that made it had a voice creating it.”

As time moves on, art submissions and competitions will have to decide how they want to handle AI-generated art. The most commonly suggested solution will be for it to have its own category.

Related Articles Around the Web

More from Trending

        @atrupar/X
    

        Trump Dragged After Making Ridiculous Claim About Randomly Finding Billions On The 'Tariff Shelf'
    
Alan Herrera
Dec 05, 2025
President Donald Trump was criticized after he claimed to reporters this week that officials in his administration suddenly found $30 billion they "never knew existed"—located on what Trump referred to as the "tariff shelf."
Tariffs are a tax on imported goods, usually calculated as a percentage of the purchase price. While tariffs can shield domestic manufacturers by making foreign products more expensive, they are also used as a tool to penalize countries engaged in unfair trade practices, such as government subsidies or dumping goods below market value.
Keep ReadingShow less
Most Read
Political News
        Vivek Ramaswamy's Controversial Solution For How To Make Parenting 'More Affordable' Is Not Going Over Well
    
Alan Herrera
01 December
Political News
        Pete Hegseth Roasted After His Placard At Cabinet Meeting Includes Hilariously Fitting Typo
    
Alan Herrera
04 December
Political News
        Jeffrey Epstein's Brother Reveals Infuriating Theory For Why Trump Reversed Course On Releasing The Epstein Files
    
Alan Herrera
18 November
Political News
        MAGA Senator Offers Absurd Defense Of Trump After Mark Kelly Calls Out His Racist Rhetoric
    
Alan Herrera
01 December
Political News
        Trump Just Epically Threw JD Vance Under The Bus While Trying To Insult Tim Walz—And Yikes!
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
03 December

        Katie Smith on Unsplash
    

        Professional Chefs Share The Top Mistakes Average Home Cooks Make
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
Dec 05, 2025
With the expansion of cable television and then streaming services, a number of competition shows featuring amateur home cooks. Shows like Master Chef and The Great British Bake Off garnered huge followings and spawned numerous global and domestic spin-offs.
The food produced by these amateurs is beyond the talents of even some professional chefs. But what about the average home cook? What can they learn from the professionals?
Keep ReadingShow less

        ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS/AFP via Getty Images
    

        RFK Jr.'s HHS Blasted As CDC Panel Considers Dropping Life-Saving Hepatitis B Vaccine For Newborns
    
Amelia Mavis Christnot
Dec 04, 2025
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's vaccine advisory panel, the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), met Thursday for the first of two days of discussions about childhood vaccine schedules and recommendations.
The panel focused on the hepatitis B vaccine and plans to vote on Friday whether to continue recommending it be given to all children at birth or to recommend something entirely different. The panel previously tabled making a decision on infant and early childhood hep-B vaccination in September.
Keep ReadingShow less

        @monicasanluiss/TikTok
    

        Bride's Friends Surprise Her With Montage Video Of All Her Exes At Bachelorette Party—And People Are Mortified
    
McKenzie Lynn Tozan
Dec 04, 2025
While Jenny Han's novel To All the Boys I've Loved Before was a major hit, and even became a great film success in 2018, not everyone's married to the idea of reconnecting with their exes after the relationships end.
It might be nice to imagine staying friends after the relationships, imagining our exes missing us or regretting losing us, or even giving us an apology for the things they did wrong. But most of us pine for this for a little while, realize it's all a fairy tale, and push past it to better things and new love.
Keep ReadingShow less

        @alexamcnee/TikTok
    

        TikToker Sparks Debate After Calling Out Driver's Extremely Bright Headlights For Blinding Her
    
McKenzie Lynn Tozan
Dec 04, 2025
Whether we are drivers or passengers, we've all experienced that annoying, possibly painful moment of feeling like we're being blinded by a fellow driver whose headlights are far too bright for a standard car on a standard road.
But while most of us complain about it to ourselves and leave it at that, TikToker Alexa McNee stepped up for all of us and called it out.
Keep ReadingShow less
Load More

Latest Stories

Start your day right!

Artists Furious After AI-Generated Artwork Comes In First Place At Colorado State Fair Competition

Latest News

Don’t Miss Out

More from Trending

Most Read

Browning

Sharpening

Common Sense

Salt, Acid, Fat, Heat

Scraping

Tasting

Gadgets

Preheating/Overheating

Mistakes

Pastry

Amateur Advice

Practicing

Caramelizing

Simplicity

Baking